Renault Sport Megane 300 Trophy | PH Fleet
Better in a group test than expected, worse on a track day than hoped
The past few weeks have been nothing if not busy for the PH Megane Trophy. It's now through 8,000 miles, which is some achievement given how seldom it's used for commuting and - truth be told - how little I've been in it recently. Given how divisive this Megane is proving, and how I'm warming to KUB over time, a second (and third, and fourth) opinion is surely going to prove no bad thing.
But we'll deal with those next time. Because this month has finally been the one in which the Trophy got out on track, as part of our Oulton Park Saturday Service. It's been something I've been desperate to do with the car ever since arrival, because if there's one place you would expect a car with 'Renault Sport' and 'Trophy' badges on it to be great, it's a circuit. Even at the launch of the regular of the 280, an element of track prowess was clear to see, one that should only be built on further with the Trophy, so a dry, warm Oulton Park was the ideal place to find out for myself.
By and large, the Megane was really, really good. I think we forget that a level of track ability is pretty much demanded of fairly ordinary performance cars nowadays, where not that long ago even genuine exotica would have struggled with a few hot laps. And the Megane certainly did not disgrace itself; however, and quite crucially, it never felt inspirational, either.
Let's deal with the good, first. Even on a pretty senior track like Oulton, it always felt quick, nudging 110mph before braking for Lodge and reaching even higher speeds than that on the run out of Cascades. While typically unnoticed, I think the engine deserves some recognition for its performance and response, especially given the capacity deficit to the rest of the sector. Using the gearbox in a more committed fashion makes it feel less awkward, too.
Speaking of awkward, the four-wheel steer - especially in Race mode, with the rear wheels going the other way to the fronts up to 62mph - really helped it to scoot through the slower bends; the car felt nimble and neutral, and able to make use of its strong traction almost immediately after turning in. It made more sense there than in any road situation, I'd say.
Furthermore, in the faster corners - Old Hall, Cascades, Druids - the Trophy felt secure and confidence inspiring; where older Meganes traded on flighty agility, which was great once you got the hang of it, this one feels more immediately accessible, the chassis super composed without falling into safety understeer.
It was proving entertaining company. The problem was the fun simply didn't last long enough. The brake pedal went long and grumbly sooner than expected, the front Potenzas lost bite sooner than expected, the whole car felt to have lost that Renault Sport resilience and stamina... well, sooner than expected. I reckon a tyre change (the Trophy-R uses a different compound of Potenza, for example) and upgraded fluid would work wonders, but that sort of modifying shouldn't have to be done on a Megane Trophy that's £35k. There's clearly potential in there, potential that's certainly realised in the Trophy-R, but I didn't come away from the track experience any more enamoured with the car than before.
Despite a less than glowing track outing, though, the Megane redeemed itself in an impressive group test showing. It's easy when using a car regularly to lose sight of what it does well, and there's nothing better for showing that off (or exposing any problems) than a comparison with rivals. So while it couldn't match the Focus's incredible performance in wet weather, the Megane countered by just being so exciting in the right moment. That it looked and sounded the best of the group meant the Megane justified its second place. Renault best hope the i30 N doesn't improve much with its facelift, though, because it was close.
Finally, that i30 N provided an interesting lesson in how to better offer dynamic configurability. Because, while it does have a tonne of settings, there's a tangible difference between them and they're easily set into an 'N' favourite mode. The Renault's 'Perso' setting is not only fiddlier, but has a baffling array of parameters: the driver can choose to set Dynamic driving system, Powertrain, Throttle pedal and Exhaust sound just for starters. Which kind of all sound like much the same thing. Don't forget, either, that this is a car without any adjustability in the suspension, usually exactly when these modes come into their own. I'll stick with Sport for road and Race for track - the latter next time hopefully with some better tyres...
FACT SHEET
Car: 2019 Renault Sport Megane 300 Trophy
Run by: Matt
On fleet since: June 2019
Mileage: 8,220
List price new: £31,835 (price as standard; as tested £36,085 comprised of Liquid Yellow paint for £1,300, Bose Pack (Bose sound system with seven speakers, digital amp and sub, plus 8.7-inch touchscreen with R-Link 2), for £800, Front parking sensors and rear parking camera for £400, Visio system (Lane departure warning, traffic sign recognition and auto high beam) for £250 and Recaro Sports Pack (Renault Sport Recaro seats with red stitching and Alcantara) for £1,500)
Last month at a glance: Nearly tremendous on track, nearly group test glory
Previous reports:
Another Trophy triumph?
Brilliant, baffling, bemusing - what next?
The beauty is more than skin deep. Mostly
The only issue with the Trophy, unlike the 280 Cup, is that you can't specify 18 wheels which restricts tyre choice.
Glad to hear it's so good on track and that the 4ws works there too, it's a brilliant addition at that price point despite the added weight.
I was at Donnington on Wednesday this week and the car fine on its brakes (standard discs, Pagid racing pads). Doing sets of 7-8 laps at a time and not a hint of pedal going long...
the Tyre choice are of course not the car's fault but the Mk3 felt secure on a set of new PS4's with little degradation after 2x7 lap sessions. A switch to a well worn set of 888's and everything went up a level (apart from punting it off on the first bend when they were stone cold). The car really comes alive with a bit of a stiffer sidewall and the rear end becomes very mobile.
The real limiting factor was the fuel it was drinking, it averages 9 Mpg on track...
I was at Donnington on Wednesday this week and the car fine on its brakes (standard discs, Pagid racing pads). Doing sets of 7-8 laps at a time and not a hint of pedal going long...
(...)
The real limiting factor was the fuel it was drinking, it averages 9 Mpg on track...
9mpg is not too bad actually, I got worse
I was at Donnington on Wednesday this week and the car fine on its brakes (standard discs, Pagid racing pads). Doing sets of 7-8 laps at a time and not a hint of pedal going long...
(...)
The real limiting factor was the fuel it was drinking, it averages 9 Mpg on track...
9mpg is not too bad actually, I got worse
I also love the CTR for it's out-there looks so both do different things.
I had a quick poke around one in Volcano Orange and it would have to be either that or Liquid Yellow again.
The latest Evo actually had the 280 (non-Cup Chassis I think?) pipping the 300 Trophy as a road car, which is food for thought considering it is cheaper.
My old 275 was pretty firm, but was great straight out of the box on track, so do wonder how the new cars compare.
I'm never buying a new Renault again though. Give it a couple of years.
Unfortunately just dropping an extra 20 bhp in doesn’t really do the Trophy badge justice imho.
I’ll be honest, the main thing I’d appreciate on the Trophy would be the exhaust. The standard 280 sounds really good anyway but the 300 sounds even better. Honestly though, the 280 is more than up to the job for road and track work. I’d probably just save the cash.
I must say, I'd really love to see Renault launch a Megane without the RWS, or maybe make it an option for those who are looking for a more hardcore version without the budget for the Trophy-R. A "track pack" option for this Trophy with the Trophy-R suspension settings and 18" wheels would be awesome.
Unfortunately just dropping an extra 20 bhp in doesn’t really do the Trophy badge justice imho.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff