Sonic booms – Concorde exempt?

Sonic booms – Concorde exempt?

Author
Discussion

Frimley111R

Original Poster:

15,725 posts

236 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
I was watching the Discovery Channel last night which covered Boeing’s attempt to make a bigger, fatter, faster version. One key issue was the sonic boom which, as tested on unsuspecting residents in Omaha by the military :Hehe:, seriously pissed them off.

I couldn’t figure out why the US plane could cause a sonic boom near/affecting residents of cities/town. Surely it’d be way up in the sky? Also, if it did for whatever reason, why didn’t Concorde do the same?

Sheets Tabuer

19,165 posts

217 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Pretty sure concorde only went supersonic over water as it seriously pissed everyone off on land too.

ScoobyDood

2,140 posts

161 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Sheets Tabuer said:
Pretty sure concorde only went supersonic over water as it seriously pissed everyone off on land too.
This

Could often hear the French concorde's "Boom" in the Channel Islands as it went 'super'

SWH

1,261 posts

204 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Grew up in the middle of Devon and used to hear Concorde every evening going supersonic over the Bristol Channel - made the front room windows rattle and the massive flat barn roof shake a tiny bit - Boom, b-b-boom is probably the best description, great stuff smile

JonnyFive

29,408 posts

191 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
SWH said:
Grew up in the middle of Devon and used to hear Concorde every evening going supersonic over the Bristol Channel - made the front room windows rattle and the massive flat barn roof shake a tiny bit - Boom, b-b-boom is probably the best description, great stuff smile
I'd love this, would be excellent biggrin

I remember reading somewhere it'd fly normally out from London until Bristol, then open the engines up.

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Also possible to hear in the South of Ireland as BA Concordes went supersonic.

In the early 1960s it was assumed that the public would accept sonic booms as the price of progress. By the early 70s that was not the case.

oilydan

2,030 posts

273 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
SWH said:
Grew up in the middle of Devon and used to hear Concorde every evening going supersonic over the Bristol Channel - made the front room windows rattle and the massive flat barn roof shake a tiny bit - Boom, b-b-boom is probably the best description, great stuff smile
I grew up in North Cornwall and used to see the con-trails and hear the Boom, B-B-Boom every evening at around 6pm.

Thanks for the nostalgia trip!!

Nowadays we get it almost every day as I work on the outskirts of Abu Dhabi, near the Airforce base where they have loads of fast-jets playing over the 'Empty Quarter'. Some days it sounds like constant thunder...

anonymous-user

56 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
There certainly used to be a morning 10:30 and evening 19:00 LHR JFK service but I think later on there was only one. Some of the flights changed around a bit and some were only part of the year also.

Tango13

8,546 posts

178 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Did the program mention what type of aircraft was used for the tests? I'd take a guess that it was the XB-70. The XB-70 pilots didn't like the boom tests as they had to fly at very low weights to accurately simulate any future SST which left them very little fuel in case of emergencies.

The USAF are very careful about where they fly supersonic anyway, dams and Native American burial grounds being the two I can remember but there are other no boom zones too.

Mave

8,209 posts

217 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
I remember sailing across the channel when a Concorde went over - scared the crap out of me!

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
The Space Shuttle was definitely exempted from the ban on overland sonic booms - mainly because there was no choice in the matter.

cabbron

416 posts

219 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
was out on the bay of biscay and will never forget the sight in a clear blue sky and that crack of the sonic boom,good memory

Le TVR

3,092 posts

253 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
I couldn’t figure out why the US plane could cause a sonic boom near/affecting residents of cities/town. Surely it’d be way up in the sky? Also, if it did for whatever reason, why didn’t Concorde do the same?
The physical effect of the boom is over-pressure. How much over-pressure is generated depends on the mass of the object not just the speed. Therefore the Boeing plan for a bigger and significantly heavier aircraft resulted in projected over-pressure figures that would have been near an order of magnitude greater than Concorde.

Frimley111R

Original Poster:

15,725 posts

236 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Tango13 said:
Did the program mention what type of aircraft was used for the tests? I'd take a guess that it was the XB-70. The XB-70 pilots didn't like the boom tests as they had to fly at very low weights to accurately simulate any future SST which left them very little fuel in case of emergencies.

The USAF are very careful about where they fly supersonic anyway, dams and Native American burial grounds being the two I can remember but there are other no boom zones too.
It didn't but it did say that flying jets over a city just to see what would happen and without telling anyone would never be allowed today!! Apparently 7000 people complained and 5000 sued!

daz3210

5,000 posts

242 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Does the boom just occur as the sound barrier is breached, or does it travel with the plane?

Jim Campbell

445 posts

224 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
According to wiki F104, B58, F101 and the odd F106 was used in the Oklahoma city tests http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_sonic...

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
Does the boom just occur as the sound barrier is breached, or does it travel with the plane?
It travels with the aircraft and it is heard by each individual as it passes by them.

Hugo a Gogo

23,378 posts

235 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Also possible to hear in the South of Ireland as BA Concordes went supersonic.
yep, I used to hear it in West Cork every evening when I lived there, not loud though

Redwing

912 posts

228 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
I was in Yeovil in about 1976 when Concorde did it by accident!

Nobby Diesel

2,058 posts

253 months

Wednesday 14th March 2012
quotequote all
I once flew to Washington DC on the Concorde and it was a totally unique experience.
Hearing the BOOM, feeling the thud in the middle of your back and watching the Mach meter at the front of the cabin was incredible.
What I remember most vividly though, was the view out of the window.
The sky was almost black and the curveture of the earth was huge, both due to the altitude. The in flight wallet that you were given, had what was then, extraordinary luxury inside. A note pad, a pencil, a deck of playing cards, a fact sheet, a fold up tooth brush and tooth paste and finally, some eye shades.
Why, on Gods earth you would need to sleep on a 3 and a half hour flight, aboard the Concorde, I could never fathom.
The most memorable fact from the Fact Sheet, was that if flew 23 miles a minute at full thrust!!
Another enduring memory that I have, was of the degree of side flex in the fuselage. In flight, it almost snaked along.
This all made a huge impression on me and I'm a little surprised at how much I can recall from 1976, when I was a kid of 10!