Automatic gearbox on a mk1?
Automatic gearbox on a mk1?
Author
Discussion

WhoreSaab

Original Poster:

3,019 posts

241 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
I've been offered a 1.6 h reg mk1 in part exchange For my Saab, it looks in good shape (owner is on ph) but it comes with an auto box.

What is the box like? Does it destroy the nature of the car etc? Will it explode if you look at it too hard?

Also how much would you value a v spec eunos with 90k on the clock?

piefacemate

592 posts

194 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
I've never driven one so can't comment, other than to say one of the strengths of the MX5 is it's superb gearchange and the need to work the gears to get the bets out of the engine. I'd imagine an auto will destroy the character of the car somewhat.

If it's cheap enough, however, perhaps you could convert it? Although manual boxes are cheap, I don't know how much of a pain it would be. Mine was originally an automatic and was converted to manual when being turbocharged.

Baryonyx

18,225 posts

182 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
Yes, one of the most exciting aspects of the car is the slick gear change and the adjustability of the throttle which makes smooth, swift changes a real pleasure. That and the fact the engine responds so well to being driven well, and the MX5 is one of those cars where you have to plan ahead and monitor your gearing when you're pressing on lead me to suspect an auto box would rob the car of some of it's charm.

I was just thinking about this when I was driving home from work tonight, as I marvelled at the position of the gearstick relative to your seating position and how short and precise the shift is. It's one of those things that make the MX5 an unforgettable car.

WhoreSaab

Original Poster:

3,019 posts

241 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
I get that it's a travesty but would really appreciate a view from someone who has driven both smile

Munter

31,330 posts

264 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
Not driven the auto. But there are changes to the engine as well as fitting the auto box. Slightly different cam or something. Which I presume they did to make the engine more suited to an auto.

piefacemate

592 posts

194 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
Munter said:
Not driven the auto. But there are changes to the engine as well as fitting the auto box. Slightly different cam or something. Which I presume they did to make the engine more suited to an auto.
Different compression ratio if I remember rightly, but not sure what else or what effect it had.

MX-5 Lazza

7,954 posts

242 months

Tuesday 1st March 2011
quotequote all
A bit less top end power but a bit more mid-range and low down torque.
If you don't need an auto then hold out for a manual, there are plenty around so don't compromise. If you do need an Auto then from what I've heard the one in the MX5 is supposed to be pretty good and is very strong i.e. they don't break when you FI up to silly power wink