Alfa 145 as first car - advice/opinions please.
Alfa 145 as first car - advice/opinions please.
Author
Discussion

mrtwisty

Original Poster:

3,057 posts

196 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
My mate (27 y/o) has just passed his test and is 'dead set' on a 145 1.6 as his first car. He is looking to spend roughly a bag of sand on the car and the same on insurance, but after that funds will not be too abundant. I have a bit of spannering ability and wouldn't mind doing a bit of weekend tinkering from time to time if necessary. He is aware that he will probably have to wait a good few months for a decent one to pop up nearby and (claims) he is willing to wait. Also he walks to work at the 'mo, so wouldn't have to rely on it as such...
So... what does PH think?

mrtwisty

Original Poster:

3,057 posts

196 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
bump

morgrp

4,128 posts

229 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Heap of st - avoid.

Especially if he hasn't got the cash to run it

Opara

506 posts

201 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Has he checked on insurance? I'm 28 and just passed and was expecting insurance to be alot more reasonable, I was wrong.A grand on an Alfa seems optimistic.

base

321 posts

211 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
I owned a 145 cloverleaf years ago for about 4 years very good car, never spent more than routine servicing items on it. buy on condition. and i dont think they are a heap of ste.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
"Alfa", "cheap" and "first car" do not generally go well in a sentence together. He'll be buying a high mileage example of a marque that even enthusiasts would say is "characterful". It won't be a cheap car by any stretch. Try and move him towards something small, slow and cheap for his first car if he wants to motor on a budget.

mrtwisty

Original Poster:

3,057 posts

196 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Cheers for the input guys, keep it coming...

Jw Vw

4,927 posts

194 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
A cheap Alfa eh? hmmm, well here's my take on it.

The model is known to be unreliable, it is likely to go wrong and when it does it will be expensive to put right, insurance prices will be high, to me it is a money pit waiting to happen so avoid like the plague.

lance1a

1,337 posts

229 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
I've had two and loved them both. Variators on the twin spark models are a pain and make sure they are done along with cambelt, which is the main area of concern.

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Cheap to buy, but budget for brekages. You may be lucky, but more than likely you will need an account with your local motor factors.
I bought a W reg 145 Cloverleaf for £600 a couple of years ago and ran it for a couple of months and 3000 miles with no problems before selling it for £600.
I wasnt so lucky with a 156 with the same engine though, still only paid £600 and drove great.



Edited by nottyash on Sunday 13th February 13:45


Edited by nottyash on Sunday 13th February 13:48

LuS1fer

43,568 posts

276 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Come on, lads, what exactly are you expecting for a grand? I had a look at a 146 and it seemed fairly sound bar a bit of welding that had been done on the rear floor (though I have a view once welded, it's going to keep going).

I ended up buying a Mk III Golf GTI for £750 but come on - gear linkage, new tyres, new rear discs, pads and bearings (one side twice), clutch cable snapped, clutch cable retaining clip snapped, exhaust back box fell off, ABS sensor failed, front spring broke - all require money to fix and that's something that was supposed to be reliable.

k-ink

9,070 posts

210 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
I've owned two Cloverleaf 145 Alfa's. No issues with either. £2k will buy a minter. So an example for a grand would be better than many here suggest. Last of the raw huge fun Alfa's. Way better fun than my 147 GTA. Go for it!

k-ink

9,070 posts

210 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Also bear in mind a similar condition golf would cost you twice as much as the Alfa. Only due to everyone being sheep and copying each other, inflating VW prices. So a 1k 145 would be similar to a 2k golf. Well that was the case when I was buying and selling mine anyway.

edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
no such thing as a cheap bag of sand alfa. madness.

robsco

7,875 posts

207 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Tell him to go for it, I should've gone down the Alfa route instead of the Seat I ended up buying.

Si 330

1,306 posts

240 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Don't how many of these doom mongers have actually owned one.
There a great hot or in the case of the 1.6 warm hatch. I loved the cloverleaf one I had 3 years of ownership nothing other than routine servicing.
With any car at the 1K mark you get problems.

VeeFour

3,339 posts

193 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
So long as you keep an eye on the oil levels and change the cambelt every 36k miles / 3 years, it'll be fine.

They're not massively complicated cars and the unreliability reputation came from the stretched belt change intervals originally quoted to keep fleet managers happy and company car drivers not checking the oil. (In the mid 90s Alfa were heavily pushing the 145/146 and 156 to fleets).

Anything in tidy condition with history that's still running today is likely to be a very nice example.

Try to get 'Junior' spec., if you can, as it came with some extra toys over standard cars.

Lovely, thrashable, old-school warm / hot hatches! (Even the 1.6 came with 120bhp and they weigh very little, so are more than a match for 'hot' offerings from elsewhere).

GoBig

377 posts

204 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
I had a 145 Cloverleaf for a few years recently and loved every minute of it.

Had no major problems with it, just regular oil change and service.

There are a few good ones about, and has been said check that the cambelt has been done as per recommendation.

I can honestly say that it put a smile on my face each time I drove it.

My OH didn't get it, but it was just so uncomplicated, if that makes any sense.

Dino D

1,953 posts

252 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Mk III Golf GTI for £750 but come on - that's something that was supposed to be reliable.
Golfs are not know for reliability for those 'in the know'. Germans cars somehow maintain this image but are are a little less crap than Italian and French.

morgrp

4,128 posts

229 months

Saturday 12th February 2011
quotequote all
Dino D said:
Golfs are not know for reliability for those 'in the know'. Germans cars somehow maintain this image but are are a little less crap than Italian and French.
I'm a vw fan and even I will concede the mkIII golf is a heap of st - easily the worst of the golf breed. They are a lot like mercedes - everyone assumed they were bullet proof and over engineered when in actual fact most built between around 1994 and 2003 were rust prone unreliable dogs. They had slashed a third of the budget for engineering of the cars and sold the cars on their existing reputation - fortunately they appear to be back on the right track now