Greatest live male vocal

[anonymous-user]

Zod said:

It has to be Robert Plant.

For proof, if required, watch Achilles Last Stand on the Led Zep DVD, mighty stuff. I'd also nominate Jeff Buckley on the Mystery White Boy album.

[ratbane]

excel789 said:

Zod said:

It has to be Robert Plant.

For proof, if required, watch Achilles Last Stand on the Led Zep DVD, mighty stuff. I'd also nominate Jeff Buckley on the Mystery White Boy album.

Plant is quoted as saying ALS is his favorite Zep track too.

Jeff Buckley - listen how good So Real is.

[Pupp]

sevros1981 said:

Not to say I don't love Plant, but when Elvis was around, he was the presence.

Elvis played our local for last New Year. He was ok I suppose but I think Percy would have him

[Pupp]

Ok, bit against the rock bias here but I'll raise you all a swift Horace Andy ona good night as someone who is both engaging and articulate in a reggae stylee....Rewind!

[jesusbuiltmycar]

sevros1981 said:

jesusbuiltmycar said:

Zod said:

It has to be Robert Plant.

No one can match Plant for stage presence!

Have you watched Elvis comeback 1968 special? Plant pinched his and Howling Wolf's act! Not to say I don't love Plant, but when Elvis was around, he was the presence.

Edited by sevros1981 on Tuesday 28th April 15:48

Are you sure you are not confusing presence with physical size?

[ratbane]

jesusbuiltmycar said:

sevros1981 said:

jesusbuiltmycar said:

Zod said:

It has to be Robert Plant.

No one can match Plant for stage presence!

Have you watched Elvis comeback 1968 special? Plant pinched his and Howling Wolf's act! Not to say I don't love Plant, but when Elvis was around, he was the presence.

Edited by sevros1981 on Tuesday 28th April 15:48

Are you sure you are not confusing presence with physical size?

....or the fact that Plant sang particularly well on Presence. (Achilles Last Stand in particular)!!! SORRY.

[sevros1981]

jesusbuiltmycar said:

sevros1981 said:

jesusbuiltmycar said:

Zod said:

It has to be Robert Plant.

No one can match Plant for stage presence!

Have you watched Elvis comeback 1968 special? Plant pinched his and Howling Wolf's act! Not to say I don't love Plant, but when Elvis was around, he was the presence.

Edited by sevros1981 on Tuesday 28th April 15:48

Are you sure you are not confusing presence with physical size?

No. Not in 1968. Besides the fact, what does physical size have to do with stage presence and quality of voice?

Pavarotti?

[rupert the dog]

Eddie Vedder. No question. Close the thread
Actually, don't close it. Could be Plant, or Marriott, or Stewart, or Tom Waits even (I love him, but he hasn't exactly got a classic voice)But at the moment I've been listening to Vedder, and he's good.

Edited by rupert the dog on Wednesday 29th April 21:04

[AL...Ease]

Some who surprised me with how consistent their live voices were:

Dave Grohl
Till Lindemann (Rammstein)
Ben Folds