2.7Tdi v 3.0Tdi
Author
Discussion

Greenday

Original Poster:

16 posts

190 months

Sunday 30th January 2011
quotequote all
First post so take it easy on me :-)

A few questions:

I'm looking for a 2008 reasonably low mileage A6 Le Mans Quattro

Firstly is the 2.7Tdi a CVT box and the 3.0Tdi a tiptronic or can you get both boxes on either engine?

Secondly is there a preference between the CVT and the Tiptronic box?

Finally is the 3.0Tdi significantly better than the 2.7Tdi?

I'm moving from a 220bhp 3.0 petrol engine. I recon the 174(?)bhp 2.7Tdi wont be much different (I dont really use the high end of the revs on my current car where all the power is)

Any other pointers woudl be appreciated.

Cheers


blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Monday 31st January 2011
quotequote all
Greenday said:
First post so take it easy on me :-)

A few questions:

I'm looking for a 2008 reasonably low mileage A6 Le Mans Quattro

Firstly is the 2.7Tdi a CVT box and the 3.0Tdi a tiptronic or can you get both boxes on either engine?

Secondly is there a preference between the CVT and the Tiptronic box?

Finally is the 3.0Tdi significantly better than the 2.7Tdi?

I'm moving from a 220bhp 3.0 petrol engine. I recon the 174(?)bhp 2.7Tdi wont be much different (I dont really use the high end of the revs on my current car where all the power is)

Any other pointers woudl be appreciated.

Cheers
I drove both and went for the 3.0. I found the difference in power noticeable with a minimal difference in fuel economy (only a short drive in the 2.7 though). The 3.0 is really quite quick mid range, eg overtaking. I would have thought you will notice the power difference with the 2.7 if you are coming from a 220bhp petrol.

The 3.0 is tiptronic or manual not sure about the box in the 2.7, but I would steer clear of the multitronic box which has a reputation for poor reliability.

Some things to look out for with either car

if its a quattro (all 3.0 are) make sure it has the same tyres on all corners with similar tread depths as tyre mis-matching can damage drive train (the 19 inch tyres are not cheap at the moment!)

Make sure that all the MMI electronics are functioning especially phone and cd autochanger

Make sure that there have been no spills in the front cup holders as there is an ecu under there thats a bit vulnerable to coffee etc

If its an avant make sure the rear screen washer pipe in the boot is not leaking as it also kills vital electronics

Other than the above I think they are pretty sound cars, had my 2007 Le Mans from new and its now got 75k on it with only problems being MMI electronics.


Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 31st January 2011
quotequote all
All quattro automatics will have the tiptronic (torque convertor) box, the Multitronic (CVT) box you will get with a front wheel drive auto only.

Comments above are spot on! smile

Greenday

Original Poster:

16 posts

190 months

Monday 31st January 2011
quotequote all
Thanks guys. Some good pointers.

Do you think the matching tyres on a Quattro are a huge issue??

I have 2 pairs on my wifes A3 Quattro (between 1 and 2mm difference in tread from front to back)

Dunlop SP Maxx were unavailable recently so had to go for Goodyears

DickSkruttock

4,553 posts

199 months

Monday 31st January 2011
quotequote all
Greenday said:
Thanks guys. Some good pointers.

Do you think the matching tyres on a Quattro are a huge issue??

I have 2 pairs on my wifes A3 Quattro (between 1 and 2mm difference in tread from front to back)

Dunlop SP Maxx were unavailable recently so had to go for Goodyears
A3 is a haldex not torsen, so matching treads front to rear not too much of an issue.

Matching tyres on a torsen is more critical. I think a couple of mm is the limit.