Scirocco 2.0 TSI or Bmw 322i?

[rambo123]

Hi guys need some advice... im looking for my next car to buy and after weeks of searching i have broken my choices down to two cars the VW Scirocco 2.0TSI or the BMW 320 or 325i. Would like to know your thoughts on both cars and which one you would personally prefer to own.

[S3000]

my vote is for the VW Scirocco with 2.0 TFSI

[robsco]

I wouldn't go for a 322i. Only on the basis they don't exist.

[Boba Fret]

With the Sirocco as you drive by, people will look at it and think "That's an alright looking, if predictably dullish, VW"

In a 3 series people will look at it, if they notice it and think "c*ck"

Your choice.

[billzeebub]

Scirocco

[Boba Fret]

robsco said:

I wouldn't go for a 322i. Only on the basis they don't exist.

or maybe it's the OP's very subtle way of being indecisive about the oh so dull 320 and the oh so dull 325????

Hmmmmmm.

Or it could just be a really gash typo.

[Heathwood]

Boba Fret said:

With the Sirocco as you drive by, people will look at it and think "That's an alright looking, if predictably dullish, VW"

In a 3 series people will look at it, if they notice it and think "c*ck"

Your choice.

Because the only thing that matters is your perception of what others may think of you?

[edc]

I've just replaced an A3 with an E90 but recently had good use of a mk6 Golf GT140 and 2.0T TT Sline. If you want a good drive then get the BMW 325. The 2.0 turbo in the TT actually sounded like a diesel.

[robsco]

Boba Fret said:

or maybe it's the OP's very subtle way of being indecisive about the oh so dull 320 and the oh so dull 325????

Hmmmmmm.

Or it could just be a really gash typo.

I've noticed a trend from your posts Boba... You don't like BMWs, do you?

[doodles19]

Clio 200 Cup.

... but im just being facetious.

[geeteeaye]

Can OP tell us whether HP/PCP/BS

[Boba Fret]

robsco said:

I've noticed a trend from your posts Boba... You don't like BMWs, do you?

Nope. Well observed

[Boba Fret]

Heathwood said:

Because the only thing that matters is your perception of what others may think of you?

That's why people buy BMWs

[robsco]

Boba Fret said:

Nope. Well observed

I could be a detective.

[Boba Fret]

robsco said:

I could be a detective.

You could.

Pretty average one mind you.

[robsco]

Boba Fret said:

You could.

Pretty average one mind you.

Distinctly average.

[anonymous-user]

It really is always the new ones making a fool of themselves.

OP I assume you mean 323? Of the choices here I would say Scirocco since its a bit more interesting than just another 3 series.

[icepop]

The new Scirocco is one of the few cars that changes onlookers opinions as it drives past. From quite sleek corporate front end, to, "OMG, what happenned at the back". rear end. 2nd only to the old Megane, in worst rear of the year. And when there's a cracking Golf GTI version to be had, begs the question.....WHY ?????

[Heathwood]

Boba Fret said:

Heathwood said:

Because the only thing that matters is your perception of what others may think of you?

That's why people buy BMWs

A few maybe, but certainly not the majority. Plenty of people are capable of choosing a car they want / need without concern for what others may think.

[Pints]

See if either of your options are RWD, then choose that one.
It's the PH way.