1st car - please help. "alternator workshop"
1st car - please help. "alternator workshop"
Author
Discussion

nmadlani

Original Poster:

5 posts

190 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Hi folks,

I've only owned a car 11 days, and don't know much about them so apologies if i ask anything silly.

I brought a 1.6 auto 51 plate VW Golf 41k as a 1st car on 30th dec 2010 for £2600 - from a car dealer in Ealing, W. London.

There was a couple of cosmetic scratches but i was assured it was in complete working order mechanically.

Yesterday when i was driving i got a warning "alternator workshop" warning on the dash.

So when i got home, i turned off the car and tried to turn it back on but i just get a clicking sound. No ignition.

I get the battery warning light as well.

My friends tried to jump start it so we could get it to a garage but it didn't work.

There is no warranty - however i understand having purchased through a dealer they are affected by statutory rights.

i called the dealer today and they said - if i can get it in to them, they will do a repair and give me a 10% discount but will have to pay for whatever is wrong with it. i only purchased it 11 days ago and it no longer turns on!?

Surely the burden is on them to prove it wasn't an existing fault and they need to repair it?

I was just wondering if you had any advice on the mechanical side, what could be wrong? how much does it cost to fix?

and also any advice in dealing with the guys who sold it to me? What are my chances of:
- rejecting it as faulty and getting a refund?
- getting it fixed privately and getting the cost of repair back?

- The situation right now is i have a car parked outside my house, which doesn't turn on and i'm not sure what my next move is or what order to do things in.

ANY help much appreciated.

Cheers

Edited by nmadlani on Monday 10th January 20:47

Silverbullet767

11,385 posts

237 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Pulled from the consumer direct government website.

website said said:
Your rights when buying from a car dealer

When buying from a dealer, under the Sale of Goods Act 1979 (as amended) a car must be:
Of satisfactory quality. It must meet the standard a reasonable person would regard as satisfactory, bearing in mind the way it was described, how much it cost, the make, the age, the history, the mileage, the intended usage of the car and any other relevant circumstances. Amongst other things, this covers the fitness, appearance and finish of the car, its safety and its durability. The car must be free from defects, except when they were pointed out to you by the seller before you agreed to buy it or where you have inspected the car and that inspection ought to have uncovered the car defects. Even where a car appears to have a minor defect, it may still be of unsatisfactory quality if that defect could lead to extensive damage or render the car dangerous to drive.

Also:
- It is not sufficient that a car is merely roadworthy and safe.
- The dealer may be liable for faults that were present at the time of sale, even though they may only become apparent later on.
- Dealers are not liable for fair wear and tear, where the car broke down through normal use. Nor are they liable for your misuse or accidental damage
As described. This covers all statements made about the car, whether in writing, in a conversation over the phone or in the showroom, in a newspaper, website, email or text, or in documentation. If the advert states "air conditioning and CD player" then the car should come with these features and they should be working.
Reasonably fit for any normal purpose. It should get you from A to B with the appropriate degree of comfort, ease of handling and reliability that a reasonable person would expect.

Reasonably fit for any other purpose you make known to the dealer. For example, if you require a vehicle for towing a caravan.

These rights are not affected by any mechanical breakdown insurance (which is often sold by dealers if the manufacturer's warranty has run out), guarantee or warranty giving additional protection.

Some dealers may use disclaimers such as ' Sold as Seen', 'Trade sale Only' or 'No Refund' to try and limit your rights. However, these rights cannot be taken away or restricted by a dealer.

Warranties/guarantees

Warranties and guarantees provide a way for you to have faults corrected at little or no cost. They are in addition to your statutory rights, not a substitute for them - so a dealer cannot refuse to consider your complaint about a fault or defect with a vehicle simply because the warranty has expired or the type of fault is specifically excluded.

Warranties and guarantees can also be particularly useful if a dealer has gone out of business. Important points to look out for when considering a warranty or guarantee include:
Key elements of a warranty or guarantee should clearly be outlined prior to sale. For example, what is covered and excluded, claim limits and procedures, conditions that need to be followed in order for it to remain valid, etc.
Warranties/guarantees vary greatly in what they cover. Make sure you receive relevant documentation including clear details of the type of warranty/guarantee - for example, free extended manufacturer's/dealer's, manufacturers, insurance backed or dealer's own warranty/guarantee.
Once the dealer gives a warranty it becomes an agreement on its own, but it is not your legal right to demand a warranty from the dealer.
Even a free warranty is legally binding and must state that it does not affect your legal rights. You should also be able to view it in writing before the purchase.

If you inspect the car, or someone does so for you, the dealer may not be liable for any faults which should have been uncovered by the inspection. However, where you inspect a car or an expert does, this mainly applies to cosmetic defects such as scratches or dents that are obvious. It's a good idea to get a description of the vehicle's condition from the dealer: ask whether there is a pre-sale inspection checklist.

If after the sale you realise that your rights under the Sale of Goods Act as described above have not been fulfilled, you are entitled to various remedies depending on a number of factors.

And remember, the dealer must have the right to sell you the car. If you discover that they do not have this right - for example, because the car was still subject to a finance agreement - you can reject the car and recover any payment that has been made.

Silverbullet767

11,385 posts

237 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Also, something that might be a bit more relevent, from the same government website.

website said:
Cars

So, you've bought a car, but there's a problem. Here's what you need to do next.
If things go wrong

If something goes wrong, stop using the car and go back to the dealer straight away and explain the problem and say what you want done.

Keep in mind however that if you purchased your car with a Hire Purchase agreement, your statutory rights will be with the finance company rather than the dealer (under the Supply of Goods (Implied Terms) Act 1973). Under this act the car must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose, correspond with any description given, and the creditor must have the right to sell the car. Where the car does not correspond to any one of the above, you may be entitled to reject the car for a full refund or claim compensation.

If the dealer fails to fulfill their obligations under the Sale of Goods Act, with regard to satisfactory quality, fitness for purpose, and the car's description, they will be in breach of contract and you are entitled to various remedies. The appropriate remedy will depend on a number of factors, including:
how long ago you purchased the car
the type of remedy that you are seeking
the seriousness of any fault or defect
whether the fault or defect keeps recurring
the cost of carrying out repairs or replacing the car

Here is a list of remedies to consider based on your specific circumstances:

Full refund

You may be able to request a full refund if you detected a serious fault, if it is still within a reasonable time of the sale and you have stopped using the car. 'Reasonable time' is not defined in law so it will also depend on the facts - it can vary from weeks to a few months. Be sure to keep all of your documents, such as independent inspections in writing as it is up to you to prove that the car was faulty at the time of the purchase if the dealer disputes your claim. If your complaint is deemed valid, you are also entitled to claim for reasonable losses suffered, including the cost of any independent report you have paid for to prove your case.

If you initially choose to allow the dealer to repair the fault within a reasonable period after the sale, you are still entitled to a refund if the repair turns out to be unsatisfactory.

If you are not entitled to a full refund - for example, because a 'reasonable time' has elapsed, you may be able to claim compensation for your losses resulting from being supplied with a faulty car.

Basic example of when a refund may be applicable:
You discover that your one-year old car bought from a dealer for £10,000 a few days ago has a major engine fault. You complain to the dealer straight away and request a full refund but the dealer disputes your claim. You agree to take the car to an independent garage and they confirm that the engine was in a very poor condition when sold. You provide the dealer with a written report of the garage's findings and ask for your money back.
In these circumstances the dealer must accept the car back and provide a full refund, as well as pay for any reasonable losses you have suffered such as the cost of the written report.

Repair or replacement

If you do not want (or are not entitled to) a full refund or to claim compensation, you may request either a repair to the car or a replacement for a similar car.

If you want a repair or replacement (or when these are not feasible, a partial or full refund) in the first six months after the sale, it is presumed that the fault or defect was present at the time of the sale. This time, if it is disputed by the dealer, the dealer must prove otherwise - not you. They will need to provide reasonable evidence that the fault was not present at the time of sale, not just a pre-sale 'tick box' check of the mechanical condition of the car at the time it was sold.

However, if the fault or defect only becomes apparent after six months, it is up to you to provide evidence that it existed at the time of the sale.

Repairs and replacements must be carried out within a reasonable time without causing you any significant inconvenience.

Any replacement car you are offered should be of a similar age, mileage and model as your original car at the time you requested the replacement.

Basic example of when a repair or replacement might be applicable:
You complain to your dealer that the one-year old car you bought from them for £8,000 three months ago has a faulty gearbox so you ask them to repair the car. It will be presumed that the car had a faulty gearbox at the time of sale and the dealer must carry out the repair to the gearbox at no cost to you unless they can prove that the car was of satisfactory quality at the time of sale.

Partial and full refund

If neither a repair nor replacement is realistically possible, you can request a partial or full refund depending on what is reasonable in the circumstances. For example, it may be the case that a full refund is not an option because you have used the car for some time before the problem appeared.


You can switch between certain remedies if you find you are getting nowhere with the dealer. But you must give the dealer a reasonable time to honour your request before you switch and you can never pursue two remedies at the same time.

Basic example of when you might switch remedies:
You discover that a one-year old car you bought for £10,000 three months ago is faulty. You take it to the dealer who agrees to repair the car. The dealer takes over two months to repair the car but the fault persists. In these circumstances you may request a replacement car or a refund instead because the repairs have not remedied the fault, were not carried out within a reasonable time and have caused significant inconvenience to you.

You can usually take court action up to six years from the date you bought the car (five years in Scotland). This does not mean that the car has to last or be fault free for six years; it is the time limit for making a claim in court in respect of a fault that was present at the time of sale. Before taking such action you may want consider obtaining independent legal advice.

If the dealer is a member of a trade association such as Motor Codes, Retail Motor Industry Federation, Scottish Motor Trade Association or Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders that follows a code of practice, you should follow any complaint procedure they operate.

Look out for businesses displaying the OFT Approved code logo. It means that the business is operating under a trade body that has an approved code of practice- providing you with high standards of customer service and ensuring your rights as a consumer are better protected. The Motor Codes of Practice for New Cars (covering warranties on new cars and older cars where the manufacturer's warranty is still current) is approved under this scheme. For more information visit www.oft.gov.uk/codes and www.motorcodes.co.uk .

In Scotland, some district councils require used vehicle dealers to register, and issue them with a licence. If you are in Scotland and have problems with a dealer, contact your local Trading Standards Service.

nmadlani

Original Poster:

5 posts

190 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Hi,

Thanks for that. I've read through it, and it appears that the dealer is obliged to fix the car for me at no cost.

They are refusing to do this though.

So i'm not sure what my next move should be?

Silverbullet767

11,385 posts

237 months

Monday 10th January 2011
quotequote all
Quote the sale of goods act 1979 for starters, this might help too.

which consumer rights said:
Your rights: buying second hand cars
Second hand cars: your rights

Whether you’re buying an old banger from a friend of a friend or a year-old luxury motor from a car dealer, there are lots of pitfalls to look out for when buying second hand cars. So it’s important to be aware of your rights and to think carefully before buying.

See our video guide to buying second hand cars for tips on what to look out for.
Your rights if you buy second hand cars from a dealer

When you buy a second hand car from a dealer, you have a right, under the Sale of Goods Act 1979, to expect the car to:
be of satisfactory quality (taking into account its age and mileage)
meet any description given to you when you were buying it, and
be fit for the purpose (for example, to get you from A to B safely)

If the second hand car does not meet these requirements you have a right to claim against the dealer for breach of contract.
Your right to reject a second hand car

If there's a problem with a second hand car soon after you’ve bought it, for example, the car develops a problem you wouldn’t expect for the car’s age and mileage, or it turns out to be not what you’d been lead to expect, you may have the right to ‘reject’ the car and get your money back.

