McAfee Vs NOD32

Author
Discussion

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,353 posts

254 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
Our new laptop (one year old) has been running McAfee for its first year but I'm tempted to go back to NOD32 which is on the old laptop but whose license has ran out now.

Is it worth getting a McAfee removal tool on this computer and putting NOD32 on instead?

Cheers!

LOGiK

1,084 posts

202 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
Dunno why you'd ever shy away from nod32. Aside from the less intrusive nature, it's a lot less resource hungry and generally has better detection. nod32 is probably the best home AV around, closely seconded by Kaspersky. McAffee and Norton are probably around the worst of the paid AV.

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

269 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
NOD32 every time.

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,353 posts

254 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
It was pre installed so thought I would give it a try. We have ditched McAfee at work and gone to NOD32 there.

NOD32 it is then.

Cheers!

Skier

488 posts

237 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
LOGiK said:
Dunno why you'd ever shy away from nod32. Aside from the less intrusive nature, it's a lot less resource hungry and generally has better detection. nod32 is probably the best home AV around, closely seconded by Kaspersky. McAffee and Norton are probably around the worst of the paid AV.
I'd be intrigued as to what makes you make the bold statement above regarding the best/worst home antivirus solutions. The only way to make the call is following side-by-side tests and most individuals cannot do this. The 'best' or 'worst' solution is also dependent on on the knowledge of the user. For example, I use ESET Smart Security (NOD32 + Firewall) on my own systems but on those machines I build or maintain for those with no/little IT knowledge I recommend Norton 360 with a few tweaks.

One recent side-by-side test can be read here: http://www.pcpro.co.uk/reviews/internet-security

This one doesn't include NOD32/ESET SS but there are many reviews out there.

The one thing I would say is that of all software that, in my view, you should pay for rather than using one of the free products is security software; £30 or so is nothing compared to the pain and inconvenience of having to reformat and strat from scratch. If a free product tops the reviews great but I've never seen it yet.

Regards

Skier

LOGiK

1,084 posts

202 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
If you take a look at how effectively mcafee and norton actually pick up viruses, particularly new ones, and how many false positives and such, you'll quickly see that there are far more effective solutions.

nod32 now is very simple to use, I guess someone who really doesn't know what they're doing would be better with something like bullguard but I'd never recommend norton or mcafee based on how intrusive they are, the previously stated detection issues as well as the rather horrible memory footprint and negative impact on performance.

Skier

488 posts

237 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
LOGiK said:
If you take a look at how effectively mcafee and norton actually pick up viruses, particularly new ones, and how many false positives and such, you'll quickly see that there are far more effective solutions.

nod32 now is very simple to use, I guess someone who really doesn't know what they're doing would be better with something like bullguard but I'd never recommend norton or mcafee based on how intrusive they are, the previously stated detection issues as well as the rather horrible memory footprint and negative impact on performance.
I have no personal experience of McAfee products and so won't comment on them. However, your comments regarding the Norton 360 line are way out of date. From Norton 360v2 onwards this product has been very good for the non-IT savvy general user. The memory and resource impact are small and to keep your non-savvy grandmother, uncle, girlfriend etc safe it's a good product. Remember, I use ESET Smart Security on both my desktop and laptop.

Anyway, this has drifted way OT.

One product doesn't fit all!

Skier



Edited by Skier on Saturday 12th March 18:54

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,353 posts

254 months

Saturday 12th March 2011
quotequote all
Well, I did a McAfee scan this morning and it found nothing. A NOD32 scan has just finished and it found 16 infiltrations.

lestag

4,614 posts

290 months

Sunday 13th March 2011
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Well, I did a McAfee scan this morning and it found nothing. A NOD32 scan has just finished and it found 16 infiltrations.
depends what exactly they are, could be partials , or just items it does not like, that are not nessecarily virus