Chinese cars, suddenly seeing quite a few...
Chinese cars, suddenly seeing quite a few...
Author
Discussion

Moodyman1

130 posts

60 months

Sunday 13th April 2025
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
£500 a month for a BYD Seal.

Blimey.

I bought a Fiat Panda for that price and it's still doing everything it should in these speed limited and surveilled times. I'm trying to give up flushing thousands away in depreciation for a car I can't work up the slightest enthusiasm for.

I could actually easily afford £500 a month, in retirement and indeed, this year's addition of the state pension would more than cover it but no thanks.
You sound like a sheddist. Don’t be embarrassed, I am too. But we’re in the minority. Many folk want trinkets and baubles. Some have access to company car schemes, salary sacrifice and other tax breaks. In their eyes, £500 a month is within reach and justified.



cerb4.5lee

40,539 posts

201 months

Sunday 13th April 2025
quotequote all
Moodyman1 said:
LuS1fer said:
£500 a month for a BYD Seal.

Blimey.

I bought a Fiat Panda for that price and it's still doing everything it should in these speed limited and surveilled times. I'm trying to give up flushing thousands away in depreciation for a car I can't work up the slightest enthusiasm for.

I could actually easily afford £500 a month, in retirement and indeed, this year's addition of the state pension would more than cover it but no thanks.
You sound like a sheddist. Don’t be embarrassed, I am too. But we’re in the minority. Many folk want trinkets and baubles. Some have access to company car schemes, salary sacrifice and other tax breaks. In their eyes, £500 a month is within reach and justified.
I remember paying £500 a month for my Cerbera 20 years ago, and in fairness at the time that felt like a few quid to me being honest. Never in a million years would I want to throw £500 a month at a BYD though for sure.

We all like different things though, and I do sometimes struggle with that to be fair. A Cerbera 4.5 or a BYD? Surely that should be a no brainer in the direction of the TVR I reckon for me, but nowadays it just isn't though, and almost everyone seems to prefer the BYD in comparison for some reason now.

LuS1fer

43,088 posts

266 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
unsprung said:
Ha! Fashionably late might be okay. Party in Chiantishire perhaps.

The new Charger looks ace. I've shouted about it on this forum. Not just battery-electric, but also available with a twin-turbo inline six. It is indeed a car that carries the design language of Charger and Challenger of yore.

But my argument is different.

Let's make a new car look almost the same, if not identical, to the much-loved original. Here's an example. Imperfect, but I'll explain.





The cars above are new, not restored. They ride on a specially-engineered chassis (not a copy of the original) and feature entirely new body panels and interiors as well as a 21st-century powertrain.

Unlike the originals, these cars drive with a bit of precision. And they are reliable daily drivers. They come loaded with mod cons. In terms of the brief I argued above, we can say that these cars tick most of the boxes.

I did say that this example was imperfect. And here's why:

These cars are far more safe than their ancestors. And being small-scale in production, they were allowed to be engineered without fulfilling each and every safety regulation on the books today.

Modern safety in an old design is, as I've said earlier, a considerable engineering challenge. I nevertheless believe that this is a challenge that we can overcome. And win.

With apologies to those who already know about Revology and their new-original Mustangs. Based in Orlando, Florida:
https://revologycars.com/

Also a mention on Top Gear:
https://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/revology/musta...

Ford Motor Company agreed to provide them an official license - again, these new cars look almost identical to the originals. Only this year, in 2025 did Ford withdraw the license. In doing so, Ford issued a statement that all cars built or licensed by Ford must meet the most current standards for safety.

I have no problem with that. Safety is good.

What I would have done differently, however, is to build a collaborative team around Revology and Ford to pioneer the use of 21st-century methods in the execution of 20th-century designs.
Your example is also ridiculously expensive.

What fobs me off is the "safety" of modern cars. It seems to me that a high bonnet means a bluffer front which means a taller front so the pedestrian has nowhere to go except splat or under the car.

How is that safe?

Mammasaid

5,175 posts

118 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
I remember paying £500 a month for my Cerbera 20 years ago, and in fairness at the time that felt like a few quid to me being honest. Never in a million years would I want to throw £500 a month at a BYD though for sure.

We all like different things though, and I do sometimes struggle with that to be fair. A Cerbera 4.5 or a BYD? Surely that should be a no brainer in the direction of the TVR I reckon for me, but nowadays it just isn't though, and almost everyone seems to prefer the BYD in comparison for some reason now.
£500/month 20 years ago is equivalent to nearly £900/month currently, so you're not comparing apples with apples, Lee.

