Bulletproof Motor

Author
Discussion

lescombes

968 posts

212 months

Monday 20th February 2012
quotequote all
Proton.... or Jap motors... Proton hardly fail the MOT or breakdown....surprising but true..ask your local garage...

BillericayDickie

34 posts

197 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
For my money it would be an e39 BMW 530i.. comfy, reliable, superbly engineered, fun to drive and relatively frugal for a 3 litre petrol (upwards of 30mpg, even with a heavy right foot).

sadly mine is gone now, thanks to a LR Disco not stopping when it should have... cry

toon10

6,246 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Pints said:
Honda Accords have a decent reliability reputation, although not quite in the barge league.
Was just going to suggest this. I had a 2.4 Exec Accord and in 4 years absolutely nothing went wrong with it. Most reliable car I've owned and it's civilised at the crusing thing but has a nice character once wrung out if you fancy a blast.

Agreed, it's not a barge but comfortable enough.

XJSsometimeSoon

378 posts

161 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
First gen Toyota Avensis.
My dad had one as a company car in about 1998 for 3 years. In that time he had clocked up 150,000 miles with the only maintainance bening carried out on tyres and brakes ( He is terrible and looking after cars) In all that time not a single thing went wrong and it did not miss a beat. Is is bland and very boring, uninspiring to drive, but also quiet and quite comfortable. The vast majority of mini cabs around here are Avensis' and have been in many with 350,000+ miles on the clock. Probably the cheapest way to super reliable motoring.

Johnboy Mac

2,666 posts

180 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
MrGB said:
maximum of £1750
bulletproof
need space
reasonable maintenance costs
petrol
Merc 190E
Good suggestions on the Honda Accord, I'd opt for a 1.8 or 2.0lt. Since you mentioned a Merc, the 190 is a bloody good car but have a look at a W124 E220 Auto.

flatline84

1,060 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Leftfield choice, pretty much unbreakable, 20mpg in 4.0 litre engine form if you're careful, and fun to be had at weekends in the mud to boot.

Should be able to get a YJ model like this within your budget:


eltax91

9,922 posts

208 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Octavia, with the older TDi 110, or the newer PD 130. They have both been indestructible for me. smile

Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

233 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
flatline84 said:
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Leftfield choice, pretty much unbreakable, 20mpg in 4.0 litre engine form if you're careful, and fun to be had at weekends in the mud to boot.

Should be able to get a YJ model like this within your budget:

Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink

J4CKO

41,804 posts

202 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
MGJohn said:
Going against the grain of the average PHer mindset but I've been driving these for best part of ten years now and they do not come more 'bullet proof' than the Rover 620ti. Yes, the one with the Rover turbocharged engine not the Honda engined ones:~



There are still a good number of well cared for examples about which can be obtained with both MoT and Tax for rather less than £1000 if you're patient. My own cars have a mere 80,000 and drive like new whilst my son's daily workhorse he uses for work travel for many years is approaching 190,000 miles now.

Will cruise @ well over 100mph with five on board and their luggauge if you wish with a decent 0-60 time should you ever need it. Driven at legal and smooth motorway speeds, mid 30s mpg is perfectly possible.

Spares should you ever need them are both plentiful and inexpensive.
..
Not doubting you John but I cant remember the last time I saw a Rover 600 of any description, or an 800 for that matter.

flatline84

1,060 posts

159 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Jimbeaux said:
Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink
Im not doubting that its very sturdy, however I did have a cherokee in 4.0 guise. It did about 5 MPG, I could actually see the needle moving every time I stepped on it hehe

jbi

12,682 posts

206 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
MGJohn said:
Going against the grain of the average PHer mindset but I've been driving these for best part of ten years now and they do not come more 'bullet proof' than the Rover 620ti. Yes, the one with the Rover turbocharged engine not the Honda engined ones:~



There are still a good number of well cared for examples about which can be obtained with both MoT and Tax for rather less than £1000 if you're patient. My own cars have a mere 80,000 and drive like new whilst my son's daily workhorse he uses for work travel for many years is approaching 190,000 miles now.

Will cruise @ well over 100mph with five on board and their luggauge if you wish with a decent 0-60 time should you ever need it. Driven at legal and smooth motorway speeds, mid 30s mpg is perfectly possible.

Spares should you ever need them are both plentiful and inexpensive.
..
Not doubting you John but I cant remember the last time I saw a Rover 600 of any description, or an 800 for that matter.
there are plenty of rover 600's about.. but they are wearing honda badges and have honda running gear.



Don't ask about the rover ones wink

NateWM

1,684 posts

181 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
jbi said:
there are plenty of rover 600's about.. but they are wearing honda badges and have honda running gear.



Don't ask about the rover ones wink
Would much rather have the Accord. Honda was a lot more fussy over the quality of parts that went into the Accord. Rover?...Not so much!

Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

233 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
flatline84 said:
Jimbeaux said:
Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink
Im not doubting that its very sturdy, however I did have a cherokee in 4.0 guise. It did about 5 MPG, I could actually see the needle moving every time I stepped on it hehe
I had a '97 4.0 Chrokee 5 speed. It was sturdy. It was designed as a truck however, transmission and all; therefore, MPG was not its forte'. The new Jeep Grand Cherokees are on a whole other level now. smile

Wild Rumpus

375 posts

176 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
I had a Merc E320 (W124) estate with full history 13K miles etc and it cost me over £3500 in repairs in one year, I had a Volvo 940 LPT estate for 2 years before that (similar mileage) and the repairs were under £200. I'd go for an old Volvo myself.....
(the Merc is much, much nicer to drive, though and it feels like it could go on forever - it just doesn't)

V88Dicky

7,310 posts

185 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
XJSsometimeSoon said:
First gen Toyota Avensis.
My dad had one as a company car in about 1998 for 3 years. In that time he had clocked up 150,000 miles with the only maintainance bening carried out on tyres and brakes ( He is terrible and looking after cars) In all that time not a single thing went wrong and it did not miss a beat. Is is bland and very boring, uninspiring to drive, but also quiet and quite comfortable. The vast majority of mini cabs around here are Avensis' and have been in many with 350,000+ miles on the clock. Probably the cheapest way to super reliable motoring.
^^^^WHS^^^^



I run a 2.0 vvt-i one of these as my daily driver, and for my needs, it's excellent. Very easy to work on, cheap parts, extremely well built (in Britain), very reliable and does 45mpg week in, week out.

mph1977

12,467 posts

170 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
Yeah some cool stuff that comes out of those MOD disposals, my mate has a snatch landrover (not a daily driver).

I have a Ferret mk ii althought not bought direct from MoD was purchased from them by original owner.

lol

my immediate thought on seeing the topic name was to direct direct the OP to Witham's or similar

http://www.mod-sales.com/direct/vehicles/,37,/Armo...

although the XJ8s they've got at the moment are a bit out of his budget - but B6 protected so more than 'bullet proof'

http://www.mod-sales.com/direct/vehicle/,37,/38675...

but the snatch LRs seem to fit the budget and bulletproof requirement

http://www.mod-sales.com/direct/vehicle/,37,/37043...

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,910 posts

218 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Jimbeaux said:
flatline84 said:
Jimbeaux said:
Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink
Im not doubting that its very sturdy, however I did have a cherokee in 4.0 guise. It did about 5 MPG, I could actually see the needle moving every time I stepped on it hehe
I had a '97 4.0 Chrokee 5 speed. It was sturdy. It was designed as a truck however, transmission and all; therefore, MPG was not its forte'. The new Jeep Grand Cherokees are on a whole other level now. smile
Heheheh, well my Jeep Wrangler suggestion was very much in the vein of the thread title - 'Bulletproof Motor', I don't remember the OP addending that with 'oh yeah, and must be really good on fuel too...'

They are bulletproof.

To the extent that I waded mine a little too enthusiastically one day (before I had a snorkel) and sucked in litres of muddy lake puddle stuff.

It hydraulic locked solid. We took the plugs out, span it up until all the water was ejected from the plug holes, and once the plugs were back in, she fired up.

Drove it home.

Drove it for another 6 months before selling it on.




Although I will concede that after another 6 months, it did go bang for it's new owner - con rod snapped and exited out the side of the block biggrin

But that's not bad - a years drving on a bent con rod caused by hydraulic locking.

Now THAT'S bulletproof. Eh Jimbeaux? biggrin


Jimbeaux

33,791 posts

233 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Jimbeaux said:
flatline84 said:
Jimbeaux said:
Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink
Im not doubting that its very sturdy, however I did have a cherokee in 4.0 guise. It did about 5 MPG, I could actually see the needle moving every time I stepped on it hehe
I had a '97 4.0 Chrokee 5 speed. It was sturdy. It was designed as a truck however, transmission and all; therefore, MPG was not its forte'. The new Jeep Grand Cherokees are on a whole other level now. smile
Heheheh, well my Jeep Wrangler suggestion was very much in the vein of the thread title - 'Bulletproof Motor', I don't remember the OP addending that with 'oh yeah, and must be really good on fuel too...'

They are bulletproof.

To the extent that I waded mine a little too enthusiastically one day (before I had a snorkel) and sucked in litres of muddy lake puddle stuff.

It hydraulic locked solid. We took the plugs out, span it up until all the water was ejected from the plug holes, and once the plugs were back in, she fired up.

Drove it home.

Drove it for another 6 months before selling it on.




Although I will concede that after another 6 months, it did go bang for it's new owner - con rod snapped and exited out the side of the block biggrin

But that's not bad - a years drving on a bent con rod caused by hydraulic locking.

Now THAT'S bulletproof. Eh Jimbeaux? biggrin
I agree, I loved my Jeep. Those who insist on throwing in "MPG" or HP per Litre" when discussing trucks irk me no end. As to your story, I suppose the fellow who bought your Jeep is on a forum somewhere calling them st! hehe

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,910 posts

218 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Jimbeaux said:
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
Jimbeaux said:
flatline84 said:
Jimbeaux said:
Your laughing simply places you in the category of not understanding what that vehicle is for. It is we who are laughing, just not with you. wink
Im not doubting that its very sturdy, however I did have a cherokee in 4.0 guise. It did about 5 MPG, I could actually see the needle moving every time I stepped on it hehe
I had a '97 4.0 Chrokee 5 speed. It was sturdy. It was designed as a truck however, transmission and all; therefore, MPG was not its forte'. The new Jeep Grand Cherokees are on a whole other level now. smile
Heheheh, well my Jeep Wrangler suggestion was very much in the vein of the thread title - 'Bulletproof Motor', I don't remember the OP addending that with 'oh yeah, and must be really good on fuel too...'

They are bulletproof.

To the extent that I waded mine a little too enthusiastically one day (before I had a snorkel) and sucked in litres of muddy lake puddle stuff.

It hydraulic locked solid. We took the plugs out, span it up until all the water was ejected from the plug holes, and once the plugs were back in, she fired up.

Drove it home.

Drove it for another 6 months before selling it on.




Although I will concede that after another 6 months, it did go bang for it's new owner - con rod snapped and exited out the side of the block biggrin

But that's not bad - a years drving on a bent con rod caused by hydraulic locking.

Now THAT'S bulletproof. Eh Jimbeaux? biggrin
I agree, I loved my Jeep. Those who insist on throwing in "MPG" or HP per Litre" when discussing trucks irk me no end. As to your story, I suppose the fellow who bought your Jeep is on a forum somewhere calling them st! hehe
Heheheh, well funnily enough, the new owner is a mate. He told me when it went bang, and I did apologise, but I couldn't have really known, as it ran fine like I say for another year after the incident.

As he's a car dealer and a good mechanic, he bought a decent 2nd hand motor for a few hundred quid and dropped it in. I did feel guilty though...

...to the extent that I bought the Jeep back from him four years after selling it to him. Gave him the price he asked for, a good price, so in the end we're all happy, and my guilt has been buried forever!

Anyway, what's the weather like out where you are mate? Been out in the mud lately? driving


jbi

12,682 posts

206 months

Thursday 29th March 2012
quotequote all
Jeep 4.0 straight 6... what a motor smile