Water Softener
Author
Discussion

kentmotorcompany

Original Poster:

2,471 posts

234 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Anyone got any experience with these.

I've read about the possible benefits, and it all sounds good.

How much should I expect to pay to have one installed?

Do they really make a noticeable difference?

What ongoing maintenance is required?

Will it make any difference to the water pressure?

m3jappa

6,889 posts

242 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
Installation is easy, took me about 2 hrs, but only because i didnt have loads of space for the required parts so had to mess about a bit.

I would imagine a plumber to charge £100 maybe? just guessing.

They need topping up every so often depending on usage and afaik will need no real maintenance.

Worth it imo, i know this sounds a bit gay but my hands are very rough due to the work i do for a living, i'm the type who doesnt care if i get diesel, petrol, paint, oil or whatever on them and it shows, i have noticed that since having the softener my hands are noticibly softer. The water just feels nicer.

I still get water marks on chrome stuff like taps though (after about 6months) and i'm really not sure why, only thing i can think is the rest of the system is 25yr old and we are in very hard water area so maybe still a bit dirty?

Paul Drawmer

5,120 posts

291 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
I put one in the last house. DIY install.

Will do it again on this house.

It's all about limescale, we are in a hard water area:
258.7 mgl CaCO3 (ppm)

Your water company will publish how hard your water is. The above results are from the Thames Water site.

If you remove the hardess, you wont have to de-scale the kettle, and your Hot water cylinder will stay more efficient, you won't get lime scale in toilet pans, or shower enclosures or curtains. We even get lime scale around our taps!

Also, you will use less soaps and detergents (nasty stuff)

Webber3

1,228 posts

243 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
We've had one for about 2 years and noticed the difference straight away. The only downside - We use a lot of water, so the softener goes through a lot of salt, which needs topping up frequently. I'm now looking for a higher capacity metered unit.

My advice is to do your research, buy your own unit and get your own plumber in to fit it. Some of these companies supply and can rip you off big time!

Toilet Duck

1,365 posts

209 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Sorry to hijack, but I'm looking to get one of these as well. Been advised to spend the extra and get a "metered" one that knows how much water its actually using/treating so only regenerates itself when it needs too (rather than after a set time period e.g. every X number of days).

Looking to spend up to £4-500 if needed; want something that is sevicable so that I can replace parts in the event they break rather than have to throw the whole unit away and buy a new one, which can be they case with cheaper units.

kentmotorcompany

Original Poster:

2,471 posts

234 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Thanks chaps.

I am about to do some extensive refurbishments to the Bathroom and thought this would be a good investment to protect the new Bathroom, as well as all the other benefits.

I was always planning to buy my own and get the plumber to install it.

hiscocks

322 posts

207 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
I just moved house and we have a little salt box and system under the sink. The sink has an extra tap, so I presume this is the only softened water in the house?

Also, the box which holds the salt has a dead spider in it... am I drinking dangerously tainted spider water??

Cheers

Ferg

15,242 posts

281 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Non-metered water softeners are quite rare now. I'd go for a metered machine from Monarch or Waterside (Culligan) and get it fitted by a plumber. The things that will make installation more expensive are generally the distance from the rising main and/or the 'hard water tap' position. This is required to avoid drinking too much of the sodium which is added to the water in the ion exchange process. (The hard water tap issue is the reason why your kettle will STILL scale.......Mr.Drawmer!)
Don't be fooled, incidentally, by claims that your heating system will benefit. Since it uses the same water unless you need to drain it this is just bks, but is used by some companies as a 'selling' point.

pano amo

814 posts

260 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
hiscocks said:
I just moved house and we have a little salt box and system under the sink. The sink has an extra tap, so I presume this is the only softened water in the house?

Also, the box which holds the salt has a dead spider in it... am I drinking dangerously tainted spider water??

Cheers
I think that little tap is your drinking water tap. I don't think you are supposed to drink the water coming through your filter?

hiscocks

322 posts

207 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Ah so all the water in the house is 'softened' but I should drink the non softened stuff? I'm confused! It looks as though the system connects up to the little tap on the sink.

Ferg

15,242 posts

281 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
It should be arranged something like this...


hiscocks

322 posts

207 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Thanks Ferg I'll check it out when I get home and try not to kill myself

pano amo

814 posts

260 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Yep dont drink from the big tap and dont eat that spider smile


I wonder how many people drink the softened water out there. Probably all dead now.

Simpo Two

91,503 posts

289 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
hiscocks said:
Ah so all the water in the house is 'softened' but I should drink the non softened stuff? I'm confused! It looks as though the system connects up to the little tap on the sink.
Softened water can taste a bit funny; hard water is nicer to drink IMHO. The hard water tap also means you have an emergency water supply in case the softener suddenly goes phut.

Soft for washing, hard for drinking smile

Ferg

15,242 posts

281 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
The hard water tap also means you have an emergency water supply in case the softener suddenly goes phut.
See bypass valves above...

hiscocks

322 posts

207 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Nice. Apparently the house came up for rent when the last residents diluted their house warming punch with softened water and killed everyone. Be careful out there, folks.

indi pearl

319 posts

221 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Best household appliance going in my humble opinion.
Fitted ours 20 years ago and it is still working as good as new. Never broken down and I service it myself every 4/5 years. I would echo the advice to pay the extra and get a flow controlled softner as the salt usage will match water use. Mine is the older (but considerably cheaper to buy) type controlled by an electric clock and performs its refreshment cycle irrespective of water use so on occasion will either refresh needlesly or fail to soften fully. It therefore usually costs more in salt than a flow controlled softner.
You will get staining for some time as the now softened water will dissolve out all the limescale in your pipework. This will take several months and you could find the odd pipe joint starts to leak. There is a benefit to your heating system assuming you use it to heat the hot water. One of the worst places for limescale is the indirect hot water cylinder (after all it is just a big kettle) and both the heating coil and internals of the cylinder will be heavily scaled up. A softner will, over time dissolve away the scale and your hot water heating will be noticably quicker and more fuel efficient.

Simpo Two

91,503 posts

289 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Ferg said:
ee bypass valves above...
Agreed although trickier to use if the device is working and all you want is glass of water smile

hiscocks

322 posts

207 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
I develop my own black and white film and I have been advised that softened water is good for the final rinse, so it's going to be quite useful!

Paul Drawmer

5,120 posts

291 months

Monday 7th February 2011
quotequote all
Ferg said:
...The hard water tap issue is the reason why your kettle will STILL scale.......Mr.Drawmer!
Doh! see, I forgot already!

Ferg said:
Don't be fooled, incidentally, by claims that your heating system will benefit. Since it uses the same water unless you need to drain it this is just bks, but is used by some companies as a 'selling' point.
Never having cut a cylinder open, won't the 'outside' of the boiler coil get well coated in a few years? And what happens to combi heat exchangers? Does the expansion/contraction blow off the limescale?