Why are BTLs still popular?
Why are BTLs still popular?
Author
Discussion

Dave3166

1,846 posts

145 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
I`m lucky enough to have been left a semi detached bungalow in a will.

So, i am renovating it, new kitchen, bathroom, paint, carpet, etc etc. Then will be renting that out for at least 2 years to recoup my money that i put in to bring it up to a modern living standard. Nice and fresh etc.

After 2 years, who knows, may sell it and invest money else where. But, for now i am quite enjoying it as a project to see how it goes.

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,440 posts

271 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Dave3166 said:
I`m lucky enough to have been left a semi detached bungalow in a will.

So, i am renovating it, new kitchen, bathroom, paint, carpet, etc etc. Then will be renting that out for at least 2 years to recoup my money that i put in to bring it up to a modern living standard. Nice and fresh etc.

After 2 years, who knows, may sell it and invest money else where. But, for now i am quite enjoying it as a project to see how it goes.
Good for you, was in a slightly similar position myself a few years back, interested in others perspectives and ideas on how to develop what I have.

mike74

3,687 posts

151 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Delusional to the point of needing psychiatric help in my opinion...

https://www.property118.com/makes-someone-pay-bill...

(And the S24 fun has barely begun yet)!

DonkeyApple

64,731 posts

188 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
joyless lobotomised parrot said:
Saleen836 said:
Surely the additional 3% stamp duty reins in cash purchases to a degree?
Doesn't apply to everything
Commercial units?

I’ve often looked at shops but they’ve always struck me as being higher risk due to the potential impact of empty rates and the modern day issue of not being able to use a hammer when collecting the rent.

Badda

3,404 posts

101 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Saleen836 said:
zubzob said:
True. The majority I bet are owned outright.

But the government doesn't appear to bothered about cash purchases. It is the over-leveraged they are concerned about, and who are the target of these measures.

Edited by zubzob on Tuesday 1st May 18:18
Surely the additional 3% stamp duty reins in cash purchases to a degree?
Why would that affect just cash purchases? I just factor it in to the purchase price and if it still makes sense, great.

DonkeyApple

64,731 posts

188 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Badda said:
Why would that affect just cash purchases? I just factor it in to the purchase price and if it still makes sense, great.
This is why it’s a good tax and has formed part of what I believe to be a very sensible management of the BTL problem and risk that had been created. If you’re not highly leveraged then that 3% just forms part of your investment calculation, it also helps level the playing field a little between home buyers and property investors. But if you’re one of the turn of the century speculative punters trying to gear to the eyeballs then that 3% suddenly is a massive chunk of extra real money to be found.

Dave3166

1,846 posts

145 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
Good for you, was in a slightly similar position myself a few years back, interested in others perspectives and ideas on how to develop what I have.
Thanks Mark, yeh, interesting to see how other people proceed with their projects.

Condi

19,222 posts

190 months

Thursday 3rd May 2018
quotequote all
I've become an 'accidental landlord' in that I've moved for work and are just renting out my existing property, and as others have alluded to, it seems nothing more than a way of paying a lot of tax.

I cant help thinking that its not doing society much good in doing so - tenants are paying far more in rent than they would otherwise have to because 40% of all my income goes straight to the government. Not wanting to be greedy, the rent would be 30% lower (£300/m or £3600/yr), for example, if the government didnt take its share, which would then be in the tenants pocket to spend on goods and services employing more people, all of whom pay income tax, spend that money themselves, and the whole economy benefits.

That said, I can see the advantages of buying a flat, especially if you can do it with little/no mortgage, and as part of a mixed portfolio of assets. You're basically buying a lifetime annuity with no compound interest, even if you do pay a lot of tax to do so.

Saleen836

12,018 posts

228 months

Thursday 3rd May 2018
quotequote all
Condi said:
I've become an 'accidental landlord' in that I've moved for work and are just renting out my existing property, and as others have alluded to, it seems nothing more than a way of paying a lot of tax.

I cant help thinking that its not doing society much good in doing so - tenants are paying far more in rent than they would otherwise have to because 40% of all my income goes straight to the government. Not wanting to be greedy, the rent would be 30% lower (£300/m or £3600/yr), for example, if the government didnt take its share, which would then be in the tenants pocket to spend on goods and services employing more people, all of whom pay income tax, spend that money themselves, and the whole economy benefits.

That said, I can see the advantages of buying a flat, especially if you can do it with little/no mortgage, and as part of a mixed portfolio of assets. You're basically buying a lifetime annuity with no compound interest, even if you do pay a lot of tax to do so.
The government would have to introduce a form of rent control if they didn't take their share as greedy landlords would just keep rents high to fatten their own pockets!

Condi

19,222 posts

190 months

Thursday 3rd May 2018
quotequote all
Saleen836 said:
The government would have to introduce a form of rent control if they didn't take their share as greedy landlords would just keep rents high to fatten their own pockets!
Would they? Wouldn't the market keep them at the 'right' level,same as any other enterprise?

rufusgti

2,566 posts

211 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
Condi said:
Saleen836 said:
The government would have to introduce a form of rent control if they didn't take their share as greedy landlords would just keep rents high to fatten their own pockets!
Would they? Wouldn't the market keep them at the 'right' level,same as any other enterprise?
No no, because unlike any other enterprise or business or market, btl is just done by greedy pigs. Evil greedy pigs. They set the price you know. No other factors.

