Anyone ever had a cracked alloy welded?
Anyone ever had a cracked alloy welded?
Author
Discussion

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
It is dented and has a crack about 1". Has anyone had similar damage repaired and still using the welded alloy? All advice / opinions welcome.

Night Runner

12,424 posts

225 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
I didn't know it could be done. Personally I'd be a bit wary, a bit like using part worn tyres.

Noisy

4,489 posts

308 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
I had a rare set of Boyd Codington alloys on a previous car, one got cracked from a pot hole, I had this repaired and was fine for the following year I owned the car.

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Noisy said:
I had a rare set of Boyd Codington alloys on a previous car, one got cracked from a pot hole, I had this repaired and was fine for the following year I owned the car.
Was it an expensive job? I will probably only have the car for another year max, but would still like to feel safe!

vrooom

3,763 posts

298 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Cracked alloy wheels, throw it away.

skinley

1,681 posts

191 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Night Runner said:
I didn't know it could be done. Personally I'd be a bit wary, a bit like using part worn tyres.
What is wrong with part worn tyres? I bet you have part worn tyres on your car right now, or do you fit brand new ones before every drive?

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
vrooom said:
Cracked alloy wheels, throw it away.
Keep getting mixed responses! Some say throw it away, others say its fine. What to do?!

This is the damage



Edited by wilbo83 on Thursday 27th January 20:12

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
it'd probably be fine and safe, but would it balance properly?

Jem0911

4,415 posts

232 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
We welded a 19" BMW wheel as we were sick of replacing them. As they crack regularly.
We have our own Ali/stainless fabricator at work.
Welds have held so far.

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Nasty! I'd be more worried about the suspension.

Jem0911

4,415 posts

232 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
That Sir is k n acked.
I would not weld that.

Eggman

1,253 posts

242 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
As long as you choose a place with the appropriate expertise (i.e. not just a mate who has bunged aluminium wire in his MIG welder and bought a bottle of argon), I can't see why there would be a problem.

Think about it - if they weren't safe, they would either find their public liability insurance prohibitively expensive or (if they decided not to insure, and for most businesses it isn't compulsory) they wouldn't be around for very long.

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Eggman said:
As long as you choose a place with the appropriate expertise (i.e. not just a mate who has bunged aluminium wire in his MIG welder and bought a bottle of argon), I can't see why there would be a problem.

Think about it - if they weren't safe, they would either find their public liability insurance prohibitively expensive or (if they decided not to insure, and for most businesses it isn't compulsory) they wouldn't be around for very long.
True, guess it just depends on how bad the damage is but looking at some places, there are bits of the edge missing and they have repaired it! At least it isnt missing any bits.

Life Saab Itch

37,069 posts

219 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
If it was on a spoke, or in the middle of the rim I would say yes. But that is right on the bead.

No way.

right it off as a loss before it blows out on you at speed and your insurance company won't pay out on the damage.

You do not want this to hapen to you at 0.85 leptons.





This happened to me this morning, not due to a cracked rim, just due to picking up some crap.

It is not a nice experience, DO NOT RISK IT

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Was about to post the link below and say that it gives me confidence, but then the above does the opposite!

http://www.alloywheelrepairs.net/awr-wheelrepairpr...

Eggman

1,253 posts

242 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
I've just been looking at this place - check that wheel out!

I'd say the worst that is likely to happen with yours even if they do a terrible job is the tyre will go flat overnight. It's not like the rim is going to suddenly shatter into a million pieces; if anything, it looks to be made of surprisingly bendy metal.

FreezerWeasel

20,566 posts

203 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
one of my DSIIs on the M3 is repaired on the inside. been on car for about 14 months, had it checked a few times when car's in the air. it's totally solid. the weld is stronger than the surrounding wheel. IMHO if the job's done PROPERLY it isn't a problem.

A205GTI

750 posts

197 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
I had an alloy crack on the inside, told by tyre place could get welded, I didnt order replacement form dealer, just didnt want to risk it.

My choice as my safety!

Flat6Fan

6 posts

190 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
I damaged a Boxster split rim (the outer magnesium rim) in the last spell of bad weather we had. I din't think it would be possible to weld, however Specialist Cars in Malton have a contact who specialises in welding all kinds of aluminium/alloy materials, and they got him to fix it. It was perfect. He also welded an aluminium strut at the back of the car somewhere (which hit the deck very hard after I flew over a humpback bridge too fast). As someone above said the weld is actually stronger than the surrounding metal.

Dog Star

17,643 posts

199 months

Thursday 27th January 2011
quotequote all
Nothing wrong with a properly welded alloy wheel (or hydrogen pipe, nuclear reactor, spacecraft etc). Just make sure a pro does it. I've seen some amazing repairs done.

The damage in the OPs pic is no big deal. I'd suggest to the OP that he seeks the opinion of a specialist and not some blokes off teh interweb.

(and as for the pic of the nasty blowout above - glad the poster is ok but it has no relevance to this topic, really)