Best Wifi enabled thermostat

Best Wifi enabled thermostat

Author
Discussion

ollyprice87

275 posts

162 months

Thursday 3rd October 2019
quotequote all
Tempted to move away from Nest. The app was crap as is and with this Google merge it’s starting to annoy me.

CharlieH89

9,080 posts

167 months

Thursday 3rd October 2019
quotequote all
I have a Tado starter kit and extension still in the boxes.
How much am I looking at a sparky putting the starter kits thermostat on the wall?

shady lee

962 posts

184 months

Thursday 3rd October 2019
quotequote all
CharlieH89 said:
I have a Tado starter kit and extension still in the boxes.
How much am I looking at a sparky putting the starter kits thermostat on the wall?
1 hour max, £60-80 depending on who you get.


CharlieH89

9,080 posts

167 months

Friday 4th October 2019
quotequote all
shady lee said:
CharlieH89 said:
I have a Tado starter kit and extension still in the boxes.
How much am I looking at a sparky putting the starter kits thermostat on the wall?
1 hour max, £60-80 depending on who you get.
Cheers Lee smile

DoubleSix

11,734 posts

178 months

Saturday 5th October 2019
quotequote all
Hey all,

Just checking in for my yearly post to see if Honeywell are going to update their Evohome hardware this century... I still want to jump in but it looks so dated!!

shady lee

962 posts

184 months

Saturday 5th October 2019
quotequote all
DoubleSix said:
Hey all,

Just checking in for my yearly post to see if Honeywell are going to update their Evohome hardware this century... I still want to jump in but it looks so dated!!
Nothing yet.

Same time next year lol?

Edited by shady lee on Sunday 6th October 10:17

Nath911t

584 posts

199 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
I'm looking to change our outdated and old timer stat for our Baxi duo tec combi boiler. One of the reasons been is that you can only set the heating on/off in increments of an hour where been able to turn it on/off at say 6.30 to 7.20 would be better than the current 6 to 8. Do the timers on these new smart meters work that way?

I like the idea of been able to put heat into certain zones as we have a dual stove burner in the lounge but not too keen on some of the prices.

jet_noise

5,677 posts

184 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Nath911t said:
I'm looking to change our outdated and old timer stat for our Baxi duo tec combi boiler. One of the reasons been is that you can only set the heating on/off in increments of an hour where been able to turn it on/off at say 6.30 to 7.20 would be better than the current 6 to 8. Do the timers on these new smart meters work that way?

I like the idea of been able to put heat into certain zones as we have a dual stove burner in the lounge but not too keen on some of the prices.
On the latter.
Would TRVs on rads near the stove do much of what you want cheaply? If you want tech then there are remote control ones.

Mr Pointy

11,344 posts

161 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
jet_noise said:
Nath911t said:
I'm looking to change our outdated and old timer stat for our Baxi duo tec combi boiler. One of the reasons been is that you can only set the heating on/off in increments of an hour where been able to turn it on/off at say 6.30 to 7.20 would be better than the current 6 to 8. Do the timers on these new smart meters work that way?

I like the idea of been able to put heat into certain zones as we have a dual stove burner in the lounge but not too keen on some of the prices.
On the latter.
Would TRVs on rads near the stove do much of what you want cheaply? If you want tech then there are remote control ones.
It's possible he's got the same issue as I have in that the programmer/stat is in the lounge so when the stove is on the lounge gets warm & the heating doesn't come on & the rest of the house is cold. I need to get the stat function out of the lounge or replace the system with a smart control version.

Nath911t

584 posts

199 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Mr Pointy said:
jet_noise said:
Nath911t said:
I'm looking to change our outdated and old timer stat for our Baxi duo tec combi boiler. One of the reasons been is that you can only set the heating on/off in increments of an hour where been able to turn it on/off at say 6.30 to 7.20 would be better than the current 6 to 8. Do the timers on these new smart meters work that way?

I like the idea of been able to put heat into certain zones as we have a dual stove burner in the lounge but not too keen on some of the prices.
On the latter.
Would TRVs on rads near the stove do much of what you want cheaply? If you want tech then there are remote control ones.
It's possible he's got the same issue as I have in that the programmer/stat is in the lounge so when the stove is on the lounge gets warm & the heating doesn't come on & the rest of the house is cold. I need to get the stat function out of the lounge or replace the system with a smart control version.
Pretty much so. When the outside temps drop I like to get the stove going and as you say it turns the heating off for the rest of the place. On the flip side, if I don't put the stove on that room gets colder than the rest of the house.

If smart means setting different rads to different temps and allowing them to turn on/off separately then it something I could probably do with. I've got 7 rads including a towel rad in the bathroom plumbed in to a Baxi duo tec run by a towerstat rf control.

My pet hate at the moment is having to put the heater timer on in hour increments. If I could do it in increments of say 10 minutes or whatever that would save a few hours a week on it's own and would help pay for the new set up.

dmsims

6,569 posts

269 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Evohome does 10 minute increments (I had to check!)

Mr Pointy

11,344 posts

161 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Nath911t said:
Pretty much so. When the outside temps drop I like to get the stove going and as you say it turns the heating off for the rest of the place. On the flip side, if I don't put the stove on that room gets colder than the rest of the house.

