Electric London cabs.

Author
Discussion

boz1

422 posts

179 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
Black cabs are absolutely the worst taxi "service" outside of the third world. Incredibly polluting, vast overpriced and driven by unhelpful obnoxious pricks who - contrary to popular acclaim - are ignorant of many destinations and frequently choose terrible routes.

Sooner they're gone, the better. If we want London to look 'pretty' for the tourists, then the easy solution is for TfL to sponsor a couple of hundred Uber drivers to use the the LEVC TXs.

Harji

2,200 posts

162 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
SkodaIan said:
Given how slow traffic is in Central London, I bet many cabs don't do much more than 150 miles in a shift unless they get some longer suburban runs.

I think I've seen somewhere that they have a 200 mile range or thereabouts so probably enough for the average shift. The big advantage of electric cars is that their range isn't affected anywhere near as much as petrol or diesel engines when in stop start traffic as energy use is near zero when stopped.
You ever heard a black cabbie once you say you have along suburban journey? You get to hear his world's problems how many kids he has to feed. Short and many trips are preferable to them in my experience.

Challo

10,245 posts

156 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
Venisonpie said:
Challo said:
How much are the new electric cabs for drivers to buy?
I take it the half fuel cost offset some of that fee?
Circa 65k. I'm touring the factory in a couple of weeks to explore the potential to use them in a different configuration for alternative use (still in London).
Thanks. Whats the general rules for Cabbies around having to use these new electric cabs? Will they all be forced to leave the old black cabs and move to electric?

Havent been to london for a few months, but Im sure there is still a huge number of very old cabs knocking around. If they can continue to use the old ones, why would they change?

So

Original Poster:

26,431 posts

223 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
The new ones seem greater in number every time I go down. I suspect they are being pushed quite hard in that direction.

jamei303

3,010 posts

157 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
So said:
The new ones seem greater in number every time I go down. I suspect they are being pushed quite hard in that direction.
£7.5k for buying a leccy one, and £10k for ditching a diesel one, plus a ban on new diesel ones, progressive reductions in age limits for Euro 3, 4 and 5 diesels and free charging in Q-Parks.

longblackcoat

5,047 posts

184 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
Challo said:
Venisonpie said:
Challo said:
How much are the new electric cabs for drivers to buy?
I take it the half fuel cost offset some of that fee?
Circa 65k. I'm touring the factory in a couple of weeks to explore the potential to use them in a different configuration for alternative use (still in London).
Thanks. Whats the general rules for Cabbies around having to use these new electric cabs? Will they all be forced to leave the old black cabs and move to electric?

Havent been to london for a few months, but Im sure there is still a huge number of very old cabs knocking around. If they can continue to use the old ones, why would they change?
There'll be a cost-based switch as the running costs are so much lower and the passenger experience so much better. All new cabs have to be zero-emissions; you certainly couldn't register a new diesel one past 1 January 2018. There's the range-extender LEVC one, Nissan are putting an ell-electric one on the road, and I presume Mercedes will do the same.

The current fleet have a maximum of 12 years life from 2017, I believe, so the last diesel cabs will be off the road by 2029 though I suspect it'll be a lot sooner than that as the new electric ones are just so much cheaper to run and passengers will in any case refuse to use the old rattle-trap cabs.

Challo

10,245 posts

156 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
longblackcoat said:
Challo said:
Venisonpie said:
Challo said:
How much are the new electric cabs for drivers to buy?
I take it the half fuel cost offset some of that fee?
Circa 65k. I'm touring the factory in a couple of weeks to explore the potential to use them in a different configuration for alternative use (still in London).
Thanks. Whats the general rules for Cabbies around having to use these new electric cabs? Will they all be forced to leave the old black cabs and move to electric?

Havent been to london for a few months, but Im sure there is still a huge number of very old cabs knocking around. If they can continue to use the old ones, why would they change?
There'll be a cost-based switch as the running costs are so much lower and the passenger experience so much better. All new cabs have to be zero-emissions; you certainly couldn't register a new diesel one past 1 January 2018. There's the range-extender LEVC one, Nissan are putting an ell-electric one on the road, and I presume Mercedes will do the same.

The current fleet have a maximum of 12 years life from 2017, I believe, so the last diesel cabs will be off the road by 2029 though I suspect it'll be a lot sooner than that as the new electric ones are just so much cheaper to run and passengers will in any case refuse to use the old rattle-trap cabs.
Thanks for the information. Off to London in March so will try and get a ride in one.

pyruse

62 posts

62 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
paultownsend said:
Slightly off topic but I was walking back to Nottingham station on Saturday. I counted over 20 taxi’s in the waiting line. Two were electric, the rest diesel, six with their engines on. Why? They were not moving. If I needed one I would seek out the electric. But I can see that this will eventually create tension between the drivers.

I cannot see how some of the older cabs are road legal.

I then jumped in my stinking diesel train as they won’t electrify the lines. Still, it was heavily overcrowded so that reduces individual carbon footprint, right?
Drivers of diesels in general seem very inclined to sit waiting with their engines running. I've no idea why, but I wish they wouldn't.

AC43

11,511 posts

209 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
So said:
I found myself actively seeking out diesel cabs.
Each to their own and all that.

