Would you vote for Scottish Independence in 2019

[TheRainMaker]

As it seems the Scottish Independence thread is picking up steam again, the topic of voting has come up.

How would you vote in 2019?

This is just a simple Yes or No, the main thread is for the debate

[hotchy]

What's the point? Brexit wont happen so this wont happen. Waste of time.

[XCP]

I live in England. I would.

I bet I don't get a say though.

[TheRainMaker]

Just interested that's all.

In the main thread, a few people seem very sure the overwhelming majority of Scotts want independence and would vote yes, I'm not so sure.

[Leicester Loyal]

I'm English and I'd vote yes.

[technodup]

TheRainMaker said:

Just interested that's all.

In the main thread, a few people seem very sure the overwhelming majority of Scotts want independence and would vote yes, I'm not so sure.

One person.

[Harry H]

Living in England I won't get a vote but given the choice I'd vote for their independence just to shut up Jimmy Cranky and get her off our TV screens.

One for the "never tire of punching in the face" thread.

[Evercross]

hotchy said:

What's the point? Brexit wont happen so this wont happen. Waste of time.

This (plus the two issues are not directly related, despite what Nicola Sturgeon and fatty Blackford say).

Oh, and if a marginal Brexit referendum result can be overturned by the political 'elite' (with the support of Nicola Sturgeon) then Scottish nationalists should realise so can a vote for Scottish independence.

Edited by Evercross on Wednesday 13th March 15:08

[TheRainMaker]

technodup said:

TheRainMaker said:

Just interested that's all.

In the main thread, a few people seem very sure the overwhelming majority of Scotts want independence and would vote yes, I'm not so sure.

One person.

Two really

But either way, just interested which way it would go on a poll without an agenda.

[PositronicRay]

How much would they pay?

[Evercross]

TheRainMaker said:

Two really

Edinburger claims to have voted no, apparently.

[XCP]

Harry H said:

Living in England I won't get a vote but given the choice I'd vote for their independence just to shut up Jimmy Cranky and get her off our TV screens.

One for the "never tire of punching in the face" thread.

As it affects the rest of the UK massively, I can't see why the rest of us shouldn't have a vote.

[otolith]

Evercross said:

hotchy said:

What's the point? Brexit wont happen so this wont happen. Waste of time.

This (plus the two issues are not directly related, despite what Nicola Sturgeon and fatty Blackford say).

Oh, and if a marginal Brexit referendum result can be overturned by the political 'elite' (of which Sturgeon is a part of) then Scottish nationalists should realise so can a vote for Scottish independence.

And if it does happen, and we end up with a hard Irish border, do the Scots want one too?

[Evercross]

XCP said:

As it affects the rest of the UK massively, I can't see why the rest of us shouldn't have a vote.

For the same reason 27 other countries didn't get to vote on Brexit?!

[dingg]

Rebuild the wall ....

[powerstroke]

XCP said:

I live in England. I would.

I bet I don't get a say though.

Me too , however they arn't all chippy malcontent buggers don't judge them using the SNP as a benchmark .....

[Edinburger]

XCP said:

I live in England. I would.

I bet I don't get a say though.

Yeah, I'm really annoyed I don't get a say in elections in areas that I don't live in too.

[Edinburger]

TheRainMaker said:

Just interested that's all.

In the main thread, a few people seem very sure the overwhelming majority of Scotts want independence and would vote yes, I'm not so sure.

Scots. One 't'. Unless you mean people called Scott?

Not sure how long you've been looking at that thread, but no one has suggested "the overwhelming majority" of Scots (one 't') would vote for independence.

[Edinburger]

Evercross said:

TheRainMaker said:

Two really

Edinburger claims to have voted no, apparently.

You've only been here three months...?!

[Edinburger]

dingg said:

Rebuild the wall ....

Hadrian's Wall?

You know that's entirely in England, right?