VAT

Author
Discussion

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
Excuse the stupid question, but can anyone register for VAT? I mean, I don't sell anything, I'm not self employed (but I could register myself if needed), but what's stopping me registering and claiming VAT back on my new £2.5k Macbook for example?

Someone's going to come along with a logical answer I'm sure, as it can't be that easy!

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

159 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
audi321 said:
Excuse the stupid question, but can anyone register for VAT? I mean, I don't sell anything, I'm not self employed (but I could register myself if needed), but what's stopping me registering and claiming VAT back on my new £2.5k Macbook for example?

Someone's going to come along with a logical answer I'm sure, as it can't be that easy!
You need to have, or will have, VATable supplies (sales).

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
PurpleMoonlight said:
You need to have, or will have, VATable supplies (sales).
But what if it's been a quiet time in Audi321 enterprises, and there hasn't been any?

megaphone

10,804 posts

253 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
You, have to be trading either as a company or self employed, then you have to charge VAT on your income, issue VAT invoices.

Nothing to stop you starting a 'company' and then claiming all the VAT back on the start up costs, then closing the company. Just be ready for the VAT man to come knocking!

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
megaphone said:
You, have to be trading either as a company or self employed, then you have to charge VAT on your income, issue VAT invoices.

Nothing to stop you starting a 'company' and then claiming all the VAT back on the start up costs, then closing the company. Just be ready for the VAT man to come knocking!
When you say 'company' do you mean Ltd? I wouldn't want to do this, but sole traders can be VAT registered can't they?

megaphone

10,804 posts

253 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
audi321 said:
megaphone said:
You, have to be trading either as a company or self employed, then you have to charge VAT on your income, issue VAT invoices.

Nothing to stop you starting a 'company' and then claiming all the VAT back on the start up costs, then closing the company. Just be ready for the VAT man to come knocking!
When you say 'company' do you mean Ltd? I wouldn't want to do this, but sole traders can be VAT registered can't they?
Yes. But all this is hypothetical as I'm sure you would not want to defraud HMRC.

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
megaphone said:
Yes. But all this is hypothetical as I'm sure you would not want to defraud HMRC.
Of course not :/

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
On what grounds would you be making the VAT reclaims?

In order to register for VAT you must supply them with details of your trading activity -

the date it commenced
the type of VAT supplies it intends to make
the likely turnover (sales) figure in its first 12 months of trade

If you fail to supply them with any of this information, they won't register you.

Terminator X

15,270 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
Whilst you chaps are technically correct the likelihood of HMRC chasing down the OP must be so small as to be virtually zero? You takes your chances etc though OP. Even if they did catch up surely you'd then just pay the vat?

TX.

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
Well my idea was.......register as self employed as an IT Consultant or something like that on the HMRC site, and then as VAT registered on the VAT site. Buy said Macbook as the tools needed to complete my 'work'. Claim the VAT back (over £400) and then tell them it didn't work out and 'de-register'? No sales made, so no invoices to produce and no VAT to pay?

I assume my actual income (employed) doesn't mess this up?

Alex

9,975 posts

286 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
I'm on the flat rate VAT scheme which means I can only claim the VAT back on items over £2k. Funnily enough, my last two laptops cost just over £2k.

Had to add a blu-ray drive to one to push it over...

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Tuesday 8th September 2015
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
Whilst you chaps are technically correct the likelihood of HMRC chasing down the OP must be so small as to be virtually zero? You takes your chances etc though OP. Even if they did catch up surely you'd then just pay the vat?

TX.
Wanna bet?

If your first few returns bear no relationship to what you told them on your VAT Application - they will be after you pretty promptly.

walm

10,610 posts

204 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
audi321 said:
Well my idea was.......register as self employed...

I assume my actual income (employed) doesn't mess this up?
I can't see any holes in this plan.

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
Indeed - a true criminal mastermind at work.

PurpleTurtle

7,142 posts

146 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
How exactly do you plan to 'claim the VAT back', OP?

The traditional approach (speaking as an IT Contractor, in business for 20yrs, VAT registereg all that time) is for you to submit a VAT return via the online HMRC service totalling your invoices for the period, the VAT charged, VAT being claimed, you paying over the net differnce.

If your top line is a big fat zero but you are asking for money back, dontcha think this might ring a teeny few alarm bells!?

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
walm said:
audi321 said:
Well my idea was.......register as self employed...

I assume my actual income (employed) doesn't mess this up?
I can't see any holes in this plan.
Errrrm you do know you can be both employed and self employed????

audi321

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
PurpleTurtle said:
How exactly do you plan to 'claim the VAT back', OP?

The traditional approach (speaking as an IT Contractor, in business for 20yrs, VAT registereg all that time) is for you to submit a VAT return via the online HMRC service totalling your invoices for the period, the VAT charged, VAT being claimed, you paying over the net differnce.

If your top line is a big fat zero but you are asking for money back, dontcha think this might ring a teeny few alarm bells!?
Yes, they issue a rebate if you have paid more out than you have charged in your invoices. Obviously you have start up costs with a business??

Eric Mc

122,335 posts

267 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
audi321 said:
Errrrm you do know you can be both employed and self employed????
Of course you can.

But the VAT would only apply to your self employed trading.

Your employed income would have no impact whatsoever on your VAT situation.

PurpleTurtle

7,142 posts

146 months

Wednesday 9th September 2015
quotequote all
audi321 said:
PurpleTurtle said:
How exactly do you plan to 'claim the VAT back', OP?

The traditional approach (speaking as an IT Contractor, in business for 20yrs, VAT registereg all that time) is for you to submit a VAT return via the online HMRC service totalling your invoices for the period, the VAT charged, VAT being claimed, you paying over the net differnce.

If your top line is a big fat zero but you are asking for money back, dontcha think this might ring a teeny few alarm bells!?
Yes, they issue a rebate if you have paid more out than you have charged in your invoices. Obviously you have start up costs with a business??
I think Hector might just press his 'Businesses with no trading income that have claimed VAT back' report and come sniffing. It seems to me a preposterously risky proposition to save the VAT on a computer.


oop north

1,603 posts

130 months

Thursday 10th September 2015
quotequote all
Really does sound like a (potentially) criminal/fraudulent act - pretend to be trading to claim back VAT through a non-existent business sounds like deliberately trying to mislead HM Revenue & Customs