I personally cannot stand the noise any 4 pot diesel banger makes. In a black cab it's even worse than normal as the whole structure shudders in unison with the horrible old chugging rattling banging dag dag boat anchor under the bonnet.

I hate the experience with a vengeance and getting into an eletric one is bliss in comparison.

Krikkit

26,581 posts

182 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
AC43 said:
So said:
I found myself actively seeking out diesel cabs.
Each to their own and all that.

I personally cannot stand the noise any 4 pot diesel banger makes. In a black cab it's even worse than normal as the whole structure shudders in unison with the horrible old chugging rattling banging dag dag boat anchor under the bonnet.

I hate the experience with a vengeance and getting into an eletric one is bliss in comparison.
Me too, absolutely awful things, I used to pass up getting one if there was any chance of a private hire.

Now I'd seek out an electric one for a short hop, no question.

untakenname

4,973 posts

193 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
So said:
Perhaps I just got unlucky with my drivers this time then, but it was a bit like being in a track car - acceleration or braking and not much in between. Or perhaps the electric cabs just encourage driving that isn't possible in diesels.
They probably just got the cab and still excited about the performance, give it a few months and they will calm down.

Went to ISE a few years back, Schipol airport had just green so only electric cars were allowed in the ranks closest to the airport.
There was a mixture of Leafs and Tesla's, naturally took the Tesla and the driver booted it at every opportunity which was great going from the airport but coming back hungover wasn't as appreciated.

iirc TFL had the same issue with hybrid buses and so reduced the rate of acceleration from standstill so passengers were less likely to fall over so perhaps if there's a demand for less performance from customers then the cabs will have the performance off the line reduced.

So

Original Poster:

26,431 posts

223 months

Monday 24th February 2020
quotequote all
untakenname said:
So said:
Perhaps I just got unlucky with my drivers this time then, but it was a bit like being in a track car - acceleration or braking and not much in between. Or perhaps the electric cabs just encourage driving that isn't possible in diesels.
They probably just got the cab and still excited about the performance, give it a few months and they will calm down.

Went to ISE a few years back, Schipol airport had just green so only electric cars were allowed in the ranks closest to the airport.
There was a mixture of Leafs and Tesla's, naturally took the Tesla and the driver booted it at every opportunity which was great going from the airport but coming back hungover wasn't as appreciated.

iirc TFL had the same issue with hybrid buses and so reduced the rate of acceleration from standstill so passengers were less likely to fall over so perhaps if there's a demand for less performance from customers then the cabs will have the performance off the line reduced.
Interesting stuff.

sasha320

597 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
Spoke to an electric cab driver yesterday and he claimed that the electric cab did 55 miles on a single charge.

He also said he charged it a couple of times per week away from home.

In turn this all suggests that the EV cabbies are using an overnight charge and topping up from time to time but potentially using the petrol generator most of the time.

Better than TX4 diesels but a long way of a transition to fully or mostly electric.

No pun but I guess we’re on a journey migrating to fully electric.

Edited by sasha320 on Tuesday 25th February 09:06


Edited by sasha320 on Tuesday 25th February 09:11

So

Original Poster:

26,431 posts

223 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
sasha320 said:
Spoke to an electric cab driver yesterday and he claimed that the electric cab did 55 miles on a single charge.
I heard this too.


98elise

26,740 posts

162 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
sasha320 said:
Spoke to an electric cab driver yesterday and he claimed that the electric cab did 55 miles on a single charge.

He also said he charged it a couple of times per week away from home.

In turn this all suggests that the EV cabbies are using an overnight charge and topping up from time to time but potentially using the petrol generator most of the time.

Better than TX4 diesels but a long way of a transition to fully or mostly electric.

No pun but I guess we’re on a journey migrating to fully electric.

Edited by sasha320 on Tuesday 25th February 09:06


Edited by sasha320 on Tuesday 25th February 09:11
I see them daily in London and I have never heard one with the engine running.

Timberwolf

5,348 posts

219 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
Was chatting about this with friends today - specifically that the old cabs were so slow and had such a crude chassis the average cabbie could be driving foot to the boards and right on the limit without the passengers noticing any difference from the usual rattling and bouncing. The new electric ones are somewhat different, they do take off quite impressively from low speeds.

sasha320

597 posts

249 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
98elise said:
I see them daily in London and I have never heard one with the engine running.
You won’t, they have an onboard electricity generator fuelled by petrol.

Not an internal combustion engine.

jamei303

3,010 posts

157 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
sasha320 said:
You won’t, they have an onboard electricity generator fuelled by petrol.

Not an internal combustion engine.
How does that petrol-powered electric generator work then, if it's not an internal combustion engine? Is the petrol burned to heat up a big water tank and the electricity generated by a steam-turbine or what?


Venisonpie

3,310 posts

83 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
Interestingly Nissan now have an ENV200 in London taxi spec - these will be half the price of an electric cab with a WLTP range of 120 miles.

98elise

26,740 posts

162 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
sasha320 said:
98elise said:
I see them daily in London and I have never heard one with the engine running.
You won’t, they have an onboard electricity generator fuelled by petrol.

Not an internal combustion engine.
The generator is driven by an ICE so you should be able to hear it if it is running, especially as it's 3 cylinder. Whenever I've been in a Prius you know when it's engine is running.