Discussion
Hi Guys, i have a 2005 Audi A4 2.0tdi with full service history! My question is, should i continue with Audi service or bring to a local indie for future services? Audi don't seem to stand by anything once a car is over 5 years old so is there any point in paying Audi's big labour charges??
Although you'll probably get a better service from an Audi Specialist, the service prices are not much different as Audi offer deals on anything over 4 years old - have a look at their website. I've got this quandry with my 2005 A4 2.0T in September.
The other thing to consider is that a fully stamped up Audi service book appeals to buyers more than a specialist - it wouldn't bother me though as long as the specialist was a specialist and not a tinpot back street garage.
The other thing to consider is that a fully stamped up Audi service book appeals to buyers more than a specialist - it wouldn't bother me though as long as the specialist was a specialist and not a tinpot back street garage.
DickSkruttock said:
Although you'll probably get a better service from an Audi Specialist, the service prices are not much different as Audi offer deals on anything over 4 years old
I had this last week with my Polo, the local VAG indy were only £1.68 cheaper for a service. I waited in the service area of the VW dealer and treated myself to about four cups of coffee and some rather nice biscuits while watching TV and reading the papers, not something I`d be able to do in the garage of the indy.The indy has undercut the dealer by just over £100 for a cambelt change though........
Deerfoot said:
I had this last week with my Polo, the local VAG indy were only £1.68 cheaper for a service. I waited in the service area of the VW dealer and treated myself to about four cups of coffee and some rather nice biscuits while watching TV and reading the papers, not something I`d be able to do in the garage of the indy.
The indy has undercut the dealer by just over £100 for a cambelt change though........
Out of interest, what were you quoted by VW for the cambelt change? My wife's Polo GTI (1.8T) is due one, and VW have quoted £299. The indy has undercut the dealer by just over £100 for a cambelt change though........
plfrench said:
Out of interest, what were you quoted by VW for the cambelt change? My wife's Polo GTI (1.8T) is due one, and VW have quoted £299.
Approx £450 from the dealer, it`s a 1.9 PD TDI.In fact, I`ve just had a look at the service report.
They`ve quoted £420.54 for the cambelt, £113.94 for a set of front brake pads (70% worn according to them) and £102.12 for a 205/45/16 tyre (they`re on the cusp).
I bought a Pirelli P Zero for £75 prior to Christmas and I`m sure I can do the pads myself in half a morning.
Edited by Deerfoot on Saturday 29th January 16:57
I take it the TDI belt change takes a while longer than the 1.8 petrol then. £299 doesn't seem so bad after these comments!
30 hours for a timing chain change! That's ridiculous... don't garages charge around £80 per hour? if so, that's going to cost around £2500! On a 6 year old A3, that's going to be about 40% of the cars value
30 hours for a timing chain change! That's ridiculous... don't garages charge around £80 per hour? if so, that's going to cost around £2500! On a 6 year old A3, that's going to be about 40% of the cars value

Deerfoot said:
plfrench said:
Out of interest, what were you quoted by VW for the cambelt change? My wife's Polo GTI (1.8T) is due one, and VW have quoted £299.
Approx £450 from the dealer, it`s a 1.9 PD TDI.In fact, I`ve just had a look at the service report.
They`ve quoted £420.54 for the cambelt, £113.94 for a set of front brake pads (70% worn according to them) and £102.12 for a 205/45/16 tyre (they`re on the cusp).
I bought a Pirelli P Zero for £75 prior to Christmas and I`m sure I can do the pads myself in half a morning.
Toilet Duck said:
I had the cambelt and water pump changed on my 56 plate 1.9Tdi Polo by my local main stealer a few months ago and they charged £299 for the cambelt plus £99 for the water pump. All the main dealers I rang quoted the same as I believe its part of the fixed price menu servicing. If they are quoting you more then they might be trying to rape you. I also tried my local non franchise garage that I normally use for MOT's and other odds and sods, and they couldn't get anywhere near that price (and they are always very reasonable).
Thanks for that.Looking at the VW UK site, there are a few prices that are different.
Brake fluid service, £59 according to VW, £65.40 according to my local VW garage.
Front brake pads, £129 according to VW, £113.94 according to my local VW garage.
They`ve certainly quoted £420.54 for the cambelt though (including water pump). I might call the service manager on Monday and see what he says, the VW indy though has still undercut them massively on the cambelt (and he uses genuine VW parts and does the water pump etc all in...).
I had an A4 of similar vintage and after getting fed up of £400 services I got my local (tried and tested and as honest as the day is long) mechanic to do all the servicing.
He used genuine parts, whatever oil I asked him to use, and did everything I needed him to do for tiny money compared to what the dealer was charging.
Ok I was lucky and there were no electronic faults or anything requiring diagnostic equipment, but when I traded the car in for my current A6 all the dealer wanted to know was "has it got a service history", he looked at it and was happy. Maybe I would have got a bit more on the trade in if it was a full Audi history but on a £6k car (as it was when I got rid of it) it wasn't going to make much difference and it's all down to the negotiation at that point anyway.
He used genuine parts, whatever oil I asked him to use, and did everything I needed him to do for tiny money compared to what the dealer was charging.
Ok I was lucky and there were no electronic faults or anything requiring diagnostic equipment, but when I traded the car in for my current A6 all the dealer wanted to know was "has it got a service history", he looked at it and was happy. Maybe I would have got a bit more on the trade in if it was a full Audi history but on a £6k car (as it was when I got rid of it) it wasn't going to make much difference and it's all down to the negotiation at that point anyway.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


