How much is my car worth?
How much is my car worth?
Author
Discussion

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Hello folks,

I've decided to sell my E36 325i due to a fairly long commute and fuel prices being on the rise. I'm just not entirely sure what it's worth.

It's done almost 183000 miles and I paid £600 for it about two and a half months ago, but since then I've spent a few hundred pounds replacing the cooling system in its entirety and the alternator. It drives faultlessly but people are obviously going to be put off by the mileage.

I currently have it advertised at £950 in a few places and realistically I'd expect someone to haggle down to £850, but all I seem to be getting from people is "it's only worth £500 with those miles".

Please note that this isn't a for sale thread and that I wasn't looking to make a quick buck from it (I'm actually losing a bit based on the asking price); I just want a little bit of confirmation that the amount I'm expecting for it isn't unreasonable as I'll be sorely upset if it transpires that it really is only worth £500. Some truly shoddy looking examples seem to be on the market for more than this.

Thanks in advance,
Adam.

Sour Kraut

45,899 posts

219 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
I'd say £500 is right on the money for a leggy, non Sport 4-door. I'd want a year's MOT too.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Define "leggy". Do you just mean high mileage, irrespective of how well it drives/has been maintained?

Sour Kraut

45,899 posts

219 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
It's old and it has done a lot of miles. For every part which has been replaced there are another dozen which haven't.

You've only had it a month and it's caused you plenty of problems; frankly I'd either keep it to earn some use from the investment you've put into it recently or start a 99p auction on eBay and be grateful for the highest bid.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Two months, and two relatively minor problems. This, in my view, is not a bad ownership experience.

It's a shame that people can't see past the miles but never mind I suppose.

playerone

872 posts

240 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
2 Wycked said:
Some truly shoddy looking examples seem to be on the market for more than this.
You are confusing asking and selling. I can ask anything I like for a car but it doesn't mean I will sell it.

You are expecting to get more than you paid for a car. Why?

GBB

1,737 posts

189 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
What condition is the bodywork/interior in?

I've got a 97 328 Coupe Auto which is close to excellent for both (having just had rear arches done) but with the miles on it 188K probably next to worthless at the moment.

It might be worth £1,000 to someone who really wants a nice 328 and isn't prepared to travel but with so much other stuff out there I can't see me selling quickly for more than £500.

At that value it's not worth selling so I'm holding onto it until the gearbox goes (no sign of it yet but they do go eventually). The way I work it, any extra petrol costs are balanced by zero depreciation now, and it gets 30mpg+ if I stick around the limit on the motorway so not too much worse than most stuff.

If you do want to sell it I'd drive around with a notice in the window, assuming it's good condition - you might find a non clued up buyer who doesn't baulk at the price - on pistonheads and Autotrader most people are fairly clued up on values and what you can get for your money.

dan101smith

17,053 posts

241 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
When you bought it did you know about the problems with the cooling system and alternator?

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
The bodywork's good, but not immaculate. I've opted to keep it and grin and bare the fuel consumption irrespective of how the other half feels about it.

I had planned on replacing certain things just to proof it against failure when I bought it, yes. The alternator failed during the first week of ownership.

JonyPI

2,579 posts

219 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
Im in the same boat, these cars just arnt worth anything at the moment, be fine once the chavs have had their way and destroying most of them, they will find their value again, Ive had mine for a couple of years, has done 160k odd and all I have had to do was the propshaft donut, had a thorough going over by a garage a few months back as one of my employees was going to have it off me and it came back with pretty much nothing up with it.

for a car with as much history as a 30yr old grandma, LSD, Full black mint sports interior, rustfree 325i I too would probably be looking at 500quid but I would get that almost just for the interior if I broke it! so just not worth selling and sits in storage, too nicer car to break!



dan101smith

17,053 posts

241 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
JonyPI said:
...but I would get that almost just for the interior if I broke it!
Unless you've got an electric Vader interior in mint condition, no you wouldn't.

JonyPI

2,579 posts

219 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
dan101smith said:
JonyPI said:
...but I would get that almost just for the interior if I broke it!
Unless you've got an electric Vader interior in mint condition, no you wouldn't.
no just mint black sports leather, couple that with black headlining and black carpet and also original mats, I would make that about 500 (getting good prices for each obviously)

I will add that this is going by prices from when I broke a 328i quite a while ago, prices may have changed and if so, I'll throw the wheels in aswell biggrinlaugh

ETA nope I wasnt far off even with just the seats! though this must be absolute top money for them.

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/BMW-E36-M3-3-2-EVO-SALOON-SP...

Edited by JonyPI on Friday 14th January 17:37


Edited by JonyPI on Friday 14th January 17:41

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
JonyPI said:
That looks absolutely lovely and I certainly would pay strong money for it. I've never been a fan of the 'Sport' body styling.

ETA: And you've helped me decide upon a set of Style 42s for mine.

Edited by 2 Wycked on Friday 14th January 17:45

JonyPI

2,579 posts

219 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
2 Wycked said:
JonyPI said:
That looks absolutely lovely and I certainly would pay strong money for it. I've never been a fan of the 'Sport' body styling.
Cheers, To be honest it was a very good friend who had it before me and we both liked the original look of it, every other e36 now has a sport kit added on and just doesn't cut it with me unless its a genuine sport or M3,plus this has a different front bumper to most and still has the brake cooling ducts.

I just loved the wheels and they were for sale near me and different to pretty much everything else I had seen (genuine BBS) and my friend added the clear lights, the rest is as is out factory, including the rear spoiler which was an extra. I wouldn't change a thing about it personally (apart from maybe an S50 and manual box biggrin)

Edited by JonyPI on Friday 14th January 17:46

JonyPI

2,579 posts

219 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
just looked at your profile and your car looks like my cars saloon brother, granite silver? early 325i and in staffs aswell, I'm just in Lichfield so not far away, I might have some spare bits for a loon you can have if they are of any use.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

261 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
JonyPI said:
just looked at your profile and your car looks like my cars saloon brother, granite silver? early 325i and in staffs aswell, I'm just in Lichfield so not far away, I might have some spare bits for a loon you can have if they are of any use.
Tamworth here, used to live in Lichfield. A quick blast up the A5. I'm pretty sure mine's Sterling Silver, but don't hold me to that.

What sort of parts do you have?