Young driver insurance
Author
Discussion

grgrgray

Original Poster:

790 posts

197 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
Just spotted this:

http://www.co-operative.coop/corporate/Press/Press...

Doesn't apply to me (at 46) but seems like a good idea for younger drivers!

LukeSi

5,780 posts

190 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
I wonder what would happen if you went on a track day. Your driving: Hard acceleration, Extreme braking, sharp cornering, over posted limits, etc.

Haytch

183 posts

189 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
Surely driving only at 2am should make your insurance cheaper than driving at 7-9am and 5-7pm. But I guess not. It's been discussed before, if someone has had to slam on there brakes to avoid an accident there insurance will cost more. Will not work.

grgrgray

Original Poster:

790 posts

197 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
"However, if a policyholder consistently drives badly, for example repeatedly breaking speed limits or taking corners too sharply, then their insurance premium could increase by 15% of the initial policy price."

The key word is consistently. Seems to be lots of threads here at the moment from sensible 17 yr olds who just want a car to get to work or college. This seems to be a way to reduce the premiums to palatable levels.



edited for to many sensibles

Edited by grgrgray on Sunday 27th March 14:01

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
Haytch said:
Surely driving only at 2am should make your insurance cheaper than driving at 7-9am and 5-7pm. But I guess not. It's been discussed before, if someone has had to slam on there brakes to avoid an accident there insurance will cost more. Will not work.
Driving round maccidees at 2 in the morning doing donuts wouldn't be safer than driving to work I think..

I am glad I never had a box like this..


HBFS

803 posts

220 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
black pipebandit said:
Driving round maccidees at 2 in the morning doing donuts wouldn't be safer than driving to work I think..

I am glad I never had a box like this..
+ Young teenagers tend to drink alcohol and go to house party's in the late hours/early morning. And sometimes, it gets mixed up.

Slade Alive

784 posts

188 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
It's a worrying trend. If this catches on how long before we're all offered it? More to the point how long before we're all refused insurance until we accept it? Is this a back door in to more motoring intrusion I wonder.

As for 17 yo's saving 11%. Is that it? £2000 policy doesn't sound good when £200 buys a lot more fun than a paltry saving will make a youngster happy me thinks.

Spree

73 posts

219 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
I've only been driving six years and could probably just about qualify for this for one year but I don't think it's a good idea at all, especially for inexperienced drivers.
They aren't very clear on how how regular they deem bad driving to be 'consistent'. I can imagine inexperienced drivers thinking they mustn't brake in fear of their premiums rising regardless of whether a car pulls out in front of them or a child runs out. If it's difficult to join a motorway they may be worried about getting up to speed again if it's going to cost them and this could make it a nightmare for other road users.
If it was a more intelligent system with the ability to judge each situation and determine whether the driver was actually at fault it might be better but I still wouldn't want it myself.
It seems to me that it's just a clever way of charging people more while spying on them in the process.

LeeThr

3,122 posts

200 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
Dont think this would really work for me if im honest. If anything my premiums would go through the roof.

What im not saying is I drive like an absolute tt. Just I drive at all times day or night, no consitancy what so ever. Also there is the odd B road which I do like the odd spirited drive along. I dont go over the limits, but I do tend to keep higher speed up through the corners if I can. Always stick to my limits and dont push it more than I feel I can, but im sure these boxes would report back to HQ im being an absolute arse and should be going around these corners at about 5mph holding up everyone behind me who also wish to make progress.

As good an idea as it seems. The only people who I honestly can see these working for, are the one's who can litterally only just pass there test, are absolutly terrified behind the wheel and do 20mph everywhere. Who are even more likely to be part of an accident.

Talk2Dave

104 posts

207 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
it would have to be alot cheaper than the avergae price of young drivers insurance before i'd even consider it.

Haytch

183 posts

189 months

Sunday 27th March 2011
quotequote all
black pipebandit said:
Driving round maccidees at 2 in the morning doing donuts wouldn't be safer than driving to work I think..

I am glad I never had a box like this..
I've had more idiots nearly crashing into me on my daily commute than at 2am. The situation you mention would obviously be more dangerous but people need to understand were not all like that smile