F10 530d Paint Issues
F10 530d Paint Issues
Author
Discussion

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
Hi All

I recently bought a new 530d M Sport, in Carbon Black.

Love the car, great drive and good MPG as well. But the paint seems really poor. When I collected the car is was covered it lots of tiny scratches, in fairness to the dealer they paid for it to be corrected by a detailer. But two weeks later, it's cover in etching's from bird sh*t and flies that just won't come off, a massive etching on the bonnet the size of a saucer! Looks rubbish!

I know there has been much discussion about BMW water based paint, just wondered if anyone else had had problems and if and how they got rectified?

Cheers

997fan.

Edited by 997fan on Thursday 5th May 10:52

Roger645

1,796 posts

278 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
Formally reject the car as unsatisfactory quality. Take pictures and document the rejection and ask the dealer for your money back.

That should get their attention.

Andyuk911

1,979 posts

240 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
Seems strange that a detailer just polished it ... and then did not protect it with a wax ... even 'cheap' ones are very good

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
Andyuk911 said:
Seems strange that a detailer just polished it ... and then did not protect it with a wax ... even 'cheap' ones are very good
Hi Andyuk911,

They did put wax on it, but it's made no difference.

When I get a second I'll post some pictures.

Cheers

MidlandDan84

588 posts

209 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
On a brand new F10 then reject it and give it back to BMW.

To be honest, I have a black E90 and the paint quality is poor, plus the black paintwork shows up EVERY mark and blemish,i dont know if that is the paint or just being black or a combination.

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
MidlandDan84 said:
On a brand new F10 then reject it and give it back to BMW.

To be honest, I have a black E90 and the paint quality is poor, plus the black paintwork shows up EVERY mark and blemish,i dont know if that is the paint or just being black or a combination.
Hi,

I've had black cars before, no problems, including a '09 M3 in Jerez Black which was really easy to look after.

I suspect the car was in such a poor state at first because the paint is soft and susceptible to damage.

997fan

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 4th May 2011
quotequote all
997fan said:
When I collected the car is was covered it lots of tiny scratches,
Not BMW, but I collected a new (silver) VW the other day. While I was examining it the salesman said he was glad it wasn't black, as they come from the factory with scratches in the paint.

I said they're swirl marks in the clearcoat. He said, no, they're in the paint, so they can't get rid of them.

I asked if VW buy in paint with scratches pre mixed-in, or are they added by the robots as they spray it on? I think he just thought I was being facetious.

Magnus Barelegs

106 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
MidlandDan84 said:
To be honest, I have a black E90 and the paint quality is poor, plus the black paintwork shows up EVERY mark and blemish,i dont know if that is the paint or just being black or a combination.
My black E90 also had incredibly soft paint.
Bird lime would mark it within minutes.
And this was despite umpteen layers of very good quality wax (Collinite)
I gave up trying to look after it, it was a thankless task.

MidlandDan84

588 posts

209 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
Magnus Barelegs said:
My black E90 also had incredibly soft paint.
Bird lime would mark it within minutes.
And this was despite umpteen layers of very good quality wax (Collinite)
I gave up trying to look after it, it was a thankless task.
Indeed, ive pretty much given up, i try to be careful cleaning it and park carefully etc but its used every day and just looks crap. The paint seems to chip very easily, think the front end will need a re-spray at some point.

A colleague has a silver E90 with 50k more on it than mine and it looks in far better condition.


Edited by MidlandDan84 on Thursday 5th May 11:26

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
Well, mines back with them today. So I'll see what they say, although I can already guess!

They should change their advertising, 'the new BMW 5 series, only suitable for indoor use!'.

Other brands get it right, not sure why BMW can't.

ITP

2,795 posts

228 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
I do think its these new water based paints. I am one of those weirdos who actually still washes my cars by hand and its pretty clear that the paint on my 2002 saab is much better than on my E90, in fact the paint on ALL the cars i've ever owned is better. Having said that, i suppose all other manufatures are worse than they used to be now due to water based paints.
I also know someone who had a carbon black E60 who had to have a full respray at the front due to loads of white spots from chips after only 35k miles.

Magnus Barelegs

106 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
I went for white this time.
I didn't want to pay for metallic paint, I wanted some extras instead.
So that left white, red and black as 'free' colours.
No way will I ever have a black BMW again, and red's not my bag.
So white it was!

Helicopter123

8,831 posts

187 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
My 635d Sport was also Carbon Black and the paint also seemed to mark with everything that came into contact with it. This happened basically from day 1. I've had couple of black Audi's recently in the household, one metallic, one solid, with no issues. The BMW paint just seemed very soft. It's a worry as I'm sorely tempted by a F10

Wills2

29,911 posts

206 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all

My F10 is also getting covered in etchings from bird lime, the quality of the PDI was bloody awful as the car is covered and I mean covered in buffer trails and holograms.

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I think it might be worth a try.

I got a call back from my dealer today, claiming they where able to remove the marks OK, and have removed half the large one on the bonnet to prove it. When I collected the car I asked if they could move it inside so I could take a good look. And he was right they had removed half the mark, but only by machine the hell our of half the bonnet leaving holograms and buffer marks on a paint job they had paid to correct two weeks prior. Clearly the car cannot be detailed every time it gets dirty. They are working on another solution.

I don't think the paint is fit for purpose, if it was anything else we had spend this much money on, we would want it to be of acceptable standard. The cars are designed be used and as BMW are a premium brand the paint should at least be as durable as other marques.

I'd be happy to take it up with BMW UK, if everyone feels strongly enough? BMW should care as it appears it's putting people of potentially buying their cars, as above.

997fan

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
My F10 is also getting covered in etchings from bird lime, the quality of the PDI was bloody awful as the car is covered and I mean covered in buffer trails and holograms.
Wills2,

Have you spoken to your dealer about the problems? Interested in their response?

997fan

997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all

Wills2

29,911 posts

206 months

Thursday 5th May 2011
quotequote all
997fan said:
Wills2 said:
My F10 is also getting covered in etchings from bird lime, the quality of the PDI was bloody awful as the car is covered and I mean covered in buffer trails and holograms.
Wills2,

Have you spoken to your dealer about the problems? Interested in their response?

997fan
Well I told the sales manager about it, when he called to ask if everything was OK with the car, he said he would get me a loan car and have it in for a full prep at the body shop.

But I haven't heard anything since, now I've bought 6 cars from this dealership (2 in the last 2 months) so I'm confident they will sort it but I know I'll have to chase.

BMW prep is piss poor.

Rainbowoverwales

1 posts

186 months

Sunday 22nd May 2011
quotequote all
I took delivery of my brand new F10 520d BMW (in Jet Black) exactly 4 months ago and I paid an extra £400 for the Supaguard Paint Protection. The car has been hand-washed once a week as well as any bird mess being removed as soon as it is noticed. However, even though the bird mess is removed so that the paintwork is completely smooth, it leaves an in-grained greyish mark in the paintwork which is unremovable. The same problem occurs with dead insects on the front and bonnet as well as the door mirrors - the dead insects can be removed but they leave an in-grained stain in the paintwork. The result being that the paintwork on my car is already badly marked, diminishing both the appearance and the value.

Prior to buying my BMW I had a black VW Golf for 6 years, which has the same usage and was kept in the same place. The paintwork of the Golf never suffered from any of these problems. My partner had a 10 year old dark blue BMW which never had paintwork problems and he now has a 9 year old light green BMW which again is fine.

It would appear from the postings on various internet sites that this is an inherrent problem with the new water-based BMW paint and is especially bad/noticeable on the black cars. As far as I am concerned, if the new paint BMW are using can be marked so easily during normal everyday usage, it is not fit for purpose. I am planning to return my car to the dealer and tell them this.

I would be most grateful for any comments and to hear of any similar problems.






997fan

Original Poster:

245 posts

192 months

Monday 23rd May 2011
quotequote all
Rainbowoverwales said:
I took delivery of my brand new F10 520d BMW (in Jet Black) exactly 4 months ago and I paid an extra £400 for the Supaguard Paint Protection. The car has been hand-washed once a week as well as any bird mess being removed as soon as it is noticed. However, even though the bird mess is removed so that the paintwork is completely smooth, it leaves an in-grained greyish mark in the paintwork which is unremovable. The same problem occurs with dead insects on the front and bonnet as well as the door mirrors - the dead insects can be removed but they leave an in-grained stain in the paintwork. The result being that the paintwork on my car is already badly marked, diminishing both the appearance and the value.

Prior to buying my BMW I had a black VW Golf for 6 years, which has the same usage and was kept in the same place. The paintwork of the Golf never suffered from any of these problems. My partner had a 10 year old dark blue BMW which never had paintwork problems and he now has a 9 year old light green BMW which again is fine.

It would appear from the postings on various internet sites that this is an inherrent problem with the new water-based BMW paint and is especially bad/noticeable on the black cars. As far as I am concerned, if the new paint BMW are using can be marked so easily during normal everyday usage, it is not fit for purpose. I am planning to return my car to the dealer and tell them this.

I would be most grateful for any comments and to hear of any similar problems.

I've had not joy just about to send my complaint to BMW, I think it might be worth seeing if Auto car are interested as they did an article previously about the quality of BM paint, I'll keep you updated.