Another what car
Author
Discussion

obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
I am looking to replace my Passat tdi snotter with something sporty.

I've done the jap turbo thing before and although the speed is fun, there's no engine noise to get me excited.

Budget is 7k, insurance not really a problem. However I'm no good with spanners so must be reliable although I only do about 100miles a week these days.

Current ideas are an Alfa GTA or Alfa GTV bit the GTV must have the cup styling. RX-7, I know its a jap turbo but they sound and look pretty good. Reliability is an issue with these suggestions though.

Other ideas are an Integrn (newer shape) or an S2000.

Problem with S2000 is only 2 seats and I do need 4 seats on occasion but could potentially borrow my GFs on such occasions.

Any other options/thoughts on the above?

Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
156 GTA out of that lot.

Had mine for 18 mths and aside from regular servicing was impeccable. No reliabilty woes whatsoever. Had 80 odd K on the clock when it went

obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Stuey145 said:
156 GTA out of that lot.

Had mine for 18 mths and aside from regular servicing was impeccable. No reliabilty woes whatsoever. Had 80 odd K on the clock when it went
Didn't know there was a 156 GTA, did you have the Q2 diff?

Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
nope. though that was on the cards if I had kept it.

Awesome awesome car for what you can get them for now. Those I know with the Q2 diff and uprated ARBs have said the transformation was well worth the £4-600

Practical too. And on a long run easily returns over 30mpg.

Lovely to drive, lovely to listen to, lovely interior.

Just .........lovely! (the 156 is a better drive than the 147 version. Although that's a fab car too!)

Try and get a test drive in one and you'll see.

obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
What's the difference between the 147 and 156 other then the obvious that makes it better to drive?

TRUENOSAM

763 posts

199 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Another vote for the 156 GTA. Absolute belter of a car

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
S2000

You want something reliable, that rules out the Alfas. I'm a former Alfa (155,156) and S2000 owner and of the three it's no contest.

You'll find a way when you need 4 seats, something like - 'Get a taxi mate!'.


Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
obob said:
What's the difference between the 147 and 156 other then the obvious that makes it better to drive?
The 156 chassis is far more capable of handling the grunt than the 147 chassis.

And that's really bout it.

(and the amount that still think the 156 is a coupe is laughable)



obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
MrLou said:
S2000

You want something reliable, that rules out the Alfas. I'm a former Alfa (155,156) and S2000 owner and of the three it's no contest.

You'll find a way when you need 4 seats, something like - 'Get a taxi mate!'.
"get a taxi dad, who cares if you're ill" - doesn't sound as good. But as I said I can borrow a car (gf doesn't live with me so its not as easy as sharing cars with your missus)

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
obob said:
MrLou said:
S2000

You want something reliable, that rules out the Alfas. I'm a former Alfa (155,156) and S2000 owner and of the three it's no contest.

You'll find a way when you need 4 seats, something like - 'Get a taxi mate!'.
"get a taxi dad, who cares if you're ill" - doesn't sound as good. But as I said I can borrow a car (gf doesn't live with me so its not as easy as sharing cars with your missus)
If he's ill he can get the taxpayers taxi smile

But, seriously, I bought the S2000 in a time when I had hardly any responsibilities, out of all the previous cars I've had it's the first one I'd go back to. If only you could get 2 child seats in smile

Summer is nearly here, beat the rush and snap one up, sell it in mid-September while the sun is still out and you'll probably get close to your money back.



obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
MrLou said:
obob said:
MrLou said:
S2000

You want something reliable, that rules out the Alfas. I'm a former Alfa (155,156) and S2000 owner and of the three it's no contest.

You'll find a way when you need 4 seats, something like - 'Get a taxi mate!'.
"get a taxi dad, who cares if you're ill" - doesn't sound as good. But as I said I can borrow a car (gf doesn't live with me so its not as easy as sharing cars with your missus)
If he's ill he can get the taxpayers taxi smile

But, seriously, I bought the S2000 in a time when I had hardly any responsibilities, out of all the previous cars I've had it's the first one I'd go back to. If only you could get 2 child seats in smile

Summer is nearly here, beat the rush and snap one up, sell it in mid-September while the sun is still out and you'll probably get close to your money back.
Can't buy until May. I'm thinking S2000 whilst I've still got minimal responsibilities. Can always get an Alfa v6 a bit later.
But then I think well get the Alfa as it's a better 1 car solution and get the s2000 when I can afford to run 2 cars.


Decisions decisions. Someone make it for me.

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
obob said:
Can't buy until May. I'm thinking S2000 whilst I've still got minimal responsibilities. Can always get an Alfa v6 a bit later.
But then I think well get the Alfa as it's a better 1 car solution and get the s2000 when I can afford to run 2 cars.


Decisions decisions. Someone make it for me.
Get the S2000 now. Running 2 cars sounds like a good idea but in reality running 2 nice cars isn't easy. Our 2nd car when we had the S2000 was an M plate Mondeo with nearly 120k on.

You'll regret the Alfa when it leaves you stranded somewhere.

Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
MrLou said:
You'll regret the Alfa when it leaves you stranded somewhere.
load of old toss.

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Stuey145 said:
MrLou said:
You'll regret the Alfa when it leaves you stranded somewhere.
load of old toss.
Mine left me stranded. I did regret it.
So, not load of old toss.

Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
any car CAN. Including Hondas

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Stuey145 said:
any car CAN. Including Hondas
You got me!

However since 1993 the only 2 cars that have stranded me were Alfas.

I loved them both, especially the day they went, but if I had to choose between a 159/147 or an S2000, it's a no-contest.

The S2000 is prettier, quicker, more fun, more reliable, more desirable and a whole load of other mores that I can't think of.




Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
The only time that any of the Alfas I've owned over the years has let me down was a knackered radiator (made in Germany I believe) but it was the original one and it had done 137k miles at that stage

obob

Original Poster:

4,193 posts

223 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
MrLou said:
Stuey145 said:
any car CAN. Including Hondas
You got me!

However since 1993 the only 2 cars that have stranded me were Alfas.

I loved them both, especially the day they went, but if I had to choose between a 159/147 or an S2000, it's a no-contest.

The S2000 is prettier, quicker, more fun, more reliable, more desirable and a whole load of other mores that I can't think of.
Doesn't sound as good though!

Stuey145

274 posts

187 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
keep thinking like that.

Sure the Honda is a very good car. But a thumping, throbbing, snarling Alfa V6 is aural nirvana.

MrLou

879 posts

250 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Stuey145 said:
The only time that any of the Alfas I've owned over the years has let me down was a knackered radiator (made in Germany I believe) but it was the original one and it had done 137k miles at that stage
Fair enough.

I don't want to drag this thread away from the OPs original question so I'll hold my jabber from here on.