Wheel Failure - Scary Time...

Wheel Failure - Scary Time...

Author
Discussion

Don1

15,974 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
It's that unusual....


Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

257 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
currybum said:
Non-ferrous metals don’t have a fatigue limit (although practically its assumed to be 10-20million cycles),
10-20 million cycles is the (assumed) fatigue life, not the fatigue limit.

g3org3y

20,754 posts

193 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
Hasbeen said:
Yep. Too much style & not enough substance.

I wonder how many wheel designers are engineers & how many are graphic artists?
OZ are a decent manufacturer and provide a lot of alloys for motorsport including Touring Cars and F1.

Multispoke alloys have been used in BTCC for ages.



HellaflushGT

Original Poster:

38 posts

171 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the vast amount of replies.

These are a set of genuine Mitsubishi wheels which were fitted to homologate the wheel for use in rallying redface

From the factory, the centre caps read O.Z, as shown here, but the wheels are actually manufactured by Enkei and are stamped so on the rear face.

I had them powdercoated in this colour.

I will photograph the other wheels upon work finish, and post for discussion smile

Thanks again, Tommy.

Kawasicki

13,144 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
Any idea of the prior history of the wheels?

Alloy wheel cracking in extended hard use is not unusual.

Powder coating temps could weaken the wheel.

The wheel failed in what is usually the most stressed area.

Herbs

4,933 posts

231 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
Did you actually buy them yourself though?

The reason I linked to the other thread was the fakes come with all correct stamps and hallmarks making them nigh on impossible to tell apart until this happens. The fact all four are doing it especially the rears rule out the type of tyres used.

If you did buy them yourself it may be worthwhile getting them inspected by OZ to ascertain if genuine or not. If they are I would say you may have a good argument for a new set on goodwill. If not genuine it would be in their interest in assisting you in following the paper trail back to where they came from.

Good luck and look forward to seeing the other pictures.

y2blade

56,193 posts

217 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
HellaflushGT said:
Not posted on here for a couple of years, but I thought I'd make you aware of my experience so that somebody in the future could possibly avoid this.

I have a Mitsubishi Evolution VI GSR running around 300hp and was on a spirited drive. As I turned, quite sharply into a large roundabout, this occured, with no impact or collision.



To note, these are genuine wheels!

Any clues as to their failure?

All the other wheels are similarly cracking in the same place, too.
yikes Flippinheck!

otolith

56,865 posts

206 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
Seems unlikely to me that the additional lateral grip of a street legal semi-slick tyre should be capable of damaging a wheel.

HellaflushGT

Original Poster:

38 posts

171 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
I'm 50/50 if I should approach Mitsubishi about it? They might just laugh me off?

Hasbeen

2,073 posts

223 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
When radials first made inroads into sports car racing & bitumen rallying, Morgans, MG A & B & Triumphs started breaking wheels & stub axles.

When we advised Morgan of the problems we were having in Oz with stub axles, it took them less than 6 weeks to have heavier ones available.

At the time regulations called for the original center to be used, but they dropped that pretty quickly.

kayzee

2,875 posts

183 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
HellaflushGT said:
I'm 50/50 if I should approach Mitsubishi about it? They might just laugh me off?
Won't do any harm but I would approach OZ first... must have scared the crap outta you!

Iroquois Plisken

100 posts

134 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
currybum said:
By using slick tyres you have massively increased the level of that cycling
Bridgestone RE 070. Standard fit on the "Blob-Eye" Impreza STI.


AlexIT

1,511 posts

140 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
HellaflushGT said:
I'm 50/50 if I should approach Mitsubishi about it? They might just laugh me off?
Might be an option.

However I cannot recall those wheels actually fitted to any "official" Evo back then.
From memory the Enkei used back then were either 5 spoke or 12 spoke for tarmac only...

And moreover I can't remember that a car manufacturer has to homologate the wheel for rally use.

HellaflushGT

Original Poster:

38 posts

171 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
I'm gonna make the call.

Brilliant tyres btw, would recommend them to anyone!!

AlexIT

1,511 posts

140 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
kayzee said:
HellaflushGT said:
I'm 50/50 if I should approach Mitsubishi about it? They might just laugh me off?
Won't do any harm but I would approach OZ first... must have scared the crap outta you!
But they are stamped Enkei on the alloy tongue out

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

257 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
currybum said:
Strictly correct, but in a practical engineering sense if your non ferrous components can get to 10-20 million cycles without failure you can treat it as a you would a limit on a iron component. As in it's so far away from the number of cycles a component will see in the real world that it may as well be a limit.
20 million cycles in terms of a road wheel doesn't seem to be very much. Given a 2 meter tyre circumference that is only about 25000 miles, and that's cyclic stress just from the cars weight, let alone bumps, potholes and cornering forces.

HellaflushGT

Original Poster:

38 posts

171 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
AlexIT said:
Might be an option.

However I cannot recall those wheels actually fitted to any "official" Evo back then.
From memory the Enkei used back then were either 5 spoke or 12 spoke for tarmac only...

And moreover I can't remember that a car manufacturer has to homologate the wheel for rally use.
These are the wheels that all Evolution VI GSR's left the factory with. They were badged and stickered up as OZ, but were manufactured by Enkei and Stamped Mitsubishi on the reverse.

They used to look like this before I went wild with the paint pot...



These are the wheel which this car came from the factory with smile

AlexIT

1,511 posts

140 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
My bad memory then smile

Herman Toothrot

6,702 posts

200 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
If they are the original wheels the car came with could ask Mitsubishi but then its an old car now and they could say they are simply at the end of their expected lifespan and if the car had been to dealership and a crack spotted they would have said new set required, just like when any other part wears out.

Infact no point asking, its what 12 or 13 years old? Past scrappage time for many vehicles

Edited by Herman Toothrot on Wednesday 8th May 15:10

StottyZr

6,860 posts

165 months

Wednesday 8th May 2013
quotequote all
HellaflushGT said:
I had them powdercoated in this colour.
This will have weakened the metal and caused the fatigue.

All the other wheels are cracking because they went through the same process, I remember a thread a month or two back with countless stories of powder coating causing failures like this in its early days.