Tell me its big enough
Author
Discussion

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

298 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Having come to the conclusion that the current barge has to go, and that I don't like any of the hatchback options out there I am looking at a regular saloon. Prob 3 series or c class.

Thing is all the friends I have with kids are screaming at me to get a 4x4 or estate as we are planning kids as well. Mrs t wants a saloon too but is getting concerned given the fervor of her friends who advocate buying a Toyota landcruiser at the first sign of pregnancy...

So help me out. Tell me that you run a normal sized car and have a family, and that I don't need to buy a citroen Picasso or a range rover sport to cope with a baby.

Pothole

34,367 posts

311 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
What did your parents have?

Why do you care what other people say on the subject? What made them experts? What control experiments are they citing for their misguided conclusions?

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

298 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
I am quite happy. Some references from other normal petrolhead parents would help me balance out the non petrolhead herd mentality of mrs ts friends.

And yes, I am sure like half of the people here I was brought up in a ford escort (we couldn't afford a house) but as we all know nothing is the same die as when we were young. Sweets are now smaller, cars are bigger but have less room inside, and standard baby items are approximately 3x bigger than in the 70s.

Now back to the positive reinforcement....

Pothole

34,367 posts

311 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Sadly, I am unable to help. I have no family and run a large saloon car.

covmutley

3,357 posts

219 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
I have 2 kids and did not want a mpv. Ended up with a v50 which I think looks pretty good. I also prefer the 3 series in estate guise over the saloon. Hope I am not too odd for that, they just seem more handsome and less rep mobile?

Very happy with my v50. Focus size but with practical boot to swallow kid stuff, very comfy, handles ok, great stereo. Way better than a mpv

Leebo77

125 posts

236 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
We've happily run with an Impreza for the last 10 years with 3 kids. Now number 4 is on the way we've had to get something with 7 seats (and kept the Impreza).

Pothole

34,367 posts

311 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Leebo77 said:
We've happily run with an Impreza for the last 10 years with 3 kids. Now number 4 is on the way we've had to get something with 7 seats (and kept the Impreza).
do you have two wives?


Edited by Pothole on Monday 25th April 07:45

BadgerBill

274 posts

268 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
If you fancy a saloon, get one! Blimey, kids might be ages away.

I like estates anyway, but in most cases almost any car is big enough...


....with a top box.

BB

Pferdestarke

7,192 posts

216 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Is there really that much more room in a 4x4, or are you just sitting in the air fearing a roll-over if you swerve on the motorway?

Get a V50, V70, 330d, A4 Avant or a 159. Don't listen to your wife's clueless friends.

Pothole

34,367 posts

311 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Pferdestarke said:
Don't listen to your wife's clueless friends.
Best piece of advice you'll see today.

Leebo77

125 posts

236 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Pothole said:
do you have two wives?
Nope. Why's that?

Pothole

34,367 posts

311 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
see edit.

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

298 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Leebo77 said:
We've happily run with an Impreza for the last 10 years with 3 kids. Now number 4 is on the way we've had to get something with 7 seats (and kept the Impreza).
This is what I want to hear. Saloon or hatch?


Leebo77

125 posts

236 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Pothole said:
see edit.
Aha. 2 baby seats on the rear bench means the middle seat is not really useable...

Bill

58,657 posts

284 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
I prefer estates to saloons anyway.... That said it depends on how much you plan to go away with it in the first six months as they do require a lot of st initially. Particularly if you're visiting people who don't have a spare travel cots and you go for a "travel system" type pram. Once they're past 9 months to a year and are eating what you do and in a forward facing seat you're absolutely laughing.

Re MPVs and faux 4x4s, the raised seating does make loading them easier - a mate of mine said he never understood sprog mobiles until he saw me launching miniBill into the back of the ZTT.

It's a question of compromises, as ever, and depends whether you can cope with packing light and awkward lifting or whether you want to join the other sheep...

LD1Racing

8,493 posts

247 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
We are expecting our first - using it as the perfect excuse to buy a new Discovery 4! Why are you so averse to buying something bigger?

Leebo77

125 posts

236 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
mr_tony said:
This is what I want to hear. Saloon or hatch?
Saloon. Fine day to day but for holidays longer than a long weekend then very tight for room.

paulmoonraker

2,850 posts

192 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Scoobys make great family cars - you should see mine sporting a roof box come summer holidays smile

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

298 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
Pferdestarke said:
Is there really that much more room in a 4x4, or are you just sitting in the air fearing a roll-over if you swerve on the motorway?

Get a V50, V70, 330d, A4 Avant or a 159. Don't listen to your wife's clueless friends.
Agree but this is a saloon vs estate or 4x4. I would happily buy a c63amg estate but apparently this makes us look old....


Pferdestarke

7,192 posts

216 months

Monday 25th April 2011
quotequote all
mr_tony said:
I would happily buy a c63amg estate but apparently this makes us look old....
That's your wife talking for you again. Listen: you're the car nut, main bread winner (probably) and the man of the house. If you can afford a C63 estate go and put a deposit on one today. Don't even consult the wife.

I dread to think what else she tells you to do. I have a wonderful relationship with my partner but in no way would she dream of influencing my car choice within reason.

How the fk does a C63 estate make anyone look old? banghead