Oh, and btw, that BYD will out accelerate the Cerbera to 60, whilst seating 5 with far more mod cons, as I said, not apples with apples.


J4CKO

Original Poster:

45,469 posts

221 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
cerb4.5lee said:
I remember paying £500 a month for my Cerbera 20 years ago, and in fairness at the time that felt like a few quid to me being honest. Never in a million years would I want to throw £500 a month at a BYD though for sure.

We all like different things though, and I do sometimes struggle with that to be fair. A Cerbera 4.5 or a BYD? Surely that should be a no brainer in the direction of the TVR I reckon for me, but nowadays it just isn't though, and almost everyone seems to prefer the BYD in comparison for some reason now.
£500/month 20 years ago is equivalent to nearly £900/month currently, so you're not comparing apples with apples, Lee.

Oh, and btw, that BYD will out accelerate the Cerbera to 60, whilst seating 5 with far more mod cons, as I said, not apples with apples.
Yeah, I thought that, massive difference, I could quite easily afford one at that, and as I always say I am not anti EV but £500 a month covers running, for me something much more interesting than a Chinese EV, but fair play to those who it works for. Not everyone wants a car to be anything other than a tool to do a job, they dont invest much thought or time into it.

I think manufacturers are trying to tempt people in with power and acceleration as its so easy to achieve with an electric motor, and to be honest after years of agonizing over the fastest, I am no longer all that bothered. When you get someone in a Tesla Model 3 rattling on about how their car will dust something legendary you realise it doesnt matter any more, a Model 3 performance will likely out accelerate a GT40, but who cares ?

I am not going to get an EV because of fast acceleration, thats kind of a Faustian Pact, would feel like trading an actual dog with all its faults, quirks and hilarity in for one of those Sony Aibo ones that doesnt hump your leg, bark or do real dog things.

But, not against having one, but would still need a fun ICE car in my life.

Saw a Jaecoo this morning on the way to work, looked alright, people are buying them.





DodgyGeezer

45,835 posts

211 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
cerb4.5lee said:
I remember paying £500 a month for my Cerbera 20 years ago, and in fairness at the time that felt like a few quid to me being honest. Never in a million years would I want to throw £500 a month at a BYD though for sure.

We all like different things though, and I do sometimes struggle with that to be fair. A Cerbera 4.5 or a BYD? Surely that should be a no brainer in the direction of the TVR I reckon for me, but nowadays it just isn't though, and almost everyone seems to prefer the BYD in comparison for some reason now.
£500/month 20 years ago is equivalent to nearly £900/month currently, so you're not comparing apples with apples, Lee.

Oh, and btw, that BYD will out accelerate the Cerbera to 60, whilst seating 5 with far more mod cons, as I said, not apples with apples.
WRT to the monthles yes £500 20 years ago may be £900 now - but given wages haven't increased in the same way maybe that isn't a bad example in terms of spending power?

The Wookie

14,184 posts

249 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Saw a Jaecoo this morning on the way to work, looked alright, people are buying them.
Being pushed by mainstream salary sacrifice schemes (like Octopus IIRC)

If you don't care about cars and you're making a choice on a website then I'd imagine it's difficult to look past how cheap they are

Even if you thought it was a bit cack when it turned up I bet a lot of people would rationalise it based on money they can spend on other things that interest them more.

kambites

70,346 posts

242 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
DodgyGeezer said:
WRT to the monthles yes £500 20 years ago may be £900 now - but given wages haven't increased in the same way maybe that isn't a bad example in terms of spending power?
Average full-time wages in the UK have risen pretty much bang in line with inflation over that time period.

cerb4.5lee

40,539 posts

201 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
The Wookie said:
J4CKO said:
Saw a Jaecoo this morning on the way to work, looked alright, people are buying them.
Being pushed by mainstream salary sacrifice schemes (like Octopus IIRC)

If you don't care about cars and you're making a choice on a website then I'd imagine it's difficult to look past how cheap they are

Even if you thought it was a bit cack when it turned up I bet a lot of people would rationalise it based on money they can spend on other things that interest them more.
I always think that your expectations are rock bottom when you don't pay a lot for something as well, so you'd be happy to turn a blind eye even if it is terrible I reckon.

A mate of mine has a Tesla Model 3, and he says that it is absolutely crap, but it doesn't bother him though...because it costs him peanuts to have and run though for example.

J4CKO

Original Poster:

45,469 posts

221 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
The Wookie said:
J4CKO said:
Saw a Jaecoo this morning on the way to work, looked alright, people are buying them.
Being pushed by mainstream salary sacrifice schemes (like Octopus IIRC)

If you don't care about cars and you're making a choice on a website then I'd imagine it's difficult to look past how cheap they are

Even if you thought it was a bit cack when it turned up I bet a lot of people would rationalise it based on money they can spend on other things that interest them more.
I always think that your expectations are rock bottom when you don't pay a lot for something as well, so you'd be happy to turn a blind eye even if it is terrible I reckon.

A mate of mine has a Tesla Model 3, and he says that it is absolutely crap, but it doesn't bother him though...because it costs him peanuts to have and run though for example.
Hmm, I have seen a lot about the Model 3, never have I seen it described as "absolutely crap", generally they are the most competitive in their class for efficiency, they go well, are well equipped, handle well, have decent range (ok, for an EV, calm down Insignia diesel owners) are comfortable and are inoffensive to look at.

Secretly I bet he loves it but has heard your thoughts and daren't express his profound and true love for his Tesla with you around for fear of what he will set off, am thinking that Angry Hitler meme that did the rounds.

I really do expect you to be in EV within ten years Lee, anyone who protests that much if definitely in denial over their true feelings wink First it will be the gateway drug, a hybrid, a BMW perchance (very nice BTW, forgot to comment !) ? I know its only a bit hybridy, but you have sneaked a little electric motor in, you can feel it filling in the gaps in power delivery, its no big deal, you can handle it, can go back to full ICE any time....

I forsee an American Beauty style epiphany, not you trying to snog the bloke next door, just a tearful yet poignant moment in the YangWang showroom when you allow your true feelings to flood out as you sign on the dotted line for your lovely new EV.


XJSJohn

16,108 posts

240 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
saw a BYD seal advert on telly the other day, the bit that caught me was the 8 year 125,000mile warranty!!!!

now i am sure there is a lot of clauses wrapped up in that warranty, but its essentially the same trick that Hyundai and Kia did on entry to the UK market and look at them now !!!



Edited by XJSJohn on Monday 14th April 16:09

cerb4.5lee

40,539 posts

201 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
cerb4.5lee said:
The Wookie said:
J4CKO said:
Saw a Jaecoo this morning on the way to work, looked alright, people are buying them.
Being pushed by mainstream salary sacrifice schemes (like Octopus IIRC)

If you don't care about cars and you're making a choice on a website then I'd imagine it's difficult to look past how cheap they are

Even if you thought it was a bit cack when it turned up I bet a lot of people would rationalise it based on money they can spend on other things that interest them more.
I always think that your expectations are rock bottom when you don't pay a lot for something as well, so you'd be happy to turn a blind eye even if it is terrible I reckon.

A mate of mine has a Tesla Model 3, and he says that it is absolutely crap, but it doesn't bother him though...because it costs him peanuts to have and run though for example.
Hmm, I have seen a lot about the Model 3, never have I seen it described as "absolutely crap", generally they are the most competitive in their class for efficiency, they go well, are well equipped, handle well, have decent range (ok, for an EV, calm down Insignia diesel owners) are comfortable and are inoffensive to look at.

Secretly I bet he loves it but has heard your thoughts and daren't express his profound and true love for his Tesla with you around for fear of what he will set off, am thinking that Angry Hitler meme that did the rounds.

I really do expect you to be in EV within ten years Lee, anyone who protests that much if definitely in denial over their true feelings wink First it will be the gateway drug, a hybrid, a BMW perchance (very nice BTW, forgot to comment !) ? I know its only a bit hybridy, but you have sneaked a little electric motor in, you can feel it filling in the gaps in power delivery, its no big deal, you can handle it, can go back to full ICE any time....

I forsee an American Beauty style epiphany, not you trying to snog the bloke next door, just a tearful yet poignant moment in the YangWang showroom when you allow your true feelings to flood out as you sign on the dotted line for your lovely new EV.
biggrin

I have let myself down letting that tiny electric motor in the gearbox sneak into one of my cars as you say! hehe

It is definitely downhill from now on I reckon.

cerb4.5lee

40,539 posts

201 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
He was also comparing his Model 3 to his old Golf R as well, and he said he much preferred that in comparison. But I'd imagine that most would in fairness.

Back2theFuji

352 posts

44 months

Monday 14th April 2025
quotequote all
XJSJohn said:
saw a BYD seal advert on telly the other day, the bit that caught me was the 8 year 125,000mile warranty!!!!

now i am sure there is a lot of clauses wrapped up in that warranty, but its essentially the same trick that Hyundai and Kia did on entry to the UK market and look at them now !!!



Edited by XJSJohn on Monday 14th April 16:09
I bought a new Kia Ceed in 2008 and was lured by the decent (if not class leading) build, 7 year warranty and low price. Mates took the piss, obviously, but I drove it to 95k in 7 years and the few things that broke were fixed quickly under warranty. That's the benchmark for these new brands.

BTW, replaced that car with a used 59 plate diesel Ceed estate which is still going strong now as our shed lol

raspy

2,198 posts

115 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
XJSJohn said:
saw a BYD seal advert on telly the other day, the bit that caught me was the 8 year 125,000mile warranty!!!!

now i am sure there is a lot of clauses wrapped up in that warranty, but its essentially the same trick that Hyundai and Kia did on entry to the UK market and look at them now !!!



Edited by XJSJohn on Monday 14th April 16:09
You are confused. The 8 year/125k warranty relates to the battery, not the entire car. The cars have a factory warranty of 6 years/93k miles.

Regarding the 8 year battery warranty. That's hardly something novel.

Tesla, MB, BMW, VW are some of the manufacturers that offer an 8 year warranty on their batteries, and in the case of Toyota and some MB models (EQS), you get a 10 year warranty on the battery.


Sheepshanks

38,805 posts

140 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
raspy said:
XJSJohn said:
saw a BYD seal advert on telly the other day, the bit that caught me was the 8 year 125,000mile warranty!!!!

now i am sure there is a lot of clauses wrapped up in that warranty, but its essentially the same trick that Hyundai and Kia did on entry to the UK market and look at them now !!!



Edited by XJSJohn on Monday 14th April 16:09
You are confused. The 8 year/125k warranty relates to the battery, not the entire car. The cars have a factory warranty of 6 years/93k miles.

Regarding the 8 year battery warranty. That's hardly something novel.

Tesla, MB, BMW, VW are some of the manufacturers that offer an 8 year warranty on their batteries, and in the case of Toyota and some MB models (EQS), you get a 10 year warranty on the battery.
…….and Hyundai and Kia are notoriously difficult for getting stuff done under warranty.

VW Group’s All In package is pretty good coverage and, if you time it right, can run to 8 years - but they don’t offer it on EVs….

confused_buyer

6,996 posts

202 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
You have to watch some of the battery warranties as they are not all equal.

Some just guarantee the battery capacity (as a percentage of original) but do not cover other battery faults.

GeniusOfLove

4,534 posts

33 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
everyone seems to prefer the BYD in comparison for some reason now.
It's almost like they want to get where they need to be reliably, in comfort, and perhaps with more than one passenger. FOOLS hehe

LuS1fer

43,088 posts

266 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
Moodyman1 said:
LuS1fer said:
£500 a month for a BYD Seal.

Blimey.

I bought a Fiat Panda for that price and it's still doing everything it should in these speed limited and surveilled times. I'm trying to give up flushing thousands away in depreciation for a car I can't work up the slightest enthusiasm for.

I could actually easily afford £500 a month, in retirement and indeed, this year's addition of the state pension would more than cover it but no thanks.
You sound like a sheddist. Don’t be embarrassed, I am too. But we’re in the minority. Many folk want trinkets and baubles. Some have access to company car schemes, salary sacrifice and other tax breaks. In their eyes, £500 a month is within reach and justified.
True but I have a Mustang that's paid for, an MX5 RF that's paid for and two Fiat Pandas that are paid for.

Jader1973

4,773 posts

221 months

Tuesday 15th April 2025
quotequote all
raspy said:
You are confused. The 8 year/125k warranty relates to the battery, not the entire car. The cars have a factory warranty of 6 years/93k miles.

Regarding the 8 year battery warranty. That's hardly something novel.

Tesla, MB, BMW, VW are some of the manufacturers that offer an 8 year warranty on their batteries, and in the case of Toyota and some MB models (EQS), you get a 10 year warranty on the battery.
The battery warranty of 8 years is state of charge only, not manufacturing defects (which is the same as the main warranty).

The 8 year warranty is actually based on a UN requirement for battery life (UN GTR 22). That’s why they are all the same.