Car for work and pleasure?
Car for work and pleasure?
Author
Discussion

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
My V6 4motion Golf is slowly getting a little long in the tooth and while it's still a great car with zero mechanical faults, I'm starting to plan out some money to buy its replacement towards the end of the year - house improvements willing smile

I use the car for everything (apart from when I take my partners Anniversary GTI biggrin) which firstly involves a lot more than average miles. In my job I will do around 10,000 miles for work (45p per mile backclap) and probably another 7,000 privately and here in lies the problem: If I was to go for an overtly sporty car then it would likely depreciate like a stone with the amount of miles I'd put on it. The second issue is that I'm too much of a petrolhead to get a A4/3 series diesel and sell my soul to the derv devil. I had an 07 STI for 2 years and put 44,000 miles on that and could get around 30mpg on the motorways with work and whatever I wanted to below that when doing my own thing. This was actually rather cheap to run as far as servicing but with tax being upwards of £450 now that would sting a lot especially as I seem to always match the renewal with my insurance coming up during the same period. And then there is spending £78 to fill up a small tank with appropriate fuel. The final point is that I'm not buying new, mainly to get something that's already had below average miles on it so I can put some on it without feeling guilty and also to save myself some mental depreciation.

So, what is my nirvana?

  • Drivers car (or close as without being a 7 or a Lotus)
  • 200bhp minimum
  • Can get 30mpg on the motorway as a minimum
  • Reliable
  • Low depreciation after buying second hand
  • Something I'd be seen dead in (not Mondeo/Vectra)
  • NOT a 2 seater
  • Ideally 4 doors (unless you can REALLY convince me and the missus)
  • Max purchase price of 20k
Not an easy list of needs but I'm after ideas and you guys are a good place to start.


Cheers,



David

Fleckers

2,880 posts

230 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
sounds like a BMW or VW


Jayho

2,413 posts

199 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Hmmm...

Skoda Fabia VRs or Mk4 Polo GTI is all I can really think of... but they're not 200bhp... 180 in a small car I think?!?! :/

Ohhhh, actually SEAT Leon Cupra R? IDK what tax and petrol would be like for them though! :/

adycav

7,615 posts

246 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
BMW.

130i or 330i if you prefer n/a

135i or 335i if you prefer turbo charged.


All other answers will be wrong.

wink

The Nur

9,168 posts

214 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2597848.htm

The above is my interpretation of the solution to your problem. I suppose it depends on whether a GTI would satisfy your "drivers car" requirements really.

E31Shrew

5,963 posts

221 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Yum yum

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...

The low depreciation bit might be a shocker but I expect there are cheaper models out there


george h

14,714 posts

193 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
The Nur said:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2597848.htm

The above is my interpretation of the solution to your problem. I suppose it depends on whether a GTI would satisfy your "drivers car" requirements really.
Definitely this, all the car you would ever need smile

adycav

7,615 posts

246 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
george h said:
The Nur said:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2597848.htm

The above is my interpretation of the solution to your problem. I suppose it depends on whether a GTI would satisfy your "drivers car" requirements really.
Definitely this, all the car you would ever need smile
Not enough cylinders and wrong wheel drive.

smile

E31Shrew

5,963 posts

221 months

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for the quick responses. Checking the classifieds is always a good pastime smile

I'll add that anything smaller than a Golf is out of the question as it'll need to be a lugger for dogs, kids and an amount of crap from B&Q smile

Jayho

2,413 posts

199 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Ved said:
Thanks for the quick responses. Checking the classifieds is always a good pastime smile

I'll add that anything smaller than a Golf is out of the question as it'll need to be a lugger for dogs, kids and an amount of crap from B&Q smile
Anything smaller than a modern golf? or just anything smaller than say a Mk4 golf? VW seemed to get a bit obese in the past few years, especially Polo's... saw the new one the other day and thought it was a golf for a second! :O

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
The Nur said:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2597848.htm

The above is my interpretation of the solution to your problem. I suppose it depends on whether a GTI would satisfy your "drivers car" requirements really.
A GTI wouldn't be a bad option but not with 40k on it. In 3 years it could have 100k on it although there are a lot of MK5s out there with a lot less. The MK6 is also creeping into shot although the once I tried had that god awful DSG box and made the car utterly unusable in the wet, especially off roundabouts. Manual might be an eye opener.

bga

8,134 posts

280 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
adycav said:
Not enough cylinders and wrong wheel drive.

smile
A better drive than a 130i or 330i though!

adycav

7,615 posts

246 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Ved said:
I'll add that anything smaller than a Golf is out of the question as it'll need to be a lugger for dogs, kids and an amount of crap from B&Q smile
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2686560.htm

306hp.

george h

14,714 posts

193 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
adycav said:
Not enough cylinders and wrong wheel drive.

smile
This should suffice then smile

http://pistonheads.com/sales/2591358.htm

Not sure about the 30+ MPG on the motorway though, guess it shouldn't be too bad

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
The R32 is a good idea. Keeps me with AWD and a V6. Not sure about the mileage but if that's 13k then there might be others out there too. I actually looked at and nearly bought one before my Scooby but VW wouldn't do 12 months tax so said bye bye and had an STI that afternoon.

cruise control

64 posts

186 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
You could do worse than a Passat B6 estate, not hugely fast but quite nippy I personally would recomend the 2.0tdi. the boot is quite big with the seats still up but when they are down... acres of space for lugging stuff for home improvememts

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2676550.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2669939.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2671936.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2671994.htm

the last two have a photo of the boot area look at the size of that!!. and all that car for the money. then there is the economy 50+mpg all day on the motorway cant be bad with the price of fuel the way it is?

Happy car hunting

chrisispringles

893 posts

194 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
cruise control said:
You could do worse than a Passat B6 estate, not hugely fast but quite nippy I personally would recomend the 2.0tdi. the boot is quite big with the seats still up but when they are down... acres of space for lugging stuff for home improvememts

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2676550.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2669939.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2671936.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2671994.htm

the last two have a photo of the boot area look at the size of that!!. and all that car for the money. then there is the economy 50+mpg all day on the motorway cant be bad with the price of fuel the way it is?

Happy car hunting
Well, welcome to PH, but a word of advice; if you post in a what car thread, look at the OPs requirements. Your suggestion fails to meet a few of them, namely pleasure and power.

To OP, what about an Alpina D3, there's a few floating around the classifieds that would fit the bill nicely.

paulmoonraker

2,850 posts

192 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
At the risk of getting beaten up, I would suggest an 05 Impreza WRX PPP. I did 45K over 2 years at 36ppm and it was fine and FUN smile

Bugger, I have just re-read your post, and see that you have owned something similar... Anyway, I stand by what I have said wink

Edited by paulmoonraker on Saturday 9th April 21:58

Ved

Original Poster:

3,949 posts

204 months

Saturday 9th April 2011
quotequote all
Now then Chris, I've always thought about Alpinas. I was left for dead by one after crossing into Wales after the toll bridge and thought, HMMMMM!!! ever since. I don't really like BMWs but you might just be onto something here.

A D3 could fit nicely, although it is a derv wink What else is in the Aplina stable?