Stereo Lithography

Author
Discussion

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
I read an interesting article about the new Ford GT(40) and how they have managed go from prototype to near finished in 16 months..

They used a technique called stereo lithography to prototype and assemble complex plastic parts without tooling costs and timescales of weeks.

I wonder if TVR could use something like this to improve their build quality without dramatically increasing their costs...

plotloss

67,280 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Stereo Lithographs are probably wayyyy beyond TVR's budget...

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
oh. I didn't think they would be so expensive, especially as tooling is about 1million £££...

PS. That was a bloody quick answer!

plotloss

67,280 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Dont know about the industrial jobs but a desktop Stereo Lithograph for making tiny 3D models is around £20K.

Christ knows how much one would be thats capable of making a panel.

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
But I'm sure an extra £5,000 per car and you have paid for it? as well as a massive increase in quality.

If my car had more precision made seals etc I would pay an extra £5,000!

Bodo

12,382 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
we're having the budget for one next year
For scientific testing purposes of course

There's a model, which works with clay/gypsum, so running costs are low. These models start at €45k, and are useable in the office, so no dirt and dust flying around.

I gues, they will be standard for every product development environment in five to ten years.

Size Nine Elm

5,167 posts

286 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Depends on volumne, they could always outsource...

Quick search shows www.prototype3d.com/

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Do I think I have a point here or am I talking out of my depth?

Bodo

12,382 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
tuscan_s said:
But I'm sure an extra £5,000 per car and you have paid for it? as well as a massive increase in quality.

If my car had more precision made seals etc I would pay an extra £5,000!
I don't think, they'll need 5k per car to amortise. Developers will be quicker and more spontaneous for ideas/testing.
Rapid prototyping increases time-to-market, as CAD, CAE, CAM already did. It's just a step further, and the way to go, even for smaller businesses.

plotloss

67,280 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Yes, but we are dealing with a company here where the factory dog makes styling changes

I am sure that it would have many many positive benefits but I just cant see TVR releasing the cash for something like that for quite some time.

A spin off question would perhaps be would SL'ing compromise the hand built cottage industry feel that TVR have?

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
I'm sure TVR could benefit from this new advance, especially as they are all engineers and would love to have such an invaluable tool at their disposal.

How does a Stereo Lithographic company get new business? Maybe someone should give them TVR's number

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
plotloss said:

A spin off question would perhaps be would SL'ing compromise the hand built cottage industry feel that TVR have?


Well they use a wind tunnel and CAD programming for the T350C and T440R...

plotloss

67,280 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
tuscan_s said:

plotloss said:

A spin off question would perhaps be would SL'ing compromise the hand built cottage industry feel that TVR have?



Well they use a wind tunnel and CAD programming for the T350C and T440R...


Yep fair point...

Bodo

12,382 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
plotloss said:
Yes, but we are dealing with a company here where the factory dog makes styling changes

I am sure that it would have many many positive benefits but I just cant see TVR releasing the cash for something like that for quite some time.

A spin off question would perhaps be would SL'ing compromise the hand built cottage industry feel that TVR have?

TVR is already using CAD (as seen in their website's factory tour). I don't know which application they've bought, but one comprehensive Pro/Engineer license can cost up to €30k, and so are all the other state-of-the-art MCAD packages.


Here's an interesting link about RP:
www.visionsandinnovations.com/works/rapid/main2.html

swilly

9,699 posts

276 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
I was under the impression TVR already used a custom Stereo lithography process - block of foam and PW and Ned hacking/biting away in a mad Jackson Pollock kinda way.

crimsonchim

421 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
If you want a limited number of custom plastic parts, then it's probably the cheapest way to do it. Not to mention having them back in a day or two as opposed to waiting 12 weeks for the tooling to arrive.

SLA machines can cost £750,000, but it is only one type of rapid prototyping. FDM or SLS would be OK for most things and there are loads of companies doing RP on a contract basis.

SLS is easier to get more parts in one build envelope, so individual parts are reletively cheaper, I'd think that would be useful for loads of things on TVRs.

Also you can produce all manner of funky shapes that wouldn't be possible by machining and moulding.

... sorry, I'll put my anorak away and go home now.

tuscan_s

Original Poster:

3,166 posts

275 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
Interesting. Is there a maximum size that you can create? E.g can you create say, a Tuscan bodyshell or are we talking about rear headlight assemblies or door seals etc...

crimsonchim

421 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
tuscan_s said:
Interesting. Is there a maximum size that you can create? E.g can you create say, a Tuscan bodyshell or are we talking about rear headlight assemblies or door seals etc...


Small parts. Generally up to about 300 mm cube. I saw a test piece on a SLA machine at DeMontford university that looked like a full size car wheel (in resin though), so I guess that machine could do 16 or so inches and pretty accurate (and for 7 or 8 hundred grand you'd want it to be!).

There are a veriety of materials avilable including metals and one rubber like compound.

SLS in nylon is probably most useful to the automotive industry, most machines have a build envelope of approx. 300 * 300 * maybe 450 deep, but some newer ones are now offering 700 x 380 x 580mm. Maybe enough to knock out your own custom rocker cover! Bigger than that and you'd have to make it in sections.

RP isn't part of my job, just an interest. Nearest thing you can get to the replicators in Star Trek!

FourWheelDrift

88,726 posts

286 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all
I thought Lithographs were those early porn pictures of the 19th century?

And Stereo Lithographs were these ones where you look through a couple of lenses at 2 photo's one with the left eye and one with the right eye and it appears 3D

As in.....

crimsonchim

421 posts

272 months

Wednesday 18th June 2003
quotequote all

Careful, that could be someone here's granny!