Chain or direct drive???
Author
Discussion

enduroxr

Original Poster:

19 posts

190 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
Just getting a heads up for future reference here! I have a 2005 A4 2.0 tdi and i've heard when the timing belt is up for renewal, it's a good idea to replace the waterpump! Thing is i've heard my model has a chain driven waterpump and the chains can break? I've also heard that a conversion kit is available to fit a direct drive waterpump? Is this true and is it better to go the conversion route? Cheers guys.

DickSkruttock

4,553 posts

199 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
I think you mean a chain driven oil pump which are known to go on pre 2006 2.0 tdis. The water pump is belt driven afaik.

The Tame Tech will confirm this....or shoot me down!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
DickSkruttock said:
I think you mean a chain driven oil pump which are known to go on pre 2006 2.0 tdis. The water pump is belt driven afaik.

The Tame Tech will confirm this....or shoot me down!
Confirmed.

enduroxr

Original Poster:

19 posts

190 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
What's the best thing to do here then TT?? Can the oil pump be changed to a direct drive? Or is it just a good idea to renew the pump/chain at a certain age/mileage?
Tame Technician said:
Confirmed.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 29th January 2011
quotequote all
If you can still get them, wouldnt be a bad idea to consider changing the oil pump chain and tensioner, its the tensioner that goes, before 80-100k. Most of the ones that failed did so at this sort of milage. The parts will be less than £100 but the labour is very expensive, it takes most of a day to do. Its basically cam belt off + sump off at the same time. 3 hours for belt + 5 for sump, roughly.

Changing to Gear drive is £1200 parts and 8+ hours labour so that £2000.

Not really economical for a precaution. BUt cheaper than a new engine and a new turbo.

How many miles has it done, how many are you intending to do, how quickly can you turn it off when you see the oil light.

Thread here
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

seagrey

385 posts

196 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
If you can still get them, wouldnt be a bad idea to consider changing the oil pump chain and tensioner, its the tensioner that goes, before 80-100k. Most of the ones that failed did so at this sort of milage. The parts will be less than £100 but the labour is very expensive, it takes most of a day to do. Its basically cam belt off + sump off at the same time. 3 hours for belt + 5 for sump, roughly.

Changing to Gear drive is £1200 parts and 8+ hours labour so that £2000.

Not really economical for a precaution. BUt cheaper than a new engine and a new turbo.

How many miles has it done, how many are you intending to do, how quickly can you turn it off when you see the oil light.

Thread here
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

I did one of these last year on a 55 plate A4 for my sister.
I couldnt get a replacement for the old pump,I was told they no longer supplied the pump seperately for my engine code and had to buy a pump with balance shaft assembly plus the gear kit that all came to £1300.

I did toy with the idea of just putting the new pump and hex drive onto the old balancer shaft assembly and leaving the chain drive on to save time but they have changed the casting to add a bolt hole for the intermediate gear,bds!
The old crank sprocket came off much easier than it looked like it would with a bit of heat but getting the sump off was a right pig.
I wasnt too impressed with the way the intermediate gear is set up though,looked a bit heath robinson.

enduroxr

Original Poster:

19 posts

190 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
If you can still get them, wouldnt be a bad idea to consider changing the oil pump chain and tensioner, its the tensioner that goes, before 80-100k. Most of the ones that failed did so at this sort of milage. The parts will be less than £100 but the labour is very expensive, it takes most of a day to do. Its basically cam belt off + sump off at the same time. 3 hours for belt + 5 for sump, roughly.

Changing to Gear drive is £1200 parts and 8+ hours labour so that £2000.

Not really economical for a precaution. BUt cheaper than a new engine and a new turbo.

How many miles has it done, how many are you intending to do, how quickly can you turn it off when you see the oil light.

Thread here
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
It's approaching 53k miles! I was intending to put another 100k on it but that might not happen now as i've the multitronic box and by all accounts it's likely to pack in before then!! Would it be a good idea to change the chain/tensioner when i get the cam belt done? Is the oil pump ok then? It's the tensioner that's the prob??

seagrey

385 posts

196 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
enduroxr said:
It's approaching 53k miles! I was intending to put another 100k on it but that might not happen now as i've the multitronic box and by all accounts it's likely to pack in before then!! Would it be a good idea to change the chain/tensioner when i get the cam belt done? Is the oil pump ok then? It's the tensioner that's the prob??
There is a hex drive between the balance shaft and oil pump which wore on my sisters car,basically a straight allen key between the shaft and pump it had worn the inside of the pump and the hex drive its self,it would grip then slip then grip again.
I got lucky,caught it early but have heard stories from people who didnt.
I think the chain set up causes this hence the gear drive conversion.
if you are going to change the tensioner and chain the sump has to come of anyway so you might as well put in a new pump.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
seagrey said:
There is a hex drive between the balance shaft and oil pump which wore on my sisters car,basically a straight allen key between the shaft and pump it had worn the inside of the pump and the hex drive its self,it would grip then slip then grip again.
I got lucky,caught it early but have heard stories from people who didnt.
I think the chain set up causes this hence the gear drive conversion.
if you are going to change the tensioner and chain the sump has to come of anyway so you might as well put in a new pump.
Sadly the hex drive can fail on both the chain and gear driven versions, and the only fix is a new balancer shaft assembly, new hex drive will just slip again as the edges are worn off the end of teh ballancer shaft.

But this is pretty unusually, we have seen maybe 4 or 5 cars that have done that, 2005-2008 models. Think how many cars there were in that production run, thats a small failure rate.

Seens close to tens times that with oil pump chain/tensioners problems, and that is only 2005 cars.

enduroxr

Original Poster:

19 posts

190 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
Sadly the hex drive can fail on both the chain and gear driven versions, and the only fix is a new balancer shaft assembly, new hex drive will just slip again as the edges are worn off the end of teh ballancer shaft.

But this is pretty unusually, we have seen maybe 4 or 5 cars that have done that, 2005-2008 models. Think how many cars there were in that production run, thats a small failure rate.

Seens close to tens times that with oil pump chain/tensioners problems, and that is only 2005 cars.
When you say 2005 cars, is that the B7 or B6 model of 2005? They changed from B6 to B7 that year didn't they?

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
I thought you could have B7's with an ASN engine. But a quick look on autotrader suggests not.

The point is, if its a 3.0 V6 ASN engine, is belt, regardless of modle/year.

If its the 3.2FSI unit, cant remember the code off hand, then its chain, regardless if modle or year.

Most B7's were 3.2, and B6's 3.0, But I think they may have been a few B7's at the changer over year with 3.0 still in them.

E.g Chain 2005 car
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010...

E.G belt 2006 car
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...