Which Q7 - 4.2tdi or 3.0tdi
Which Q7 - 4.2tdi or 3.0tdi
Author
Discussion

dazzalse

Original Poster:

575 posts

210 months

Friday 28th January 2011
quotequote all
Have been considering one of these for the last month or so and still cannot decide if I should go for the more powerful engine, this will be used everyday for the school run ( about 40 mile round trip) and frequent trips up to London and down through Europe covering about 30,000 miles per year. My heart says 4.2tdi but thinking from a practical point of view the 3.0tdi might be a better allrounder?
Is there anyone running a 4.2tdi that could share there experiances, and likewise with the 3.0tdi? I am particular interested in reliability and service after they have had your money !

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Friday 28th January 2011
quotequote all
Have you read this?

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

I`d expect the 3.0 to be adequate.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Friday 28th January 2011
quotequote all
3.0 is an excellent motor, 4.2 does have amusing punch but worsens already dire fuel economy. 3.0 can touch 30mpg if you're nice to it which is pretty good for a big old beast, remap would improve this a smidgen too.

My money would be on the smaller engine for the mileage you cover.

kent_phil

329 posts

274 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
Can talk for the 3.0TDi - took delivery of one last month and very pleased with it so far.

As for performance we came from a 4.2FSi Q7 and the 3.0TDi feels just as quick with the new 8 speed box.

As for economy did the first long trip last weekend and the trip computer showed 34mpg average, around town for the school runs (all 30mph limits and traffic jams) it's doing 20mpg with the auto-engine shutdown function. This takes a bit of getting used to but I'm finding it fine.

Also bought the extended warranty to 5 years which is great value new and it's not top band road tax like the 4.2 which you can guarantee is going to get more of a penalty as time goes on.

I would like to get it re-mapped but the dealer can't do these as it's more than just software apparently and don't want anyone else doing it given the warranty.

Some great deals available as well, buying new worked out far cheaper than an ex-dem and only 5k over an 18 month old 4.2TDi.

mr pg

2,068 posts

236 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
40 mile school run! Have you thought about an A6 Allroad 3.0TDi instead? Would be much better on a run like that, and more economical. Adjustable suspension, and with winter tyres, go anywhere ability.

dazzalse

Original Poster:

575 posts

210 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
mr pg said:
40 mile school run! Have you thought about an A6 Allroad 3.0TDi instead? Would be much better on a run like that, and more economical. Adjustable suspension, and with winter tyres, go anywhere ability.
Would prefer the Allroad but we need the 7 seats!

mr pg

2,068 posts

236 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
You can get 7 seat Allroads, at least in my 2004 model. 2 rear facing seats as an option.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 31st January 2011
quotequote all
kent_phil said:
I would like to get it re-mapped but the dealer can't do these as it's more than just software apparently and don't want anyone else doing it given the warranty.
2010 ECUs are security locked, Revo are in the process of releasing kit to dealers (ours was ordered on Friday for delivery in march I think) to unlock these, I don't know about other tuners. Unsure how visible this is to Audi from a software point of view.