I believe Subaru have lost the Evo/Impreza war by a mile.
I believe Subaru have lost the Evo/Impreza war by a mile.
Author
Discussion

Acheron

Original Poster:

643 posts

185 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Not only did they take forever to make a Sedan of the Impreza, it looks very 'meh' when compared to the Evo.
http://www.subaru.com.au/models/impreza/r/sedan/ex...

Conor D

2,124 posts

196 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
That's not the Impreza WRX/STI it's the R.



Looks a bit better, no?

Thorburn

2,422 posts

214 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Acheron said:
Not only did they take forever to make a Sedan of the Impreza, it looks very 'meh' when compared to the Evo.
http://www.subaru.com.au/models/impreza/r/sedan/ex...
I'm not sure that's really aimed at competing with the Evo, given that it has 150bhp and comes with 16" steel wheels.

Acheron

Original Poster:

643 posts

185 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Conor D said:
That's not the Impreza WRX/STI it's the R.



Looks a bit better, no?
I suppose thats the one i should have posted yeah, but compared to an Evox... Meh.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

219 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Acheron said:
Conor D said:
That's not the Impreza WRX/STI it's the R.



Looks a bit better, no?
I suppose thats the one i should have posted yeah, but compared to an Evox... Meh.
I actually prefer that to the X TBH. That said it I think it looks like a VII-IX with the new scooby nose grafted on.

DanGPR

991 posts

192 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Always prefered the evo to the scooby, but historically, the Mitsi has always been a fair bit mre expensive, so although the cars are in the same vein, it's not really apples for apples...

martin mrt

3,878 posts

222 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
I think the hatch Impreza is a fine looking car, far better than the Evo 10 and the Impreza Saloon.

The Evo 10 is a vile looking contraption

Dr Derek Doctors

8,422 posts

214 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Wow this topic is really going to bring out the claws of the EVO/Impreza nerd zealots.

If you prefer the Impreza buy an Impreza and if you prefer the Evo buy an Evo.

daemon

38,404 posts

218 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Personally, i think they've both lost. I think both brands are very out of touch with what buyers these days want.

The the value of the £ against the yen has priced them out of the market. £32995 for an STi - really??? Three years ago they were £26495.



Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

211 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
I know this sounds a little odd given they're in the same car niche but has the Impreza ever really directly competed with the EVO?

I mean the EVO has pretty consistently outgunned the Impreza (and many variants) in turns of outright performance but the Subaru has always offered a slightly more sane, charismatic (flat four) and cheaper alternative to the EVO.

In my opinion, it still does this. Infact the new Impreza hatchback is probably the first one I would be tempted by because to me it seems like a car that would be easy to live with and offers 9/10ths of the performance.

If the baseball cap parade don't like them anymore then all the better.






al1991

4,552 posts

201 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
The Evo will always be the winner for me.

GarryA

4,700 posts

185 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
It stopped here for me.....




daemon

38,404 posts

218 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Dr Derek Doctors said:
Wow this topic is really going to bring out the claws of the EVO/Impreza nerd zealots.

If you prefer the Impreza buy an Impreza and if you prefer the Evo buy an Evo.
+1

I've come very close to buying a new Sti back in '07, however i wouldnt have had an Evo.

My wife has a 2010 scooby WRX-S at the minute and the only think she'd change it to is an STi.

No doubt EVO people will have their opinions too.

It just is what it is. Each to their own.

Edited by daemon on Saturday 4th December 21:39

sn00per

79 posts

181 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
GarryA said:
It stopped here for me.....

+1 the classic Impreza for me is by far the best looking of all Impreza's. The 'frog eye' model following it was disgusting, then the 02-05 versions were decent, but from 06 it went very downhill. Starting with one which had a grille like a Seat in 06 to the latest shape which is a disgrace IMHO, looks like a unwanted bd lovechild of a Rover 25, Focus & a Proton. vomit

STW2010

5,887 posts

183 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Dr Derek Doctors said:
If you prefer the Impreza buy an Impreza and if you prefer the Evo buy an Evo.
And the award for the 'Most obvious statement of the year' goes to....

TXWRX

312 posts

189 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
I do like the evo 6 i must admit, the classic scooby, i'm a subaru fan but i think its aged worse than the evo although that may not be helped by some of the owners, rare you see a good clean classic and it looks very dated now

I think the evo's as standard have always had a bit more power been a bit stiffer and cost a bit more, if i remember when i was looking at things they were also even worse than the subaru to insure, to me they are a bit soulless compared to the scoob, that said given the right circumstances i could see myself getting one for a while and a lot of people on scoobynet and the mlr seem to have both at different times

alolympic

700 posts

218 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
These cars about the driving, no?
Test drive an STi and then come back with an informed opinion about the car. It's not a fashion accessary after all.

R1 Loon

26,988 posts

198 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
daemon said:
Dr Derek Doctors said:
Wow this topic is really going to bring out the claws of the EVO/Impreza nerd zealots.

If you prefer the Impreza buy an Impreza and if you prefer the Evo buy an Evo.
+1

I've come very close to buying a new Sti back in '07, however i wouldnt have had an Evo.

My wife has a 2010 scooby WRX-S at the minute and the only think she'd change it to is an STi.

No doubt EVO people will have their opinions too.

It just is what it is. Each to their own.

Edited by daemon on Saturday 4th December 21:39
I bought my wife the WRX STi something last year, that had been breathed on by ProDrive. It's by far and away the most fun I've had on the roads in years in a car and I've had 911s, RS4s and M3s.

Conor D

2,124 posts

196 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
I think the hatch Impreza is a fine looking car, far better than the Evo 10 and the Impreza Saloon.
This.

Some of the Hatchback Imprezas look incredible! I'd have the sound of the Impreza over the Evo any day.

Gwagon111

4,422 posts

182 months

Saturday 4th December 2010
quotequote all
Subaru have right royaly dropped the ball. The WRX STI saloon is priced at a scarcely believable 33000 pounds. This doesn't take into account the 950 quid first year VED, and doesn't include options like a rear wing or PPP. the equivalent Evo X is 25000 quid. Even the far quicker, far better Evo FQ 330 can be had for 30000 quid. If you pay Mitsubishi a few hundred quid you get the first three years servicing for free. Subaru have quite clearly gone mental, thinking they can charge between three, and eight thousand quid for a car which is not as good as the Evo. Completely stark raving bonkers.

Edited by Gwagon111 on Saturday 4th December 22:42