Help Me Decide Which One.........(pse)
Help Me Decide Which One.........(pse)
Author
Discussion

Footiestar

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Sunday 9th January 2011
quotequote all
Hey guys,

About to part company with my Subaru Impreza WRX (Hawkeye) as altough its good fun the body of the car feels as though its made of tin. I'm believe the newwer shape Hatchbacks are a bit more sturdy, and plan to choose between this and 3 other cars.

2005 X5 (3.0 Diesel)
2005 M3
2005 S4
2008 Impreza STI

Appreciate they are all different cars (especially the X5) but would really value some input, at least to get it down to best 2 and I will test drive them.

My driving needs - travel about 90 miles each day in car which is mostly motorway, but the one I choose should be fun but also decent in all weather as I need to drive even if icy/snow if it hits sunny Scotland!!!!

If anyone is in the know of these cars I'd really appreciate your input as can't decide which one.........

Cheers.

beemarman

180 posts

250 months

Thursday 13th January 2011
quotequote all
For me the X5 just to save money on fuel. Compared to your old car I would go for the M3.

The Audi would consume more fuel than the others on your list. The M3 would be my choice.

Tommo 87

86 posts

180 months

Thursday 13th January 2011
quotequote all
Footiestar said:
Hey guys,

About to part company with my Subaru Impreza WRX (Hawkeye) as altough its good fun the body of the car feels as though its made of tin. I'm believe the newwer shape Hatchbacks are a bit more sturdy, and plan to choose between this and 3 other cars.

2005 X5 (3.0 Diesel)
2005 M3
2005 S4
2008 Impreza STI

Appreciate they are all different cars (especially the X5) but would really value some input, at least to get it down to best 2 and I will test drive them.

My driving needs - travel about 90 miles each day in car which is mostly motorway, but the one I choose should be fun but also decent in all weather as I need to drive even if icy/snow if it hits sunny Scotland!!!!

If anyone is in the know of these cars I'd really appreciate your input as can't decide which one.........

Cheers.
Would be the STI for me, although a 335d could be a good option.

Footiestar

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Thursday 13th January 2011
quotequote all
cheers guys for those replies.

yes the X5 would be best for fuel and defo great just now (snow/ice) but unsure if it will excite me come summer......maybe yes as isn't a slouch.

335d is defo one I considered and got some nice one's within my budget.

Have a a test drive arranged of X5 and STi 08 plate with PPP next Saturday.....here's hoping one feels right.

Cheers.

Tommo 87

86 posts

180 months

Thursday 13th January 2011
quotequote all
Footiestar said:
cheers guys for those replies.

yes the X5 would be best for fuel and defo great just now (snow/ice) but unsure if it will excite me come summer......maybe yes as isn't a slouch.

335d is defo one I considered and got some nice one's within my budget.

Have a a test drive arranged of X5 and STi 08 plate with PPP next Saturday.....here's hoping one feels right.

Cheers.
I can feel the purchase of a Prodrive coming on wink
Good luck with that mate.

Tommo

Footiestar

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Thursday 13th January 2011
quotequote all
LOL - you must be the same mind reader as my mrs, as I'm sure that was her reply when I told her tonight.

Cheers.