Harry's Garage - YouTube

Author
Discussion

ChocolateFrog

25,800 posts

174 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
M4SER said:
Uncle John said:
The Portofino is a bit muted, bloody GPF’s, but seriously rapid for an entry level Ferrari. Crazy really.
I'm afraid it is, even though it doesn't have any rear silencers. The combination of GPF and new (for 2021) drive-by vehicular noise limits on all new cars have seriously muted ICE cars compared to what was allowed only a couple of years ago. Even so, they still sound better than an EV!
It's not the volume for me, it's the tone.

It's not a million miles away from Corsa with a bean can exhaust that we all deride so much.

It doesn't sound cultured at all, the interim sound of the present before we get the silence of the future.

Sad because Merc/AMG have atleast made a fist of making a decent sounding turbocharged car.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
It's not the volume for me, it's the tone.

It's not a million miles away from Corsa with a bean can exhaust that we all deride so much.

It doesn't sound cultured at all, the interim sound of the present before we get the silence of the future.

Sad because Merc/AMG have atleast made a fist of making a decent sounding turbocharged car.
Hopefully this will mean the cars which pre date these rule changes remain in high demand.

Can you imagine a Sauber C9 just farting up La Sarthe vs it’s bellowing V8 roar.

Quickmoose

4,523 posts

124 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
As Savagegeese, (youtuber) said recently, now is the time to really consider the car you always wanted and to do what it takes to get it. The motoring landscape is changing very fast on a weekly/monthly basis...

smithyithy

7,271 posts

119 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Quickmoose said:
As Savagegeese, (youtuber) said recently, now is the time to really consider the car you always wanted and to do what it takes to get it. The motoring landscape is changing very fast on a weekly/monthly basis...
I think this is quite accurate and pretty depressing when you think about it...

First they stop producing ICE cars, then they slap emission zones everywhere so that certain ICE cars are limited in where they can drive, then they modify / limit the petrol market so that it becomes increasingly expensive / impractical to run a fun / older car.

Like you say, it seems like it's becoming a weekly / monthly basis that something else changes and the horizon draws closer.

giveitfish

4,034 posts

215 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Don't forget compulsory fitment of adaptive speed limiters from next year, and lower drive-by noise regs too.

We're all going to be fighting over a limited pool of pre-2022 cars from now on lol.

Jules Sunley

3,933 posts

94 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Just watched the Portofino review, I agree about the muted noise being sad but still think it's a lovely car I'd quite like

Doofus

26,108 posts

174 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
All this doom mongering only applies to new cars.

Stop wishing your lives away, and use some imagination when it comes to buying your next car. I promise you, your neighbours don't give a st about what you drive. smile

ETA: Oh, and you can turn the speed limiter off anyway.

AJLintern

4,209 posts

264 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Are they going to be testing for these stricter noise limits on the MOT? Surely can put an after-market sports exhaust on...?

smithyithy

7,271 posts

119 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Doofus said:
All this doom mongering only applies to new cars.

Stop wishing your lives away, and use some imagination when it comes to buying your next car. I promise you, your neighbours don't give a st about what you drive. smile

ETA: Oh, and you can turn the speed limiter off anyway.
That's my point though, some things only apply to new cars being built / sold from X year, and that wouldn't have been much of an issue before as we could all still keep our older ICE cars, but there's more and more changes on the horizon that will directly affect those cars too.

Doofus

26,108 posts

174 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
smithyithy said:
That's my point though, some things only apply to new cars being built / sold from X year, and that wouldn't have been much of an issue before as we could all still keep our older ICE cars, but there's more and more changes on the horizon that will directly affect those cars too.
Yeah, but not in such short a timescale.

Obviously, if your idea of a nice day out in the car is driving into the middle of Birmingham, then you're out of luck, but 'twas ever thus.

smile

RichB

51,782 posts

285 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Doofus said:
All this doom mongering only applies to new cars.

Stop wishing your lives away, and use some imagination when it comes to buying your next car. I promise you, your neighbours don't give a st about what you drive. smile

ETA: Oh, and you can turn the speed limiter off anyway.
Well said, do I really care what happens in 2050? No... biglaugh What my grandchildren chose to drive (or fly) to get their kicks is their concern.

smithyithy

7,271 posts

119 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
RichB said:
Doofus said:
All this doom mongering only applies to new cars.

