CTR ep3.....thoughts

Author
Discussion

Grovsie26

1,302 posts

169 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Its not just the looks of the DC5 though, can't believe you prefer the CTR there, but lots of other things, like Steering, seats, LSD, brakes, slighty more powerful engine, etc. Each to there own CTR for 4-5k is a good buy IMO.

An R32 Golf same MPG as a CTR? Are you sure you were putting the fuel in the CTR and not pouring it on the floor?

shibby!

921 posts

200 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
daz4m said:
shibby! said:
Im going to go the other way here........

Hated it!!!!!!!

Hated more than anything on this planet! I even liked a Deisel Golf better than that car! I liked my Subaru which broke down every Monday better than the car.


To me.........

It felt cheap, the engine almost felt and drove like it was a plastic toy, i thought it was quite skittish (which is something i didnt expect), reliable enough..... i thought the get up and go was fairly decent below its 6k, and the vtec did come in well. I didnt think it drove particularly well.
I had an Mr2 turbo before that.... so its not like i was coming from some German Luxo barge before that and was spoilt with quality (although i do think the Mr2 is very well made)

What i would suggest instead is a good Evo 6 or the DC5 Integra.... Other options include a BMW 330ci clubsport, E36 M3.

Good luck anyway, why dont you go try a few.
So after saying all that you recommend a DC5. Very confused.

A nice E36 is a good shout though.
Just known for being a better car........ plus the looks! smilesmile

Its more powerfull has LSD and was built as a follow from the DC2 which was an excellent car. Iw would buy it purely for the looks!

Its more focued, to me you get what you pay for with the Integra Type R's...... the EP3 Civic's were too soft..... esp following the EK9 Civic's.

LuS1fer

41,175 posts

247 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
I'm a lover of coupes but have never thought the Integra a good-looking car.

KaraK

13,203 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
bdgriffiths said:
AshBaldry said:
Just to add...don't let people tell you "yeah there useless before Vtec"
Or
"You need to redline them to get anywhere"

They perform IMHO,fine before 6,000RPM
Glad you said this as I was a little concerned that I wouldn't like the change from mid range grunt in the vrs. A friend had one and he said it was fine before VTEC but just came alive at the top end. Im seriously tempted as it offers me everything i want
I test drove one a few years ago and formed the exact opposite opinion - it was dull as dishwater off-VTEC, felt like any other bland 2.0 petrol and VTEC was over all too quickly, I always felt that it would be great on track where you are 9/10s minimum everywhere but IMO it really didn't work on real roads.

The seating position and gearchange were fantastic (loved that centre console gearshift) but the steering was ste - felt like you were using playstation steering wheel.

daz4m

2,909 posts

197 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
shibby! said:
Just known for being a better car........ plus the looks! smilesmile

Its more powerfull has LSD and was built as a follow from the DC2 which was an excellent car. Iw would buy it purely for the looks!

Its more focued, to me you get what you pay for with the Integra Type R's...... the EP3 Civic's were too soft..... esp following the EK9 Civic's.
Don't disagree, DC5 is the better car but many of your negatives on the Civic also apply the DC5, hence my point.

You've confused me even further now talking about focused cars and then suggesting a 330ci to the OP.

shibby!

921 posts

200 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
daz4m said:
shibby! said:
Just known for being a better car........ plus the looks! smilesmile

Its more powerfull has LSD and was built as a follow from the DC2 which was an excellent car. Iw would buy it purely for the looks!

Its more focued, to me you get what you pay for with the Integra Type R's...... the EP3 Civic's were too soft..... esp following the EK9 Civic's.
Don't disagree, DC5 is the better car but many of your negatives on the Civic also apply the DC5, hence my point.

You've confused me even further now talking about focused cars and then suggesting a 330ci to the OP.
Just an opinion! smile

I just quite liked the 330ci, with the clubsport being a bit more focused i suppose. I suggested it mainly as an alternative. Not really suggesting that he has to buy the most focused.

Normally i would suggest the M3... It would appear to be outside the price range.

The 330ci is just a good car in general. I liked mine, a lot!..... was just an alternative really! wink



I could suggest lots of things i prefer more than the EP3..... i just didnt like it. I do however have no experience with the DC5 and the DC2. So the comment on the DC5 is based mainly on reputation and those looks!! smile

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
shibby! said:
Just known for being a better car........ plus the looks! smilesmile

Its more powerfull has LSD and was built as a follow from the DC2 which was an excellent car. Iw would buy it purely for the looks!

Its more focued, to me you get what you pay for with the Integra Type R's...... the EP3 Civic's were too soft..... esp following the EK9 Civic's.
The JDM Ep3 also has LSD and more powerfull engine, so thats also worth a look.

Grovsie26

1,302 posts

169 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
How can you slate the hell out of the CTR and then reccommend a DC5, or a 330Ci?

Hmmmmmmmm,

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Grovsie26 said:
How can you slate the hell out of the CTR and then reccommend a DC5, or a 330Ci?

Hmmmmmmmm,
Crazy. the Dc5 is better, but not by lot.

danneth

996 posts

189 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
EP3 is an awesome car i had mine 2 years and only changed cause i needed more power and it would have meant spending alot on a n/a

The reliability, gearbox, handling, noise are all just superb, i think its one of them cars where it will always put a smile on your face its just a shame its "only" 200bhp as these days hot hatches are moving well on from that

diddly69

695 posts

179 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
danneth said:
EP3 is an awesome car i had mine 2 years and only changed cause i needed more power and it would have meant spending alot on a n/a

The reliability, gearbox, handling, noise are all just superb, i think its one of them cars where it will always put a smile on
your face its just a shame its "only" 200bhp as these days hot hatches are
moving well on from that
200bhp is plenty enough! biggrin If it ain't broke don't fix it smile

zabba

2,135 posts

217 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
I owned an EP3 for 5 years, and it's probably the best car I have ever owned. I tried several hot hatchs when trying to replace it, GTi Edition 30, VXR, Mk 2 Leon Cupra etc but I didn't find any of them as exciting to drive.

In the end I replaced it with an S2 Exige, fantastic car, but I really do miss the engine and gearbox of the EP3.

The only modification I made to my EP3 was a "fast road" geometry setup, this improved steering feel (often moaned about on the EP3) and sharpened up the handling.

In the 5 years and 50k I had the civic nothing went wrong and nothing rattled, main dealer servicing was reasonable, never more than £250, and the only other costs were tyres and brakes.

You can also get a good facelift EP3 for under £7k, no need to spend £9k.

One thing I would hold against the EP3 though, is it wouldn't make a great everyday car if you do a lot of motorway mileage, that's the only time I could have done with some more low down power.

TameRacingDriver

18,136 posts

274 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
danneth said:
just a shame its "only" 200bhp as these days hot hatches are moving well on from that
Just a shame hot hatches nowadays weigh as much as the moon.

frosted

3,549 posts

179 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Go for it ,IMO if 20mpg is not a problem maybe an rx8 is a better drivers car and more comfortable in the same time ?

Problem with the civic ( had one from new in 2006 for 30k miles) is that it's fwd otherwise fantastic car

danneth

996 posts

189 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Just a shame hot hatches nowadays weigh as much as the moon.
whats an extra 100-200 kgs though when your adding 60-100bhp...

TameRacingDriver

18,136 posts

274 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
danneth said:
whats an extra 100-200 kgs though when your adding 60-100bhp...
How about it harming the handling, making them less involving, worsening fuel consumption, requiring bigger brakes, wheels and tyres, and being harder on them, which in turn makes them more expensive to run and giving worse ride quality, and finally after all that, not really being any faster as a result (note that the 0-100 time of the CTR is barely any worse than many of the fat hatches you talk about) .

There's more to driving enjoyment than BHP figures.

Steameh

3,155 posts

212 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
Owned one for a few months, whilst a very competent car, I never really got along with it as I thought I might.

It was a love hate relationship, loved the car for B-road smashing, but hated the long trips down from Doncaster to Portsmouth to see my then girlfriend.

Spend about 1500 getting the air con fixed as the radiator is in a silly place according to the Honda dealer who did the work.

I don't know, I preferred the R32 I had.

RallyeS1

63 posts

162 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
How about it harming the handling, making them less involving, worsening fuel consumption, requiring bigger brakes, wheels and tyres, and being harder on them, which in turn makes them more expensive to run and giving worse ride quality, and finally after all that, not really being any faster as a result (note that the 0-100 time of the CTR is barely any worse than many of the fat hatches you talk about) .

There's more to driving enjoyment than BHP figures.
Good call!!

Allways fancied an ep3, never driven one though so I wouldnt like to comment. But as a passenger they feel great, great sound, plenty fast enough and the build quality is spot on!

chevronb37

6,471 posts

188 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
bdgriffiths said:
chevronb37 said:
I ended up with two of them. First one I sold at 90k miles and it was only just starting to show its age. The clutch was on its way out but otherwise spot on - seats still supportive and pulled well. I had a Premier Edition after that and it was better again. Neither used a drop of oil or suffered any kind of mechanical malady. Took the second one as far as Spa and even a 10 hour day behind the wheel was fine. I wouldn't hesitate to have another if the situation arose.
Im looking at a premier one just love the recaros and seriously want A/C
They're good cars. I really don't think they're as hardcore or as highly strung as everyone makes them out to be.

shibby!

921 posts

200 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
Grovsie26 said:
How can you slate the hell out of the CTR and then reccommend a DC5, or a 330Ci?

Hmmmmmmmm,
Because i thought it was st smile

The 330ci is a good car...... i just like the look of the DC5 and heard it was supposed to be hardcore, and thought it was supposed to be much better (i did say i didnt have experience with the DC5 but did with both the TYpe R and 330)

But on the other hand i also suggested some other things like Evo 6 and E36 M3 which are also good cars! smilesmile

Anyway good luck............. these cars seem to have a love them or hate them thing going with them.