This can't be right?

Author
Discussion

parrot of doom

Original Poster:

23,075 posts

236 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
www.slowitdown.co.uk/speed_info.asp

tax collectors said:
Excessive and inappropriate speed is the single biggest cause of road traffic collisions.


I'm just double checking, but this is complete and utter bollox, right? How the hell do they work that one out?

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

257 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
They don't.....they just say the first thing that comes to mind.

ed22

190 posts

233 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
"If you are unsure of the speed limit stick to 30mph.
When driving in a 30mph zone, put your vehicle in 3rd gear. The natural speed of the car will be around 30mph, and will assist you in keeping to the speed limit."

Won't this simply ADD to emissions????

NiceCupOfTea

25,298 posts

253 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
ed22 said:
"If you are unsure of the speed limit stick to 30mph.
When driving in a 30mph zone, put your vehicle in 3rd gear. The natural speed of the car will be around 30mph, and will assist you in keeping to the speed limit."

Won't this simply ADD to emissions????



Can I use this as a defence if I get scammed in a 20 zone?

streaky

19,311 posts

251 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
Old hat. See: 'RE: Know your Limits' (started Wednesday 3rd September 2003) - Streaky

supraman2954

3,241 posts

241 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
ed22 said:
"If you are unsure of the speed limit stick to 30mph.
......."

Won't this simply ADD to emissions????


ooooh, just realised, this is no longer valid as 20MPH zones are now being enforced. You may be better off sticking to 20 if unsure of the limit.

A cunning plan by our government? A way of creating extra congestion, or for raising extra revenue?

edited to add: oops, just saw NCoT's post



>> Edited by supraman2954 on Monday 11th April 08:48

PetrolTed

34,432 posts

305 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
misinformation site said:

When driving in a 30mph zone, put your vehicle in 3rd gear. The natural speed of the car will be around 30mph, and will assist you in keeping to the speed limit.


What nonsense

30mph? To be in control of either of our cars 30mph = 2nd gear. 3rd gear is practically freewheeling/coasting on idle speed i.e. out of control.

Balmoral Green

41,084 posts

250 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
tax collectors said:
Excessive and inappropriate speed is the single biggest cause of road traffic collisions.
Actually, I dont know why they dont just take this to its logical conclusion and claim that ALL road traffic collisions are as a result of excessive and innapropriate speed.

If you are doing say 25mph in a 30 mph zone and someone comes out of a side road without looking, your speed may well have been within the speed limit, but clearly you were travelling too fast 'just in case' someone came out of a side road without looking. Likewise the person who pulled out without looking was also travelling too fast, even if it was just a few mph, that is excessive compared to STOP.

If your car is stationary at the side of the road and a piano falls out of a sling and smashes into your car, speed is once again the problem, in this case being the terminal velocity of the piano.

We all know that nearly all accidents are caused by bad driving, and something like 93% of accidents occur within the speed limit, but it can still be claimed that excessive speed was a factor, because at least one of the vehicles involved has to be physically moving in order for a collision to occur.

Excessive speed is a factor in ALL accidents, you cant argue with that.




telecat

8,528 posts

243 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
Sent to the marketing Department.

You state that

“Excessive and inappropriate speed is the single biggest cause of road traffic collisions.”

Figures produced by this government state that only 7% of accidents are caused by speed over the stated limit. Even if incidents that have occurred BELOW the stated limit but at an inappropriate speed for conditions or are secondary are added this does not push the figures beyond 15%. HARDLY THE BIGGEST CAUSE OF ACCIDENTS.

Jeremy Hunt

trax

1,538 posts

234 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
They usually claim that 30% of accidents are caused by speed, when yes, only 7% are. They say that were an accident was caused by drink driving, if he was going slightly over the limit, even though that was nothing to do with the cause, its another speed related accident stat.

Thats like saying 25% of accident are caused when drivers where heading in a westerly direction. If we stopped drivers going west, we could reduce accidents by 25%.

Zod

35,295 posts

260 months

Monday 11th April 2005
quotequote all
PetrolTed said:

misinformation site said:

When driving in a 30mph zone, put your vehicle in 3rd gear. The natural speed of the car will be around 30mph, and will assist you in keeping to the speed limit.



What nonsense

30mph? To be in control of either of our cars 30mph = 2nd gear. 3rd gear is practically freewheeling/coasting on idle speed i.e. out of control.
Hmm, I'd say the natural speed for my car in third would be about double that.

silver993tt

9,064 posts

241 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
My ZX12R does 90mph in 1st gear at the red-line

MR2Mike

20,143 posts

257 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
silver993tt said:
My ZX12R does 90mph in 1st gear at the red-line


And the red-line is the natural place for the engine to be running at

sj78

3,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
[url]www.slowitdown.co.uk/challenge.asp[/url]

Have a go at this and muller those pedestrians every time!

KB_S1

5,967 posts

231 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
Did anyone look at the stopping distances?
How many members here have cars that would take 14m to stop from 30? Is it not about time these stats were uptdated now that cars have brakes fitted as standard?

silver993tt

9,064 posts

241 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
MR2Mike said:

silver993tt said:
My ZX12R does 90mph in 1st gear at the red-line



And the red-line is the natural place for the engine to be running at


Well no, at 4000rpm (33% to red line) it's exactly 30mph in 1st gear.

In a car with a redline at 7000rpm, that's 2333rpm (33%), still not very much at all.

Anyway, I use my car and bike 98% of the time on the continent. The other 2% gets me to the tunnel and back.

supraman2954

3,241 posts

241 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
sj78 said:
www.slowitdown.co.uk/challenge.asp

Have a go at this and muller those pedestrians every time!
Not this again. You will make it to work exactly 10 minutes late every time, even if you don't move forward an inch!

NiceCupOfTea

25,298 posts

253 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all


I just did it "properly" and was 10 minutes late!

I can't even begin to go into the multiple ways in which that is a complete crock! Oh, alright then :

1 - top down view, very realistic
2 - only about 15 feet visibility
3 - worst brakes in christendom
4 - surely should have left earlier if journey takes 25 minutes!
5 - do kids normally loiter on zebra crossings waiting for cars to come along!?
6 - love the emotive headlines - "Driver mows down kids, etc.", "being on time wouldn't be much use to parents of child run over" Oh, won't somebody PLEASE think of the children!?

ARGH! Derbys Scam Partnership should be strung up for this bit of gormless crap.

Edited: yep, just left it there and got to work 10 minutes late without mowing down any kiddies . Tomorrow I shall get up 10 minutes earlier than usual, and sit in my car for a bit without starting it. Should make it in bang on time!

>> Edited by NiceCupOfTea on Tuesday 12th April 19:02

boredpilot

478 posts

240 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
i stopped the car on the zibra crossing and a kid walking into the car, headline comes up car plows through children. Odd speed wasnt the factor that time it was the kid running into the stationary car



>> Edited by boredpilot on Tuesday 12th April 19:09

ledfoot

777 posts

254 months

Tuesday 12th April 2005
quotequote all
ed22 said:
"If you are unsure of the speed limit stick to 30mph.
When driving in a 30mph zone, put your vehicle in 3rd gear.
Won't this simply ADD to emissions????



It will certainly increase emissions, just the same as traffic lights do.

It will also increase fuel consumption and deplete valuable oil stocks much faster.

It will cause an increase in noise, caused by higher revving engines.