Discussion
Surely the asker can only be "let down" if there were a promise (implied or otherwise) that Mr. Astley *would* "give you up" should you ask for it. Since he has stated quite clearly, many times, that he is "never gonna give you up" then why would you ask for it? How can you be "let down" if you already know the answer to the question? If you already know that he is "never gonna give you up" then he would actually be NOT letting you down by his refusal.
![confused](/inc/images/confused.gif)
Sounds more like setting yourself up for a fall rather than a paradox.
![biggrin](/inc/images/biggrin.gif)
![confused](/inc/images/confused.gif)
Sounds more like setting yourself up for a fall rather than a paradox.
![biggrin](/inc/images/biggrin.gif)
Edited by Strangely Brown on Thursday 25th February 14:13
Strangely Brown said:
Surely the asker can only be "let down" if there were a promise (implied or otherwise) that Mr. Astley *would* "give you up" should you ask for it. Since he has stated quite clearly, many times, that he is "never gonna give you up" then why would you ask for it? How can you be "let down" if you already know the answer to the question? If you already know that he is "never gonna give you up" then he would actually be NOT letting you down by his refusal.
![confused](/inc/images/confused.gif)
Sounds more like setting yourself up for a fall rather than a paradox.
![biggrin](/inc/images/biggrin.gif)
![confused](/inc/images/confused.gif)
Sounds more like setting yourself up for a fall rather than a paradox.
![biggrin](/inc/images/biggrin.gif)
Edited by Strangely Brown on Thursday 25th February 14:13
![clap](/inc/images/clap.gif)
![rofl](/inc/images/rofl.gif)
Perhaps the paradox recognises the folly of youth... Mr Astley was in his 20s when he recorded this pop classic.
as we age, nevers become maybes, and quite often... FFS go on thens.
I for one was never going to turn into my father... Yet here I sit, somewhat disappointed in the physical and cognitive resemblance.
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff