Swirl Flaps - Garage Quotes
Discussion
Just rang 2 BMW indys in Manchester and had 2 very different methods to get rid of the Swirl Flaps on my E46 320d.
BMTec in the city centre quoted me £110+VAT. This consists of 2 hours labour, no parts required. They take out the swirl flaps, break off the vavles and fill the hole on the original flap with a silicon glue and refit.
Baymow in Stockport quoted £190+VAT. They remove the swirl flaps and refit aluminium blanking plates in their place. I imagine the parts cost around £50 (price taken from PMW) but this still leaves ~£180 in labour charges.
My head says get the blanking plates fitted for peace of mind but the cost seem a bit excessive. Any thoughts?
BMTec in the city centre quoted me £110+VAT. This consists of 2 hours labour, no parts required. They take out the swirl flaps, break off the vavles and fill the hole on the original flap with a silicon glue and refit.
Baymow in Stockport quoted £190+VAT. They remove the swirl flaps and refit aluminium blanking plates in their place. I imagine the parts cost around £50 (price taken from PMW) but this still leaves ~£180 in labour charges.
My head says get the blanking plates fitted for peace of mind but the cost seem a bit excessive. Any thoughts?
MattOz said:
First quote sounds iffy. Why on earth would you fill the hole with gloop? Second quote is better. At least they're actually using a blanker. It takes about an hour to do if you've done it before, but double that for the first time.
That's what put me off about the first quote, plus he wasn't the most polite person on the phone.Baymow have certainly done the job before. It seems like they want to charge for around 3 hours labour though.
I've decided (with the help of a friend) to order the blanking plates from PMW and undertake the job ourselves.
PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
mjcneat said:
I've decided (with the help of a friend) to order the blanking plates from PMW and undertake the job ourselves.
PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
Can you guide me on the EGR and the breather? These are things I am unaware of. I plan to do my swirl flaps as well. The trouble is that they might have been done already by a previous ownwer, but I cant see in to find out without taking manifold off!PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
Alistair H. said:
Can you guide me on the EGR and the breather? These are things I am unaware of. I plan to do my swirl flaps as well. The trouble is that they might have been done already by a previous ownwer, but I cant see in to find out without taking manifold off!
EGR valve may just need cleaning. It's included in the Swirl Flaps guide. http://www.bimmerforums.co.uk/forum/f3/e46-320td-3...Vortex breather - http://www.bimmerforums.co.uk/forum/f3/replacing-t...
Thanks.
Mines the 3 litre 530d engine. so its a little different. The point I was making is it seems impossible to check if they have been done by a previous ownwer without actualy taking the manifold off. I guess Im just lazy! - I dont want to order the blanking plates take it all to bits to find it already done!
Mines the 3 litre 530d engine. so its a little different. The point I was making is it seems impossible to check if they have been done by a previous ownwer without actualy taking the manifold off. I guess Im just lazy! - I dont want to order the blanking plates take it all to bits to find it already done!
Hi all - my first post here.
Recently bought a 530d 2004 80k miles.
Did all the reading on the common faults, swirl flaps, breathers, thermostats EGR etc.
Must admit to being a little anxious about the swirl flaps in particular.
Anyway did the flaps job today and the EGR stat while I was at it. Not too bad a job, if you have a good set of tools to hand.
Finally pulled the inlet manifold, got it on the bench and had a good look.
F***** ME!
5 flaps working ok, but 1 had lost one of the fixings screws.
It was twisted and didn't operate with the rest.
As it was jammed against the side, it wasn't possible to pull the whole flap out of the manifold.
I reached in with a finger to see if it would rotate and the bloody thing fell off.
The shaft sheared just where the second screw was. No force applied at all.
Seems the car has ingested one screw in the past and got away with it.
It was only a gnats fart from taking the whole flap in.
With all the crud that accumulates in the manifold, it's easy to see at a glance these flaps are no
Where near strong enough in construction.
A run after the job showed there is no noticeable difference pulling away
as everyone else seems to report.
If you are even thinking about checking the flaps on your motor, DO IT NOW!
Don't bother with blanking plates - why waste money?
A 6mm self tapper screw will wind in nicely where you remove the shaft from the existing plugs. They will screw into the plastic nicely and seal perfectly. Add a blob of araldite to the head of the screw for further peace of mind.
I have shivers just thinking how close this was!
Recently bought a 530d 2004 80k miles.
Did all the reading on the common faults, swirl flaps, breathers, thermostats EGR etc.
Must admit to being a little anxious about the swirl flaps in particular.
Anyway did the flaps job today and the EGR stat while I was at it. Not too bad a job, if you have a good set of tools to hand.
