Welcome back Jenson?

Welcome back Jenson?

Author
Discussion

Agent Orange

2,194 posts

248 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
I really rate Button but 2000-2008 really was his own making.
Likewise - big fan of JB and he really did make his own bed in that time. A lot of bad decisions during that period. That's not even with the benefit of hindsight - at the time the moves felt wrong.

JoyDivision

904 posts

205 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
DJRC said:
As for Hamilton? Rapidly becoming a modern great.
A great what?


Maybe look back in another 10 years and see then what he may have achieved.


At the moment he`s just another driver.

RichB

51,932 posts

286 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
DJRC said:
Precisely because it annoys some ppl enough to comment on it rather than on what is being discussed is precisely the reason I continue to do it. That it still riles ppl after 10yrs continues to warm the cockles of my extremely childish heart smile That ppl continue to regard calling someone childish as some kind of deep insult also continues to gladden me smile Just wait until you are able to tell me what a totally uncouth low born gutter dwelling piece of scum I am and fear not stick around for I give plenty such opportunities smile

Or of course you can just ignore it. You would be amazed at the amount of bks I manage to ignore but then I freely expect most of what is said to be drivel. I am rarely disappointed smile
How infantile..................smile
He has always reversed Button's initials, going back years. As long ago as when he was known as DJC on these parts but he added an R when it was pointed out that CJD is Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease and no one wants to be known as a disease! laugh

thegreenhell

15,903 posts

221 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
And why is that? He was put out on loan to Benneton/Renault for two years to make way for Montoya, lost his seat to Alonso in 2003 and neither Williams or Renault chose to renew his contract for 2003. This is where it goes from bad to worse, JB signs a 2+2 contract with BAR with a stipulation that if they lost the Honda engine he could walk and his manager got him a contract with Williams, which was contested by BAR as not only were they keeping the engines, Honda was buying 45% of the team. So while Williams-BMW would become a bloody good car JB was stuck at BAR for another two years. Then JB signs a contract with Williams in 2006 and has to buy his way out of it to stay with Honda for £17m. The 2006 Honda was vastly better than the Williams, he was certainly right about that but for 2007-2008 neither were any good. Meanwhile Montoya had finished 3rd in the WDC in 2002 & 2003, and Alonso would win the WDC twice in the time that Button was battling contracts between Brackley, Enstone & The Grove. Between poor decisions & sitting on a yacht while the test driver grafts at the factory Button got himself into crap cars.

I really rate Button but 2000-2008 really was his own making.
And yet, despite all the poor management decisions, if you were to ask him now would he go back and change anything? That chain of events lead to him being in the right place at the right time with Honda/Brawn to win a WDC. More luck than judgement undoubtedly, but does it matter at the end of your career when you look back?

If he had taken any of those Williams opportunities where would he be now? Neither the team nor any of the other drivers they employed throughout that decade have gone on to win a world title since. The Renault situation was out of his hands, since Flavio wanted his young hotshoe Alonso in the car, and anyway it took a further three years after he had left before the titles went in Enstone's direction, so it wasn't like he hopped straight out of a winning car into a dog.

LDM

372 posts

129 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
JoyDivision said:
DJRC said:
As for Hamilton? Rapidly becoming a modern great.
A great what?


Maybe look back in another 10 years and see then what he may have achieved.


At the moment he`s just another driver.
Totally agree, I think things have changed over the last 15 or so years and suspect some drivers will stand out for more than the number of championships they have one, would you put Vettel or Alonso in the same bracket as Senna?


Jonsnow606

116 posts

116 months

Tuesday 4th November 2014
quotequote all
Lewis should go down as one of the great entertaining racers (win or lose) of all time, Only time will tell if he can ever be mentioned in the same breath as the Senna's, Prost's, Schumacher's etc...

The only 2 of the current list of f1 drivers that have the potential of going down as one of the greats are the obvious two, and Sebastian Vettel isn't one of them, regardless if he goes on and wins another wdc.

Back on topic, it'll be a sad day if Jenson has to retire, or leave f1 next season because his not got a decent car to drive.