However, you have only a ‘reasonable’ time to reject a second hand car. There’s no clear definition of what a reasonable time is – you probably need to do it within three or four weeks of buying it. And if the fault is very obvious you may have less time.

If you reject a second hand car you must stop using it.
Your right to claim for the cost of repairs

If it’s too late to reject the second hand car (or you don’t want to) you can ask the dealer for a repair or replacement. If the dealer refuses, you could:
claim from it the cost of getting the second hand car repaired elsewhere
claim for a reduction in the purchase price, or
return the car and get the money you paid back, less a deduction for the use you’ve had (called ‘recision’)

However, if your claim is worth more than the small claims limit where you live (£5,000 in England and Wales, £750 in Scotland or £2,000 in Northern Ireland) you may need to take advice before you act, because you may risk facing time-consuming and expensive court action.

If you get a warranty or guarantee with a second hand car, you may be able to claim on that to get any problems fixed. However, this doesn’t affect your legal rights, and you could still either reject the car, or claim against the dealer.
How a trade association can help with second hand car problems

Some motoring trade associations have complaints schemes that can sort out problems between car dealers and customers. Check whether the dealer you bought from is a member of a trade association and whether it has a complaints scheme.

One of the main trade associations, the Retail Motor Industry Federation (RMIF), has a conciliation and arbitration service to deal with disputes about second hand cars.
If you bought your second hand car on credit

If you bought your second hand car with a credit card or with credit provided by the dealer, the card company or credit provider is jointly liable with the dealer for any breach of contract, so you can also claim from them.

If the credit company refuses your claim, you could then take the matter to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
If you bought your second hand car on hire-purchase (HP)

If you bought your second hand car on HP, your rights are against the HP company, not the dealer, so you must take up any problems with it, not the dealer. However, you rights are different and if you have a serious problem, and the HP company won’t help, you will need to seek legal advice.
If you buy a second hand car privately

If you buy a second hand car from a private seller you have fewer rights than if you buy from a dealer. Key parts of the Sale of Goods Act don’t apply – there is no legal requirement that a car is of satisfactory quality or fit for its purpose.

However, legally, the seller must:
accurately describe the second hand car (for example, an advert must not say ‘one owner’, when the car has had several)
not misrepresent the second hand car (tell you something about the car which isn’t true – so, for example, if you ask whether the car has ever been in an accident, the owner must answer truthfully)
If the second hand car you buy was stolen

Anyone selling goods (including second hand cars) must be the legal owner or the sale doesn’t count. If a second hand car is stolen, the legal ownership of the car usually remains with the original owner. So, even if you buy it, in most cases it won’t legally belong to you.

If you discover the second hand car you’ve bought is stolen you should contact the police. It’s most likely that you will have to return the car to its rightful owner.

There are some exceptions to this and the situation is complex so you should seek legal advice. The only way to get your money back is to try and reclaim the cost of the car from the person that sold it to you.
If the seller has mislead you about the second hand car

If something you buy is not ‘as described’, or if the seller is guilty of misrepresentation, you are entitled to:
give the second hand car back and get your money back, or
if you want to keep the car, ask for compensation (usually the cost of any repairs it needs)

However, if you buy a second hand car that was not described as being in excellent condition or good working order, and it breaks soon after you buy it, you do not have any right to reject it, or to claim compensation.

Some unscrupulous second hand car dealers might pretend to be private sellers to get out of their legal obligations. If you think a dealer is trying to pretend they're a private seller, do not buy from them and report them to the local trading standards department.
Buying second hand cars at auction

When you buy a used car at auction you have very limited legal rights. Though the Sale of Goods Act generally applies to cars sold at auction, auction houses are allowed to exclude its main conditions (such as being of satisfactory quality, as described and fit for the purpose) if they put a notice on display in the catalogue.