Finally pulled the inlet manifold, got it on the bench and had a good look.
F***** ME!
5 flaps working ok, but 1 had lost one of the fixings screws.
It was twisted and didn't operate with the rest.
As it was jammed against the side, it wasn't possible to pull the whole flap out of the manifold.
I reached in with a finger to see if it would rotate and the bloody thing fell off.
The shaft sheared just where the second screw was. No force applied at all.
Seems the car has ingested one screw in the past and got away with it.
It was only a gnats fart from taking the whole flap in.
With all the crud that accumulates in the manifold, it's easy to see at a glance these flaps are no
Where near strong enough in construction.
A run after the job showed there is no noticeable difference pulling away
as everyone else seems to report.
If you are even thinking about checking the flaps on your motor, DO IT NOW!
Don't bother with blanking plates - why waste money?
A 6mm self tapper screw will wind in nicely where you remove the shaft from the existing plugs. They will screw into the plastic nicely and seal perfectly. Add a blob of araldite to the head of the screw for further peace of mind.
I have shivers just thinking how close this was!
Edited by Fivedirty on Saturday 11th February 19:38
Edited by Fivedirty on Saturday 11th February 19:40
Cheib said:
I must have had muy head in the sand....never read about swirl flaps before! I've got a X5 3.0 SD that I bought new in 2007....I still have the BMW warranty so presumably covered. Having said that....does my car have them ?
You have the 335/535 Twin Turbo, nowt to worry about.Alistair H. said:
mjcneat said:
I've decided (with the help of a friend) to order the blanking plates from PMW and undertake the job ourselves.
PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
Can you guide me on the EGR and the breather? These are things I am unaware of. I plan to do my swirl flaps as well. The trouble is that they might have been done already by a previous ownwer, but I cant see in to find out without taking manifold off!PMW seem very helpful over the phone and very good prices as well.
I've read around and might as well sort out any other little jobs whilst doing the swirl flaps.
Can anyone suggest any common problems that may need doing? I've got so far:
- Replace crackcase breather with vortex type
- Clean EGR valve
- Remvoe swirl flaps
Thanks in advance.
Give Peter or Daniel a ring 01245 496739
www.pmwltd.co.uk
Lots of swirlflap info here
I'm in Nero in Chelmsford, car is at PMW. Will pick it up at 10:30 or so.
Freaked out last night reading about loss of torque and mpg after swirl flap removal. But this seems to be more talked about on E60/E90 engines, not the E39/E46. Even so less torque and mpg is preferable to a massive repair bill, but would be a shame as I like the performance/economy balance of the E39 530d. Can anyone post their experiences?
Having said that I don't have all of my pixels in the dash (next job) and only had the car for a few weeks so I probably won't notice anyway!
Freaked out last night reading about loss of torque and mpg after swirl flap removal. But this seems to be more talked about on E60/E90 engines, not the E39/E46. Even so less torque and mpg is preferable to a massive repair bill, but would be a shame as I like the performance/economy balance of the E39 530d. Can anyone post their experiences?
Having said that I don't have all of my pixels in the dash (next job) and only had the car for a few weeks so I probably won't notice anyway!
Esseesse said:
I'm in Nero in Chelmsford, car is at PMW. Will pick it up at 10:30 or so.
Freaked out last night reading about loss of torque and mpg after swirl flap removal. But this seems to be more talked about on E60/E90 engines, not the E39/E46. Even so less torque and mpg is preferable to a massive repair bill, but would be a shame as I like the performance/economy balance of the E39 530d. Can anyone post their experiences?
Having said that I don't have all of my pixels in the dash (next job) and only had the car for a few weeks so I probably won't notice anyway!
makes no difference to torque and only a minor one top mpg when idling only.Freaked out last night reading about loss of torque and mpg after swirl flap removal. But this seems to be more talked about on E60/E90 engines, not the E39/E46. Even so less torque and mpg is preferable to a massive repair bill, but would be a shame as I like the performance/economy balance of the E39 530d. Can anyone post their experiences?
Having said that I don't have all of my pixels in the dash (next job) and only had the car for a few weeks so I probably won't notice anyway!
Esseesse said:
...Freaked out last night reading about loss of torque and mpg after swirl flap removal....
Made no difference on my old one(2.0d) at all, response, torque, mpg etc, all the same.When I was picking the Mini up from TWG in Camberley the other day an E70 3.0d was in for a flapectomy and talking to the garage owner he said it's a common request. Quoted £180ish for my current car (3.0d) which I will do when the warranty runs out.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