If smart means setting different rads to different temps and allowing them to turn on/off separately then it something I could probably do with. I've got 7 rads including a towel rad in the bathroom plumbed in to a Baxi duo tec run by a towerstat rf control.

My pet hate at the moment is having to put the heater timer on in hour increments. If I could do it in increments of say 10 minutes or whatever that would save a few hours a week on it's own and would help pay for the new set up.
The new timers will set in much smaller increments than an hour so they will do what you want, although a full smart system will be at least £600 so you'd need to save a lot of fuel to pay that back. For me it's case of getting the whole house warm & not just the lounge.

shady lee

962 posts

184 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Zoned heating will save money, how much per year is like looking into a crystal ball given the varied amount of different houses, insulation and heating habits.

On my house our energy supplier brought our monthly direct debit down from £120 to now £70 over the course of half a year, but the comfort level is huge too, no more half cold half hot house with poorly placed thermostats.

guindilias

5,245 posts

122 months

Sunday 6th October 2019
quotequote all
Yep, it's a big investment (no matter the system) but will make it's money back - certainly in my house. I was forever leaving rads turned on when there was nobody about, and if I turned the dining room on for having people round it would stay on for a week before I went in there again. Now they all come on and off as needed - and if I'm having people round can set the heating in that room to come on for 5 hours as a one-off.
I like Tado, but others like other things - it is , however, like the "body only" cordless tool trap - once you buy into a brand you are stuck with them unless you want to replace the lot.
Incidentally, I remember reading ages ago that Tado was, not "ipen source" as such, but something along those lines. "Released their API" or something rings a bell.
Does this leave a door open (in a good way) for IT people to code stuff, or is it merely so that third parties like IFTTT can work with it?


ben5575

6,338 posts

223 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
Nath911t said:
Pretty much so. When the outside temps drop I like to get the stove going and as you say it turns the heating off for the rest of the place. On the flip side, if I don't put the stove on that room gets colder than the rest of the house.

If smart means setting different rads to different temps and allowing them to turn on/off separately then it something I could probably do with. I've got 7 rads including a towel rad in the bathroom plumbed in to a Baxi duo tec run by a towerstat rf control.

My pet hate at the moment is having to put the heater timer on in hour increments. If I could do it in increments of say 10 minutes or whatever that would save a few hours a week on it's own and would help pay for the new set up.
You'll need to check your boiler compatibility, but a Tado thermostat (£180) and the separate Extension Kit (£80) will solve your annoyances:

Annoyance 1 - Stove on, heating off

As explained above, this is caused by your current thermostat being located and hardwired in the same room as your stove. The above Tado kit will give you a new battery powered thermostat that you can place in any room (so you can stick/screw it to the wall in you hall for example). The battery powered bit is important as it means it doesn't need hardwiring where you put it. This will cure your put stove on/rest of the house cold issue. (This can be helped by fitting manual TRVs to the rads in your living room for peanuts as suggested above)

Annoyance 2 - hourly increments of heating

The Tado kit is controllable down to the minute via an extremely good app on your phone.

I've had a full Tado kit including TRVs to all rads installed for a week and I cannot stress how impressed I've been with the system. Once you've got your head around the logic (top tip you need a smart TRV in the room with your thermostat), it is incredibly simple to use and very effective.

Re costs, there are two ways of looking at this. Firstly you can obsess about whether it will/will not pay back over a fixed period of time.

Alternatively, you can think about how annoyed you are with your current set up and think that £250 will solve it. The added benefit will be that you'll get some of that money back over time.

For me that is a small cost to have a home that is comfortably heated.

Sheets Tabuer

19,106 posts

217 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
I might be going bonkers so can I have a sanity check,with a nest and Alexa I think I've always said "Alexa turn the heating on" and it worked, now all I'm getting is sorry your (nest) cannot do that.

Is it just me, I know it's been 6 months since I've used it..

dmsims

6,569 posts

269 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
Part of Govt regulations, you don't need the heating on

Nath911t

584 posts

199 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
Thanks all for taking the time to reply in detail with some great info. Much appreciated.

I think it's best I get my wallet out biggrin

The Tado looks a good bit of kit but then so does the Honeywell, Drayton and a few others. If I'm going to do it I might as well do it properly.

bonerp

818 posts

241 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
I've got the Netatmo by Stark. Blends in with my white walls and has never once let me down. Does what I expected it to!

fezster

23 posts

67 months

Monday 7th October 2019
quotequote all
Somebody said:
@ shady lee Do you have OpenTherm with your evohome? I have an OpenTherm replacement boiler covered by insurance due to the old one being beyond uneconomical repair.

I have been dissuaded from going OT due to hot water priorisation as I have an s-plan set up and would be a bad system as S & Y Plan systems were designed in a time where water temperature for heating and hot water was the same. With OpenTherm, space heating can be at a very different temperature (maybe 30 Deg C) to what is then required for hot water reheat (70+ Deg C) and therefore not ideal for modulation system conversions.
I assume you have a HW cylinder?

Evohome boosts the CH temperature to 80 degrees when the HW reheat cycle is on, to solve this exact issue you refer to.