Couple lose £120k in email scam

Couple lose £120k in email scam

Author
Discussion

TurricanII

1,516 posts

199 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
People need to remember that an email is as secure as a postcard through the front door!

The victims are lucky that they weren't told that the payment had not gone through (by the scammers).

Some victims are fooled into sending the same amount several times...

All you can do is phone to check bank details, or send a cheque perhaps.

OddCat

2,577 posts

172 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
TurricanII said:
The victims are lucky that they weren't told that the payment had not gone through (by the scammers).
Eh ??

turbobloke

104,179 posts

261 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
OddCat said:
TurricanII said:
The victims are lucky that they weren't told that the payment had not gone through (by the scammers).
Eh ??
Hoping there was enough in their account to cope with a re-send after not checking that the original send really hadn't gone through? Double dip attempt?

shakotan

10,721 posts

197 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.

Autopilot

1,301 posts

185 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
shakotan said:
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.
Not really the case with this example though is it.

AndStilliRise

2,295 posts

117 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
shakotan said:
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.
I think you will find that it was a complicated scam, not detectable and actually quite smart. Think it would have caught a number of people out.

anonymous-user

55 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
Dr Mike Oxgreen said:
Riley Blue said:
I'm probably being incredibly dense here but if he needs to pay HMRC £120,000 inheritance tax and went into his own bank with his debit card to do it, couldn't he have paid it direct without invoving his solicitor's account?
Yes.

The account number and sort code for paying IHT are freely published on HMRC’s web site. Simply do a BACS or CHAPS transfer direct to HMRC, putting your IHT reference number as the reference on the transfer. Job done - no need to involve the solicitor’s bank account at all.
That's what I thought, so perhaps there was more to this IHT payment than has been revealed, i.e. it wasn't a straight forward payment to HRMC.
My bank (Co-op) is so useless in its algorithm-driven post stable door anti-fraud measures that it froze my account after I made a fairly chunky payment of income tax using my debit card. The payment was to a legit HMRC account, and I was in a rush as I was travelling and had left the payment to the last day. The bank then had a wobbly and stopped me spending fifteen quid on petrol. The same system routinely blocks my card every time I try to buy car insurance, and intermittently when I use Amazon. I have the same weary conversation every time and get the block lifted.

Tony 1234

3,465 posts

228 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
shakotan said:
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.
Sorry but I don't think that's a fair point in this case!

Autopilot

1,301 posts

185 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
My bank (Co-op) is so useless in its algorithm-driven post stable door anti-fraud measures that it froze my account after I made a fairly chunky payment of income tax using my debit card. The payment was to a legit HMRC account, and I was in a rush as I was travelling and had left the payment to the last day. The bank then had a wobbly and stopped me spending fifteen quid on petrol. The same system routinely blocks my card every time I try to buy car insurance, and intermittently when I use Amazon. I have the same weary conversation every time and get the block lifted.
I was quite impressed with HSBC's anti-fraud squad. I bought a second hand car from a main dealer and put down the cash I received from the sale of one car as a deposit and paid for the rest of the car on my debit card to an account that had the funds for the rest of it in. As it was a reasonable amount of money, they had to phone it through Merchant Services who asked numerous questions and literally the moment they hit the go button, my mobile rang and it was the HSBC fraud people.


cmaguire

3,589 posts

110 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
My bank (Co-op) is so useless in its algorithm-driven post stable door anti-fraud measures that it froze my account after I made a fairly chunky payment of income tax using my debit card. The payment was to a legit HMRC account, and I was in a rush as I was travelling and had left the payment to the last day. The bank then had a wobbly and stopped me spending fifteen quid on petrol. The same system routinely blocks my card every time I try to buy car insurance, and intermittently when I use Amazon. I have the same weary conversation every time and get the block lifted.
Both my Santander (business) and Nationwide cards get occasionally refused when travelling, sometimes after having already been used abroad on the same trip. Phoning them to deal with it might cost £20+ if in Dubai or similar, so I won't do it.

My Halifax card I cannot recollect ever being knocked back anywhere. This is obviously the one to clone or steal. I always have this one as a safety net. I put £8000 on it in June as part payment for a bike and half expected a call to verify. Never happened, went straight through.
I

Efbe

9,251 posts

167 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
cmaguire said:
Both my Santander (business) and Nationwide cards get occasionally refused when travelling, sometimes after having already been used abroad on the same trip. Phoning them to deal with it might cost £20+ if in Dubai or similar, so I won't do it.

