Oh b*lls what now?!!

Oh b*lls what now?!!

Author
Discussion

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
Just driving into Manchester today and the engine on the 400 decides to stop whilst doing about 60 on the motorway.

"This is getting a bit too common" thinks I. Since it has done the exact same thing twice in the last couple of weeks.

I pull in on the hard shoulder and turn it over - it doesn't want to know. But past experience tells me that in about 5-10 minutes I'll start, and sure enough it does.

Whilst waiting I pull off one of the plug leads and try a spare spark plug against the engine. It sparks, Hmmm.

Anyway, sure enough after about 10 mins it starts so off I go - for about a mile and it stops again.

Well after about four miles and the forth time of it happening I decide to call out the RAC.

This time it takes ages before it will start again (well I had nothing else to do whilst I was waiting!)and I notice that after the engine has been running for about 5 mins, that water is bubbling out of the cap on the expansion tank, even though the temperature guage hasn't even made it to ninety yet.

Now these could be two unrelated symptoms but I've got a baaaad feeling that I could be looking at a cylinder head problem.

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all


And before anyone asks:

The temperature guage has been checked recently and been shown to read accurately.

The filler cap on is the correct rating (according to the bible) and is only a couple of months old.

Also the radiator, hoses, plugs & leads have all been replaced withing the last few months.

Anybody care to offer any opinions before it goes to the garage tomorrow? I've got a feeling this one's gonna sting

jmorgan

36,010 posts

286 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
On the water bubbling over bit, mine did that.
On being checked at the garage they started it with the rad cap off and air bubbles were comming out. Ended up both heads cracked.
My problem may be completly unrelated to yours so don't take it as gospel.

dickymint

24,543 posts

260 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
Would that be small frothy white bubbles? cos mine did that the other week when the hose split and i had to to fill it with coolant. And to top it all, today i found a small crack in the middle of the vee just forward of the bell housing, which small drops of oil would ooze out under acceleration. Doesn't sound good eh!!

jmorgan

36,010 posts

286 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
Isn't that V bit you are talking about just a cover?
Suppose the bubbles were but I bet there are a lot less than cracked heads can cause that?

Brm Brm

217 posts

276 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
Have to say it does sound like a head/head gasket problem. Even more likely if it continues to chuck coolant out immediately after the engine is switched off. Why dont you whip the heads off and have a look (a Haynes Rover V8 manual is much cheaper than a garage) - its not a huge job and it might only be a gasket gone. Unlikely to be a cracked head if its been running well for a while and has not had any undue provocation such as overheating.

Not quite sure why this would stop the engine during normal running though, even a severe leak would not normally stop it completely. (I managed to limp off the motorway on 4 cylinders in a 350 a few years ago and it kept running). You may as you say have another problem causing that. Some sort of electrical connection breaking down when it gets hot perhaps? possibly leading to a fuel starvation or ignition problem??? Probably best to get the heads checked out first though.

Good Luck!

jellyed

331 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
fuel comeing up ok ??????

dickymint

24,543 posts

260 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
bit rude earlier Bob didnt mean to pinch your thread. will start a new one tomorrow. Good luck with yours. Ps had similar prob as you and it turmed out to be ignition module breaking down when hot.

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Sunday 5th January 2003
quotequote all
Don't worry about it Dicky! (pinching the thread that is, you should probably worry about the engine )

I've got to agree with you Brm that I can't see how one cylinder - even if it was full of coolant - would stop the engine running.

When it did stop, the engine smelled a bit "gassy" to me which first made me wonder about over-fueling problems, but it doesn't run rough first, it just stops (maybe ignition module?).

I can't help thinking I'd be better off with a good old bank of carbs instead of all this electronic wizardry!

But what I really need it good ol' Steve Heath to come online and tell me theres a screw located in the bottom of the boot which I just have to rotate half a turn and It'll all be fine!

Where are you when I need ya Steve?!

wedg1e

26,809 posts

267 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Could easily be something as daft as a poor connection to the ECU's water temp sender. If you pull the lead off the sender while the engine's running, it dies. So any combination of heat/ damp/ vibration could be the cause....

Ian

shpub

8,507 posts

274 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Sounds like a head gasket or similar problem. I wouldn't drive the car but get it to hospital and it might just be a gasket and you might have saved the heads from warping. When they strip the car chcek the cams etc just in case they need replacing.

Easiest way to see if it is a gasket is to do a cooklent chmical test. Lot quicker and easier than whipping the heads off which is pretty specialised work. Lots of things to get wrong.

Steve

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Sound advice as usual Steve. Good point about the chemical test.
Is it true what I heard about the heads on these sometimes going porous?

shpub

8,507 posts

274 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Porous heads, cracked blocks and heads, duff head gaskets have all happened. But they are the exception. Most cases are failed gaskets and if caught early enough will not require cylinder head skimming or replacement.

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Must be unlucky! I ended up replacing cylinder heads on both my previous cars. I've never yet got away with just a gasket.

camlifter

16 posts

267 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Bobfrance,

So many things to go wrong, but don't rule out some kind of electrical failure. When the engine dies, does it splutter or does it just cut out? I ask because I had a problem with my immobiliser circuit last year - the relays were failing under load (once they were hot) and the engine was just cutting out at the strangest of times. Change of immobilizer; problem solved.

Regards

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Don't worry I'm not ruling anything out yet.
I'm still hoping It'll be something cheap!

I too had a duff immobilizer (the fault sounds similar to yours) but I won't be that - I pulled it out a couple of months ago (problem solved!).

mark.tideswell

19 posts

286 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
I know it sounds to good to be true ,you say the car was ticking over when it overheated have you checked the electric fan is working .When i had my 350 the mot testing station left it ticking over and the water came gushing out of the expansion tank!,anway it turned out that the fan was siezed solid!{they dont seem to get used much}as for cutting out it could be fuel pump on its way out {they tend to come back to life when they been left to cool down}or even bad Electrics

bobfrance

Original Poster:

1,323 posts

269 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
True. But I'm pretty sure it didn't overheat - the temp guage reading was way down and the coolant that was being pushed out of the tank wasn't that "steamy" if you know what I mean.

Blimey! my head's swimming with possibilities.

mark.tideswell

19 posts

286 months

Monday 6th January 2003
quotequote all
Yes but you cant really go off the gauge i dont think they are that acurate!and the sender could be faulty anyway{had to buy a new one for mine} , if it is standing still with engine runnig it should in theory be moveing up and down as the thermostate opens/closes i also remember c/neil telling me that there were 2 types of sender fitted you had to have the one that matches the gauge

kevinday

11,700 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th January 2003
quotequote all
Maybe water pump?