Badda

3,404 posts

101 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
Badda said:
Why would that affect just cash purchases? I just factor it in to the purchase price and if it still makes sense, great.
This is why it’s a good tax and has formed part of what I believe to be a very sensible management of the BTL problem and risk that had been created. If you’re not highly leveraged then that 3% just forms part of your investment calculation, it also helps level the playing field a little between home buyers and property investors. But if you’re one of the turn of the century speculative punters trying to gear to the eyeballs then that 3% suddenly is a massive chunk of extra real money to be found.
Totally agree. BTL isn’t evil and Landlords aren’t evil but the overleveraged make the whole ‘business’ look shady and provide poor service for their tenants.

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,440 posts

271 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
rufusgti said:
No no, because unlike any other enterprise or business or market, btl is just done by greedy pigs. Evil greedy pigs. They set the price you know. No other factors.
Ever thought of a career in the Diplomatic Corp? biggrinbiggrinbiggrin

coljoh148

1,998 posts

196 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Something I've been toying with the idea of recently is getting my own btl property, mostly for retirement provisions but if it turns a small profit at the same time then fantastic. I've got some money sat pretty static for a deposit and even with said tax implications I cannot see around it.

I'm looking at popular city centre Glasgow/Edinburgh 2 bed flats, value around 150-170k. Idea would be to rent it for 25yrs so that in retirement I have a income or a property to sell that's really cost me very little to implement.

Was considering student let's, vetted of course, charge 400/month a room or whatever - which is cheaper than student halls. Then out of term time possibly air bnb. This was the idea as a work colleague does this (actually began 6yrs ago solely for putting his own kids through uni and has been successful renting privately since) safe and consistent enough and only grief is a bit of a repaint between tennents.

I really cannot see anything better to stick say 40k into.

Anyone feel free to talk me against this?

DoubleSix

12,322 posts

195 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Taxed on the way in (Stamp). Taxed on the way through (Income Tax). Taxed on the way out (CGT).

Vs Two years ISA subs:

No tax on entry. No tax on income. No tax on exit.


As for your bit about letting to students and having “no grief but a lick of paint”.... seriously....







Edited by DoubleSix on Saturday 5th May 15:03

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,440 posts

271 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Not sure about Scotland, but down south SA get a better tax break.

GT03ROB

13,897 posts

240 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
coljoh148 said:
I'm looking at popular city centre Glasgow/Edinburgh 2 bed flats, value around 150-170k. Idea would be to rent it for 25yrs so that in retirement I have a income or a property to sell that's really cost me very little to implement.
Mr Parrot works in these regions at considerably less values than that. I'm sure he'll come give you his thoughts!

joyless lobotomised parrot

5,637 posts

130 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
GT03ROB said:
coljoh148 said:
I'm looking at popular city centre Glasgow/Edinburgh 2 bed flats, value around 150-170k. Idea would be to rent it for 25yrs so that in retirement I have a income or a property to sell that's really cost me very little to implement.
Mr Parrot works in these regions at considerably less values than that. I'm sure he'll come give you his thoughts!
It's so far off my 'business plan' that I really couldn't comment. I just never could and really still can't do "future gratification".

Condi

19,222 posts

190 months

Sunday 6th May 2018
quotequote all
rufusgti said:
Btl, purchased in 2015 for 116k.
30k deposit
Now valued at 140k.
Repayment mortgage and insurance 400 per month over 20 year mortgage.
Rent 650 per month. (100% occupancy so far)
The profit per month pays the mortgage on my own house 215 per month.
In 17 years both the mortgage on the flat and the mortgage on my house will have been payed off with the rent i recieve.
after this the rent provides the top up to my income i need to at least sustain my current situation.
Please explain that to me. If you get 650/m rent, then even on the lowest tax band of 20% (assuming you had a job to get the mortgage/deposit to start with) then you're down to £520/m, and so unless you're not paying tax on the rental income it nowhere near covers both mortgages. On a 40% tax rate then you're down to 390/m which doesn't even cover the mortgage on your rental.

Or are you not quite doing things properly?

GT03ROB

13,897 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th May 2018
quotequote all
joyless lobotomised parrot said:
GT03ROB said:
coljoh148 said:
I'm looking at popular city centre Glasgow/Edinburgh 2 bed flats, value around 150-170k. Idea would be to rent it for 25yrs so that in retirement I have a income or a property to sell that's really cost me very little to implement.
Mr Parrot works in these regions at considerably less values than that. I'm sure he'll come give you his thoughts!
It's so far off my 'business plan' that I really couldn't comment. I just never could and really still can't do "future gratification".
I did kind of suspect that! Draws an interesting contrast however between 2 models of BTL. I know which I'd find more attractive.