M3 e36 or e46?

M3 e36 or e46?

Author
Discussion

toady1

Original Poster:

1,614 posts

226 months

Monday 14th May 2007
quotequote all
Hi, i'm looking at getting my next car, and I want it to be a dual road and 'every now and then' trackday fun car. Question is, do i go for a cheaper e36 and spend some money on upgraded brakes/suspension, or spend a bit more and go for the newer e46? what are peoples opinions, preferably if you've real life experience of the two! thanks!

toady1

Original Poster:

1,614 posts

226 months

Tuesday 15th May 2007
quotequote all
yeah it would be a nicer car for everyday use, but is the extra 8+ grand worth it as i would like to put it on track too. Which one is more of a drivers car, forgetting all the newer gadgets the e46 has?

toady1

Original Poster:

1,614 posts

226 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
well ive got a bec kit car for my proper track day fun car, the bmw or whatever i get is mainly for the road, and the odd trackday to learn its personality, and as a good back up if the weathers wet and ive a trackday booked!
My last fun car was a cerbera, so im used to the worry in the back of my mind, but dont think the repair bill will be quite as bad if the m3 did go wrong. I aggree the e30 m3 is the best drivers m3 they have done, but wouldnt be for me as an everyday car. I think i might save a few more months and go for an £18k'ish e46. Is that price going to get me a decent one or should i look out? I could get a 15k one now, and there are a few on the trader for around that price, but what is there that could go wrong with them at that price? would it be a false economy?

Do the e46's still suffer from the alleged 36 evos VANOS probs? or has this been sorted now?


Edited by toady1 on Wednesday 16th May 13:40