Stop wishing your lives away, and use some imagination when it comes to buying your next car. I promise you, your neighbours don't give a st about what you drive. smile

ETA: Oh, and you can turn the speed limiter off anyway.
Well said, do I really care what happens in 2050? No... biglaugh What my grandchildren chose to drive (or fly) to get their kicks is their concern.
That's my worry though, I know people that are in the sort of 50 to retirement age now, and they're able to buy and drive their dream cars with relative ease now, despite more EVs popping up here and there..

Come 2050, I'll be in that age bracket, and hopefully financially sorted enough to do the same, but the landscape for petrolheads will be very different by then..

ChocolateFrog

25,800 posts

174 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
ChocolateFrog said:
It's not the volume for me, it's the tone.

It's not a million miles away from Corsa with a bean can exhaust that we all deride so much.

It doesn't sound cultured at all, the interim sound of the present before we get the silence of the future.

Sad because Merc/AMG have atleast made a fist of making a decent sounding turbocharged car.
Hopefully this will mean the cars which pre date these rule changes remain in high demand.

Can you imagine a Sauber C9 just farting up La Sarthe vs it’s bellowing V8 roar.
I think it must do.

If I had the opportunity to pick a Ferrari V8 Berlinetta, Money no object I'd have a 458 (might as well go Speciale), the newer stuff holds little interest to me and I can't be the only one.

355/360/F430 and 458 all sound cloud9

RichB

51,782 posts

285 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
smithyithy said:
That's my worry though, I know people that are in the sort of 50 to retirement age now, and they're able to buy and drive their dream cars with relative ease now, despite more EVs popping up here and there..

Come 2050, I'll be in that age bracket, and hopefully financially sorted enough to do the same, but the landscape for petrolheads will be very different by then..
I'm sorry to read that and I feel for the next generation. I'm 65 and enjoyed all my cars. Driving on the roads now is not like it was 50 years ago but there'll be something to excite in 30 years time. I just won't be here to experience it.

RobXjcoupe

3,204 posts

92 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Had a watch of the early and late Range Rover classic comparison video and was interesting to hear and see those subtle differences. Not sure how new or old that video is/was but gave a brief insight for a restoration I’m about to start smile

DonkeyApple

55,831 posts

170 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
RobXjcoupe said:
Had a watch of the early and late Range Rover classic comparison video and was interesting to hear and see those subtle differences. Not sure how new or old that video is/was but gave a brief insight for a restoration I’m about to start smile
In terms of hearing, those differences aren't all that subtle. smile.

Incidentally, Disco 1 sound deadening is well worth getting hold of. The floor and tunnel mouldings are the same but the bulkhead moulding is the more comprehensive LSE/end of the classic line version. Disco 1 front wheel arch liners also stop a lot of noise.


RobXjcoupe

3,204 posts

92 months

Wednesday 14th July 2021
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
RobXjcoupe said:
Had a watch of the early and late Range Rover classic comparison video and was interesting to hear and see those subtle differences. Not sure how new or old that video is/was but gave a brief insight for a restoration I’m about to start smile
In terms of hearing, those differences aren't all that subtle. smile.

Incidentally, Disco 1 sound deadening is well worth getting hold of. The floor and tunnel mouldings are the same but the bulkhead moulding is the more comprehensive LSE/end of the classic line version. Disco 1 front wheel arch liners also stop a lot of noise.
Duly noted. Haven’t started yet. But it’s time to start collecting parts smile

Matt p

1,039 posts

209 months

Wednesday 14th July 2021
quotequote all
Thoroughly good episode regarding the Hydrogen development from JCB. Good to see an ex Lotus engineer getting amongst it too. Lord Bamford was engaging also.

It peaked my interest as a building I visit has just had its Hydrogen fuel cell decommissioned and removed. I was keen to hear about future development in the field and where it could possibly lead.

Great episode thumbup

404 Page not found

15,304 posts

201 months

Wednesday 14th July 2021
quotequote all
Very very interesting episode. I've always thought batteries are not the answer to our future power needs!

Mars

8,771 posts

215 months

Thursday 15th July 2021
quotequote all
Totally fascinating hydrogen episode. We all knew it was a possible tech but it gets totally overwhelmed by the electric publicity, to the point where I just assumed there was no further research in hydrogen. It's hugely encouraging to see how painless a switch could be for the larger machines.