Rolex as an investment?
Rolex as an investment?
Author
Discussion

Simon Bags

Original Poster:

680 posts

206 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Morning People. I planted a thread on the finance section not so long ago, asking for advice on where, how, and what type, to buy gold. I only wanted say a Krugerrand or so, part for the niceness of actually having something gold to have and hold, and partly for a potential investment?

Had loads of great replies and hints but someone did mention (and although I think it was only tongue in cheek) that it maybe worth just buying a new Rolex, stick it in a box with all the papers, enjoy it for what it is but it has been known for these to actually go up in value?

Is this a myth? Complete pish, or is there some actual merit to this?

Thanks, Simon.

Importr

111 posts

225 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
As far as I know, the only Rolex's which increase in value are the Vintages (1980s and older).

You'd be better to buy a Vintage and store that.

LordGrover

34,189 posts

243 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Difficult to enjoy it in the box.
Probably not the best investment anyway.

Zingari

947 posts

204 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
I think the days of a good return on a 'new' Rolex are over. It is also difficult to predict what will be collectable in the years to come given that Rolex do not release limited editions. Panerai (not for everyone as they are big) have a following and some of their limited editions make a profit of five-fold (PAM360) if you can manage to buy one in the first place.

As others have said it is the vintage ones that have the potential but as most people now know the market value (and the London Arcade dealers make their prices up by +50%) you are not going to get any bargains.

Avoid gold models stainless steel sport Rolex are the ones. The best you can hope for is a small return after many years so wear it knowing that you will at least get your money back AND be able to wear a nice watch. They also go in and out of fashion - Daytona was always sought after with a long waiting list v good profit but now you can buy one straight from a AD.

Best buy at the moment is seadweller as there was a rumour this was to be deleted following the introduction of Deep Sea. However the DS has not taken off so it will be interesting to see how they fair in the future - could go the same way as the original Milgauss?

I can remember in the early 80s buying my first Rolex and the Milgauss was featured in the catalogue with its ability to witstand strong magnetic fields - who the feck was going to buy one of them I thought? well I wish I had! Same thoughts over GMT with large hand!

We live and learn! I'm content that my 18yr old battered Submariner is still worth more than I paid for it - but then again I'll never sell it.

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
If you want to buy a Rolex to wear and enjoy it go for it, as a pure investment there are better safer places to put your money.
Effectively you are speculating on the fashion market, what will be "in" in 5/10 or 20 years.
Have you seen what 70's & 80's dress Rolex's are making at the moment? You can, if you try, get a decent condition Air King for less than £1k... probably no more than it cost new, if you take inflation etc into account.
The only Rolex I would get to "invest" in is a 2nd hand 80's or 90's stainless steel Sub/ Seadweller with black face, chances are you will always find a buyer for one and maintain the purchase price if nothing else...

RemainAllHoof

80,183 posts

313 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
The only Rolex I would get to "invest" in is a 2nd hand 80's or 90's stainless steel Sub/ Seadweller with black face, chances are you will always find a buyer for one and maintain the purchase price if nothing else...
This is true... if you ignore the regular £500(?) services.

Simon Bags

Original Poster:

680 posts

206 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies everyone, kind of confirmed my suspicions. Besides, if it were true that Rolex's bring back enormous returns, everyone would be doing it.

I think I'll stick to my Krugerrand thought.

Simon.


Maxf

8,444 posts

272 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
They can bring HUGE returns - but you need to put in an incredible amount of legwork and be rather lucky.

These Milsubs selling for £60-120k at the moment... how much do we think they were originally bought from their 'issued' owners for? Maybe the same goes for the Comex Sea Dwellers.


Mr E Driver

8,542 posts

215 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Beware if buying a Sea Dweller or a Submariner because there are lots of different models determined by their number, with different dials all with a variety of values/prices.
Going for one that has not had the dial and hands changed at a Rolex service centre will be worth more than a regularly serviced and updated one.
Be careful that the 'old watch' does not have a fake dial to make it look like a rare model and worth more than it really is.
If you buy one wear and enjoy wearing it as the odd scratch and mark won't make much difference.
If you send it to Rolex for service make sure they don't change the hands and face.

audidoody

8,598 posts

287 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
I was the genius who gave you the original advice, and you're right. It was given with a bit of tongue in cheek.

I suppose the point I was making was that if you were going to take a punt on Gold, a Rolex could be just as much fun as an investment.

Rolex retail prices only ever go up. So the logic suggests that you'll always get your money back and hopefully a bit more of you buy wisely (as suggested here). Gold prices will likely continue to rise but could also fall. And there's not much you can do with gold coins until you sell them except keep them in a vault or hide them in your shoe when you need to grab the last Dakota out of Mogadishu or are attacked by an agent of SPECTER on the night train from Istanbul to Venice.

As an example, I bought a 16030 S/S Datejust in 1987 for £800 which would now fetch IRO £1,300 and a pre-owned GMT in 2003 for £1,900 (now worth around £2,800'ish) Sure, the same money been invested in a no-risk savings account would have achieved the same gain, but it wouldn't have given half the enjoyment.

On the other hand, £800 of gold bought in 1987 would now be worth £3,200 (there's an App for that) . Still not enough to buy a new Rolex!


Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
When looking at investment consider the impact of inflation. Has an asset actually outpaced inflation?

Watches only have a relatively short history, maybe 80 years ago people considered pocket watches to be an investment, however the wrist watch destroyed their popularity. Will a Rolex be desirable in 50 years time?

Gold has a somewhat longer track record.

Basically a Rolex may or may not be a solid long term investment but it's not exactly the right place for widow and orphans to invest their life savings.

Edited by Fittster on Wednesday 6th April 16:15

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Don't bother buying a Rolex for investment purposes, they're overpriced, mass-produced rubbish. If you like watches your better off with a more special watch brands like Audemars, Jaeger-LeCoultre, Blancpain, Patek etc. Not saying they'll make a fantastic investment but at least you'll have a decent watch on your wrist.

Simon Bags

Original Poster:

680 posts

206 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
audidoody said:
I was the genius who gave you the original advice, and you're right. It was given with a bit of tongue in cheek.

I suppose the point I was making was that if you were going to take a punt on Gold, a Rolex could be just as much fun as an investment.

Rolex retail prices only ever go up. So the logic suggests that you'll always get your money back and hopefully a bit more of you buy wisely (as suggested here). Gold prices will likely continue to rise but could also fall. And there's not much you can do with gold coins until you sell them except keep them in a vault or hide them in your shoe when you need to grab the last Dakota out of Mogadishu or are attacked by an agent of SPECTER on the night train from Istanbul to Venice.

As an example, I bought a 16030 S/S Datejust in 1987 for £800 which would now fetch IRO £1,300 and a pre-owned GMT in 2003 for £1,900 (now worth around £2,800'ish) Sure, the same money been invested in a no-risk savings account would have achieved the same gain, but it wouldn't have given half the enjoyment.

On the other hand, £800 of gold bought in 1987 would now be worth £3,200 (there's an App for that) . Still not enough to buy a new Rolex!
I guess it's all really about having a punt at something. If it works, great, if it doesn't then hopefully you'll still be able to enjoy what you've punted for. I'm not overly worried about it being an investment, just always fancied something, um, well, gold really, coin, 1g bar, that sort of thing.

I think I'll do some more investigation. Especially as far as buying a slither over the net is concerned.

Cheers for all your help.

Simon.

DS3R

13,528 posts

197 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
audidoody said:
Rolex retail prices only ever go up. So the logic suggests that you'll always get your money back and hopefully a bit more of you buy wisely (as suggested here).

As an example, I bought a 16030 S/S Datejust in 1987 for £800 which would now fetch IRO £1,300 and a pre-owned GMT in 2003 for £1,900 (now worth around £2,800'ish) Sure, the same money been invested in a no-risk savings account would have achieved the same gain, but it wouldn't have given half the enjoyment.
What about servicing costs? How would they affect the return? I guess your maths also assumes the watch is in perfect condition. Which is a shame, as it may mean it really would have to sit in a box doing nothing.

Is the answer to buy TWO Rolexes (Rolex, Rolex's, Roli?!?), one to wear and not worry if it gets scratched, and the other to sit in a box. And if it sits there long enough, maybe it will be worth as much as the two originally cost!

RemainAllHoof

80,183 posts

313 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Simon Bags said:
audidoody said:
the enjoyment.
enjoy
Not much enjoyment if you keep it hidden in a box. If you wear it, you risk damaging your investment (whether it's scratches, grazes, a chip to the crystal or a full-on smack that stops it working) plus have to service it regularly. At best, expect to get your money back, I would say. Watches are not something for the amateur to invest in. That said, you might find a 1969 Speedmaster for sale in a local charity shop for just £50. In which case, buy it.

I do have some "investment" watches but I bought them to wear and so I wear them and don't really mind losing money on them if they gain the odd scratch...

Adrian W

15,623 posts

259 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
The right Daytona would be a good investment, say up to 1998 with a Zenith movement, the trouble is most people know that,so it is unlikely that you will just stumble across one, it's a bit like speculating on property, most people buy houses to live in, we are not property speculators and it can be dangerous to dabble, you could get burnt, I think most of us are happy that if we decide to sell a watch, we don't loose. stick to what you know, it's safer!

Mr E Driver

8,542 posts

215 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
The right Daytona would be a good investment, say up to 1998 with a Zenith movement, the trouble is most people know that,so it is unlikely that you will just stumble across one, it's a bit like speculating on property, most people buy houses to live in, we are not property speculators and it can be dangerous to dabble, you could get burnt, I think most of us are happy that if we decide to sell a watch, we don't loose. stick to what you know, it's safer!
You lose money buying new and selling within a few years, like cars.

Servicing does not make any difference so long as the watch is running within a few seconds a day or less when you buy though services are part of the provenance.

The Daytona isn't in as much demand as they were. A Sea Dweller or early Sub is a better bet.

Maxf

8,444 posts

272 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
If you have the papers then serviceing really doesnt add much (if the watch is running well) - normally those sold with 'service papers' are sold as such because the original papers have gone missing.

Rolex's don't need regular servicing - this is a myth. I've had my 1988 Date service twice - and the second time was only as I wanted a new dial. I bought a 1978 Submariner which had never been serviced and it ran pretty well. Only service them if you need the papers or they are running badly!

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Maxf said:
If you have the papers then serviceing really doesnt add much (if the watch is running well) - normally those sold with 'service papers' are sold as such because the original papers have gone missing.

Rolex's don't need regular servicing - this is a myth. I've had my 1988 Date service twice - and the second time was only as I wanted a new dial. I bought a 1978 Submariner which had never been serviced and it ran pretty well. Only service them if you need the papers or they are running badly!
+1 I never service a watch unless it has issues, or i want to prove its authenticity.
My 1998 Seamaster has NEVER been serviced, has been beaten worn at least every week and it still performs with in COSC limits.

Gareth135R

565 posts

254 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
In 2006 I bought a Rolex Non Date 1406M from Blowers Jewellers. It was 6months old and cost me £1800.
5 years later it's probably worth £2500 on the used market. They're about £3750 new(?). Gotta love the Rolex prices hikes over the past couple of years.