Discussion
There are two aspects to all of this; the 'driver error' and the consequences.
If Gary Hart had ended up in a field instead of on a railway line, the driver error would have been the same, but the consequences vastly less tragic.
Similarly, if you are caught at 120 on an empty motorway on a Sunday morning, your 'driver error' has been noted, but there are no consequences. However, if you had a split second lapse of concentration at 120, your 'error' might be the same, but the consequences could be very different.
As a driver, as soon as you get behind the wheel, you are not only responsible for your behaviour, but also for any consequences which result from your behaviour.
You might have 100,000 drivers doing 120 on empty motorways, and only one coming to grief, but that one must accept the responsibility for the consequences, even if the other 99,999 don't think they've been doing anything wrong.
The law has to come into effect when the risk of 'error' is severe enough to outlaw the behaviour in the first place - such as driving while falling asleep.
Discuss...
If Gary Hart had ended up in a field instead of on a railway line, the driver error would have been the same, but the consequences vastly less tragic.
Similarly, if you are caught at 120 on an empty motorway on a Sunday morning, your 'driver error' has been noted, but there are no consequences. However, if you had a split second lapse of concentration at 120, your 'error' might be the same, but the consequences could be very different.
As a driver, as soon as you get behind the wheel, you are not only responsible for your behaviour, but also for any consequences which result from your behaviour.
You might have 100,000 drivers doing 120 on empty motorways, and only one coming to grief, but that one must accept the responsibility for the consequences, even if the other 99,999 don't think they've been doing anything wrong.
The law has to come into effect when the risk of 'error' is severe enough to outlaw the behaviour in the first place - such as driving while falling asleep.
Discuss...
Every time somebody gets into a car they are learning or honing their skills. So your point about tuition applies more to those that have just passed their test and less to those that have done 100,000's miles.
This debate will go round in circles and I am sure evryone is getting bored, so I'll call it a day on this one.
Merry Christmas everyone!
This debate will go round in circles and I am sure evryone is getting bored, so I'll call it a day on this one.
Merry Christmas everyone!
All,
Many thanks for the input, it's great to hear unobjective and alternative views. Unfortunately or should I say gladly I remember very little about the accident, the info I posted came from witnesses. Being the victim I'm just a bit biased so hence my stance.
At the very least I hope this post makes everyone think twice about bikers.
Best wishes to all for Christmas and the New Year.
Many thanks for the input, it's great to hear unobjective and alternative views. Unfortunately or should I say gladly I remember very little about the accident, the info I posted came from witnesses. Being the victim I'm just a bit biased so hence my stance.
At the very least I hope this post makes everyone think twice about bikers.
Best wishes to all for Christmas and the New Year.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff