Lib-con looking to lower blood alcohol limit

Lib-con looking to lower blood alcohol limit

Author
Discussion

F i F

Original Poster:

44,259 posts

252 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
otolith said:
streaky said:
thunderbelmont said:
They'd save more than a few hundred lives if they made everyone live in bungalows, with no items of furniture more than 2" high (so you can't climb up and fall off of it), because falls in the home account for more deaths than drink-driving.
2" high furniture is a lot easier to trip over - Streaky
Not if you force everyone to crawl on all fours.
But then you'd continually have to get the carpets cleaned due to this lot...

F i F

Original Poster:

44,259 posts

252 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
Sorry for resurrecting an old topic that had gone a bit off track but I have got to Annex L of the North Report.

Came across this data

Country BAC limit Alcohol related deaths Checks per driver % Offences as %
- mg/100 ml % of all road deaths No of checks/No drivers of driver population
UK 80 17.0 1.7 0.3
Sweden 20 16.1 45.3 0.3
Spain 50 20.5 13.5 0.4
Netherlands 50 6.2 20.4 0.3
Hungary 0 (nil) 8.7 18.2 0.6
Finland 50 27.3 22.0 0.9
France 50 27.3 29.9 0.9
Czech Rep 0 (nil) 3.4 6.6 0.2


I would argue that this suggests the biggest influence on alcohol related road deaths is not the limit, is also not necessarily the testing regime but a cultural thing.

What is Netherlands doing right though? Those crazy Dutch eh?

But I'd say UK police are targeting the drivers well while some forces eg Sweden paperbag are targeting almost anything that moves based on a lower BAC limit to no effect.

edited for table formating grrrr and numptyism missing off a complete column.


Edited by F i F on Friday 25th June 10:08

otolith

56,471 posts

205 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
I am suspicious of the use of percentages there (because if we reduced deaths by other causes it would make our alcohol figure look worse) and of the definition of "alcohol related road deaths" - does it, for example, include pissed pedestrians falling under buses?

streaky

19,311 posts

250 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
And people with alcohol in their bloodstream falling from road bridges or on to roads?

More importantly, are the national figures compiled on the same basis (ROH level excepted)?

Streaky