So make sure you check the auction house conditions before you bid. When you buy at auction, your rights are against the seller, not the auction house.

nmadlani

Original Poster:

5 posts

190 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Right -

I called the dealer this morning quoting the 1979 SOGA. Also that "sold as seen" is an invalid statement for a dealer.

They were having not of it and said they would do nothing for me, i could bring it in if i want but i'd have to pay for any repair.

Should i write to the dealer and await a written reply before doing anything to the car?

I understand i could "reject" the faulty goods but i would need to prove it was an existing fault when i purchased it.

Has anyone tried this? would a garage inspection report suffice? at what point would i return the car?

Or if i choose to have it repaired independantly and try to claim the costs through small claims, should i wait for a written response before doing so?


Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Citizens advice/trading standards/RAC legal assist... get a call in to one of them and ask how you should take further action as the garage has declined the opportunity to resolve the issue.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
nmadlani said:
I called the dealer this morning... they were having not of it
I would ask to speak to the next rung of the ladder and give each of them the opportunity to take ownership of the problem; salesmans' direct boss, dealer principal, area sales director, etc.

I would also make them aware of your comments here - we are a big forum, and that could be a few sales they might not make in the future...

EDIT: Plus, if it's a franchised dealer, suggest you will contact UK main customer service.

Edited by FamilyDub on Tuesday 11th January 12:14

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Threatening them with slander? Not a good idea, keep it civil.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Threatening them with slander? Not a good idea, keep it civil.
^^ Never said anything about not keeping it civil. smile

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
I would ask to speak to the next rung of the ladder and give each of them the opportunity to take ownership of the problem; salesmans' direct boss, dealer principal, area sales director, etc.

I would also make them aware of your comments here - we are a big forum, and that could be a few sales they might not make in the future...

EDIT: Plus, if it's a franchised dealer, suggest you will contact UK main customer service.
Every point you made is hilarious! Can you imagine the kind of place it must be if it sells a car these days without a warranty?

Edited by Deva Link on Tuesday 11th January 14:49

nmadlani

Original Poster:

5 posts

190 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
I wrote to them explaining that under Sales of goods act 1979. If a (non accident or wear and tear) fault appears within 6 months, it is presumed to have been existing at time of sale. If they dissagree it's up to them to prove otherwise.

They are required to repair so it is in satisfactory working order and fit for purpose for a reasonably period of acceptance. This is my preference.

I also informed them it is illegal for a dealer selling to a consumer to use terms such as "sold as seen, no comebacks" or any other term suggesting the transaction is not covered by SOGA 1979. As is clearly stated office of fair trading guidelines.
There is no such thing as sold as seen when buying from a dealer, you always have statutory rights.

I intend on calling rac to look at it and tell me what they feel is wrong, how much it will cost to fix, and how likely it is to re-occur.

I've given the dealer 7 days to respond. If i don't hear, and depending on what RAC say, if it is economically fixable (£200 max) then i will get it done independantly and claim through small claims.

My only concern is if it's something major, or not easily fixed that could keep re-occuring.

Then i would want to reject the vehicle and prove it was faulty at time of purchase. But i can imagine this would be time consuming and complex

Silverbullet767

11,385 posts

237 months

Wednesday 12th January 2011
quotequote all
Well done, stick to your guns, he's trying it on, hoping you will give up. Don't!

The SOGA is there for a reason.

OctyVrs

107 posts

191 months

Wednesday 12th January 2011
quotequote all
The small claims court is cheap, easy and it's there exactly for cases like this. No expensive legal representation required. Dead cheap and really easy.

Your case is an open and shut one too which makes things simple.

nmadlani

Original Poster:

5 posts

190 months

Friday 14th January 2011
quotequote all
RAC looked at the car and confirmed the Alternator is faulty and that's why the car won't start.

They said I need to get it to a garage and have it replaced.

I've sent another fax to the dealer (original letter sent by fax and recorded delivery.) informing them of this and repeating my claim for them to fix it at no cost.

fingers crossed. If i dont hear within 7 days of the original letter i'm going to have to get it fixed independantly and go the legal route.