My Halifax card I cannot recollect ever being knocked back anywhere. This is obviously the one to clone or steal. I always have this one as a safety net. I put £8000 on it in June as part payment for a bike and half expected a call to verify. Never happened, went straight through.
I
actually the wrong way round. The halifax algorithms are pretty damn sophisticated. they look at the movement of the user to track payments, patterns in what is being bought, creating a profile of the customer and what they usually do/don't do.

has worked damn well for me, blocked the only fraudulent transaction that has ever been on my account, and only flagged up a few of my legit transactions which were things like me phoning to make a payment in indonesia and australia, which to be fair I am glad got flagged!

Also if you are going abroad, just phone your bank before you go and let them know!

cmaguire

3,589 posts

110 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Efbe said:
actually the wrong way round. The halifax algorithms are pretty damn sophisticated. they look at the movement of the user to track payments, patterns in what is being bought, creating a profile of the customer and what they usually do/don't do.

has worked damn well for me, blocked the only fraudulent transaction that has ever been on my account, and only flagged up a few of my legit transactions which were things like me phoning to make a payment in indonesia and australia, which to be fair I am glad got flagged!

Also if you are going abroad, just phone your bank before you go and let them know!
I'm not in the habit of making £8000 payments to bike shops.

Or telling anyone when I go abroad, as I don't do family holidays booked a year in advance.



Dr Mike Oxgreen

4,143 posts

166 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
My bank (Co-op) is so useless in its algorithm-driven post stable door anti-fraud measures that it froze my account after I made a fairly chunky payment of income tax using my debit card. The payment was to a legit HMRC account, and I was in a rush as I was travelling and had left the payment to the last day. The bank then had a wobbly and stopped me spending fifteen quid on petrol. The same system routinely blocks my card every time I try to buy car insurance, and intermittently when I use Amazon. I have the same weary conversation every time and get the block lifted.
It will be very interesting to see if Smile (hence also Co-op) query the unusual activity on my account. I’ve just started channelling daily transfers from one place to another via that account, because (a) the destination account will only accept transfers in from the Smile account and (b) I’m too tight-fisted to pay for a CHAPS transfer to do it all in one go. Frankly I’ll be unimpressed if they don’t query it, because it must look like blatant money laundering.

Efbe

9,251 posts

167 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
cmaguire said:
I'm not in the habit of making £8000 payments to bike shops.

Or telling anyone when I go abroad, as I don't do family holidays booked a year in advance.
it's really not hard, just tell your bank you are going abroad, it matters not if you give them a years notice, a week or an hour. I think for some banks you can even tell them online or send a text or send an e-mail.

anonymous-user

55 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Dr Mike Oxgreen said:
[...Frankly I’ll be unimpressed if they don’t query it, because it must look like blatant money laundering.
Yeah, cuz it is, yeah. Glad to hear that the coke N hookers biz is booming, Dr Mike.

shakotan

10,721 posts

197 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
AndStilliRise said:
shakotan said:
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.
I think you will find that it was a complicated scam, not detectable and actually quite smart. Think it would have caught a number of people out.
Transferring very large sums of money without physically speaking to someone at the recipient company seems immensely stupid to me.

Efbe

9,251 posts

167 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
shakotan said:
AndStilliRise said:
shakotan said:
People falling for these scams is just tax on the stupid.
I think you will find that it was a complicated scam, not detectable and actually quite smart. Think it would have caught a number of people out.
Transferring very large sums of money without physically speaking to someone at the recipient company seems immensely stupid to me.
re-read the story.

They did call the solicitor, asking for details of bank account to be e-mailed over.
Later that day they received an e-mail from the solicitor with bank account details included.

julianc

1,984 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Mojooo said:
When making large payments I tend to send £10 through first and check with the recipient - although this is more out of concern from typing their account number wrong on my online banking.
+1

PIGINAWIG

2,339 posts

166 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Sooooo much speculation'.

Just to update, the police are now involved. Fingers crossed....

Autopilot

1,301 posts

185 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Fingers crossed it yields the right result!