BritishRacinGrin

24,811 posts

162 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Europa1 said:
RichB said:
Is snarky the in word?
I didn't think they were snarky, more world weary, dry sarcasm born out of 2 seasons of dragging a dog of a car around the world's racetracks whilst suffering a series of left field strategy calls and currently having his chain seriously yanked by his employer as said employer fawns over the "Spanish samurai"
I didn't know 'snarky' was a word but having looked it up I think it is a perfect description of Button's pit stop remark;

Google Definition said:
snarky

snide and sharply critical.

Smollet

10,833 posts

192 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
DJRC said:
Precisely because it annoys some ppl enough to comment on it rather than on what is being discussed is precisely the reason I continue to do it. That it still riles ppl after 10yrs continues to warm the cockles of my extremely childish heart smile That ppl continue to regard calling someone childish as some kind of deep insult also continues to gladden me smile Just wait until you are able to tell me what a totally uncouth low born gutter dwelling piece of scum I am and fear not stick around for I give plenty such opportunities smile

Or of course you can just ignore it. You would be amazed at the amount of bks I manage to ignore but then I freely expect most of what is said to be drivel. I am rarely disappointed smile
I can relate to that. smile

swisstoni

17,348 posts

281 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
Smollet said:
Going back to the fact that Hamilton has won more GPs than Button I'd venture to say that Button has spent a far greater percentage of his career driving a crap car compared to that of Hamilton.
And why is that? He was put out on loan to Benneton/Renault for two years to make way for Montoya, lost his seat to Alonso in 2003 and neither Williams or Renault chose to renew his contract for 2003. This is where it goes from bad to worse, JB signs a 2+2 contract with BAR with a stipulation that if they lost the Honda engine he could walk and his manager got him a contract with Williams, which was contested by BAR as not only were they keeping the engines, Honda was buying 45% of the team. So while Williams-BMW would become a bloody good car JB was stuck at BAR for another two years. Then JB signs a contract with Williams in 2006 and has to buy his way out of it to stay with Honda for £17m. The 2006 Honda was vastly better than the Williams, he was certainly right about that but for 2007-2008 neither were any good. Meanwhile Montoya had finished 3rd in the WDC in 2002 & 2003, and Alonso would win the WDC twice in the time that Button was battling contracts between Brackley, Enstone & The Grove. Between poor decisions & sitting on a yacht while the test driver grafts at the factory Button got himself into crap cars.

I really rate Button but 2000-2008 really was his own making.
Rather easier to see with 20-20 hindsight. Who would have predicted McLaren would start making boat anchors rather than cars a few years ago.

Jonsnow606

116 posts

116 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Gaz. said:
Smollet said:
Going back to the fact that Hamilton has won more GPs than Button I'd venture to say that Button has spent a far greater percentage of his career driving a crap car compared to that of Hamilton.
And why is that? He was put out on loan to Benneton/Renault for two years to make way for Montoya, lost his seat to Alonso in 2003 and neither Williams or Renault chose to renew his contract for 2003. This is where it goes from bad to worse, JB signs a 2+2 contract with BAR with a stipulation that if they lost the Honda engine he could walk and his manager got him a contract with Williams, which was contested by BAR as not only were they keeping the engines, Honda was buying 45% of the team. So while Williams-BMW would become a bloody good car JB was stuck at BAR for another two years. Then JB signs a contract with Williams in 2006 and has to buy his way out of it to stay with Honda for £17m. The 2006 Honda was vastly better than the Williams, he was certainly right about that but for 2007-2008 neither were any good. Meanwhile Montoya had finished 3rd in the WDC in 2002 & 2003, and Alonso would win the WDC twice in the time that Button was battling contracts between Brackley, Enstone & The Grove. Between poor decisions & sitting on a yacht while the test driver grafts at the factory Button got himself into crap cars.

I really rate Button but 2000-2008 really was his own making.
Rather easier to see with 20-20 hindsight. Who would have predicted McLaren would start making boat anchors rather than cars a few years ago.
Hindsight is a funny thing, but to make THAT many mistakes!?...

Good thing his driving skills haven't had as many holes in it smash

Lewis was always going to be a better driver over the course of their careers, his a better driver, but jenson would also have his moments of fame (wdc, Canada afewyyears ago).

5RedLights

155 posts

129 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
I imagine we'll be getting some news on this at Brazil, if not sooner.

Button has been posting some nostalgic twitter posts in the last couple of days, such as pics of his first year in F1 and his last win.

Button's good friend Coulthard also tweeted a video on "when to call time" the other day.

Alonso seemed to be having a good old eyeball of the Mclaren last weekend too -
http://www.grandprix247.com/2014/11/05/santander-m...

It's naturally a shame he didn't have more success with Mclaren, but when he looks back at his career, particularly from 2009 onwards, surely he'd be happy with what he's acheived?

London424

12,830 posts

177 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
I honestly can't figure out the whole movement thing...everyone (by this I mean Vet and Alonso) are taking steps backwards, with no rule change in sight that might lead to a pot of gold in the future.

Very strange goings on.

Vocal Minority

8,582 posts

154 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
5RedLights said:
I imagine we'll be getting some news on this at Brazil, if not sooner.

Button has been posting some nostalgic twitter posts in the last couple of days, such as pics of his first year in F1 and his last win.

Button's good friend Coulthard also tweeted a video on "when to call time" the other day.

Alonso seemed to be having a good old eyeball of the Mclaren last weekend too -
http://www.grandprix247.com/2014/11/05/santander-m...

It's naturally a shame he didn't have more success with Mclaren, but when he looks back at his career, particularly from 2009 onwards, surely he'd be happy with what he's acheived?
3rd most starts of any F1 driver behind Mickey Cobblers and Mr Barrichello, bagged a teams first win and championship (technically two first wins...but y'know). He's been around a while and in his pomp regularly featured in lists of team principals most rated. Certainly not the waste of space some of the more rabid folk on here would contend!

Kaiser_Wull

149 posts

182 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Vocal Minority said:
3rd most starts of any F1 driver behind Mickey Cobblers and Mr Barrichello, bagged a teams first win and championship (technically two first wins...but y'know). He's been around a while and in his pomp regularly featured in lists of team principals most rated. Certainly not the waste of space some of the more rabid folk on here would contend!
[Nods head in agreement with above]

DanielSan

18,868 posts

169 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Vocal Minority said:
3rd most starts of any F1 driver behind Mickey Cobblers and Mr Barrichello, bagged a teams first win and championship (technically two first wins...but y'know). He's been around a while and in his pomp regularly featured in lists of team principals most rated. Certainly not the waste of space some of the more rabid folk on here would contend!
It speaks volumes about who rates him, not how many people. And the names that do rate him tell you everything you need to know.

Crafty_

13,344 posts

202 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Very unlikely to be going to Porsche http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/116623

shalon

47 posts

152 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Will be a shame if. He leaves the f1 paddock rate him highly which really means things I think his biggest issue is Ron Dennis never hired him it was whitmarsh not sure if he was ever linked to a mclaren drive in the past but Montoya was signed for 2001 before Jb was signed for 2000 I think then Flávio wanted his star pupil alonso in the car personally I'd of kept Jb instead of trullli when he went to bar surprised a lot of people when compared to villneuve drove prob better than the Ferrari drivers in 04 reasonably well in 05 and 06 with midfield equipment showing real form hear or there then terrible cars in 07 and 08 with the odd star drive to tenth etc blitzed barrichello in their time together who was as good as schumi on his day didn't have Hamiltons qualifying speed was always 2 tenths behind but then his tyres could do 5 laps more in first stint which to be fair wasn't reqired a lot of the time deserves a place in f1 and his success he has had

MartG

20,773 posts

206 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Crafty_ said:
Very unlikely to be going to Porsche http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/116623
Maybe Toyota - would stick two fingers up at Honda if he did smile

Crafty_

13,344 posts

202 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Given where Toyota are in the championship I doubt they see the need to change anything.

He can just take some time out, get his wedding sorted and do some triathlons/iron man stuff, maybe settle down and have some kids?

I just ran out of breath trying to read shalon's post.


aeropilot

35,057 posts

229 months

Wednesday 5th November 2014
quotequote all
Crafty_ said:
I just ran out of breath trying to read shalon's post.
laugh

I gave up after the third line.