The "Do we need Dads?" thread

Author
Discussion

tonyvid

Original Poster:

9,870 posts

245 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
I was watching that programme on BBC2 last night about separated families...I fully expected PH to have boiled dry by now but can't find any mention - where is the thread then?

no1special

1,026 posts

179 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
I never saw the program, but in answer to your question, YES, in my opinion.

becksW

14,682 posts

213 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
Absolutely Yes, didn't see the program, whilst plenty of people grow up fine without one parent or occ neither, if you have a good Dad, it can only be an advantage.

tonyvid

Original Poster:

9,870 posts

245 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
It was quite a shocking programme actually - it was about Dads really trying to be fair and provide and get their share of parenting...apart from the 2 mothers who were either unappreciative or being a total cow. As I said, shocking.

TankRizzo

7,315 posts

195 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
I watched it. I had a lot of sympathy with the white dad as he was obviously trying very hard to make things work and see his children, only to be torpedoed by his cow of an ex-wife at every turn. However, I did get the impression we weren't being told the whole story about the two of them. She was clearly still very, very bitter about the breakup (hence the comments like "I don't need a man" now and again), and was blatantly using the kids as a tool in her little power games with him.

I noticed that the presenter said they'd been separated for four years, but the littlest of the four kids couldn't have been more than three or four.

LeeME3

1,502 posts

228 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
TBH I thought the programme was pretty sh!te - judging from the title I was expecting some analysis, debate, maybe even some informed (ie researched) opinion. Obviously I should haven't raised my hope so high (it was the BBC after all) as it just seemed like another type of reality TV to me.

shakotan

10,733 posts

198 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
Chris Rock said:
I'm tired of this st, and a bunch of girls are like:

"You don't need no man
to help you raise no child."

Please shut the fk up with the bullst. Yeah, you can do it without a man, but that don't mean it's to be done.

st, you could drive a car with your feet if you want to, that don't make it a good fking idea.
Edited by shakotan on Thursday 1st April 11:29

tonyvid

Original Poster:

9,870 posts

245 months

Thursday 1st April 2010
quotequote all
LeeME3 said:
TBH I thought the programme was pretty sh!te - judging from the title I was expecting some analysis, debate, maybe even some informed (ie researched) opinion. Obviously I should haven't raised my hope so high (it was the BBC after all) as it just seemed like another type of reality TV to me.
I thought it was pretty good, actually - plenty of time for it all to breathe rather than being stuffed with "earlier we saw" crap. It reminded me of those old A to B programmes that stared the whole reality thing off, they were so clever. We only got to see what they edited which can always have a bias - I would have liked to known more about the backgrounds and why there was so much bitterness though.

The black couple appeared to start off well but the women didn't look so good at the end of the prog - he was struggling to pay both mortgages, got to the point of reposession and she decides to get an Au Pair when he finds a new way to finance things! I was really hoping the white bloke would shag his ex-wife's Au Pair...

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd April 2010
quotequote all
Just managed to catch this.

White guy was a bit of a tool, but clearly had his heart in the right place. Thought they gave his ex a far too easy ride - the shot of him weeping after she'd refused him the kids in the morning reshown just after she'd lied through her teeth about him even being there being the only exception.

The whole programme was just very sad and way too close to home.

tonyvid

Original Poster:

9,870 posts

245 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
2nd episode in on Wed, BBC2 at 21:00.