RE: New Porsche 911 GT3 - Geneva 2017

RE: New Porsche 911 GT3 - Geneva 2017

Author
Discussion

cuda

464 posts

242 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
But the big question. PDK or manual?

Well, the GT3 Configurator doesn't give you a manual option...

nicholasm

145 posts

187 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Debaser said:
I enquired at my local Porsche dealer about one of these just over a year ago. Was (politely) told 'no chance'.
Did the same last Easter and was also told that. I still wrote a letter of intent to buy afterwards - God loves a trier!

Dave Hedgehog

14,587 posts

206 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
cuda said:
But the big question. PDK or manual?

Well, the GT3 Configurator doesn't give you a manual option...
like they have not all already been sold to "friends and family members" to be flipped for double money lol


Mr Noble

6,535 posts

235 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I suppose that if each dealer only gets 15 of them, then there's never going to be any chance for the likes of you and me to buy one.

I called up my local OPC again this morning to ask, and was again told to politely do one or order a GTS or Turbo. (And I've had 3 cars from them over the years.)

15 per dealer is nothing.

Obviously the principle's wife will get one, and his 4 best mates, and his rich uncle Arthur, and then there will be the 6 famous local celebs and footballers who are on the 'GT VIP Club' list cause they provide the DP and his wife with invites to lots of VIP gigs throuout the year. That leaves just 3 cars for people he really had to persuade to buy a panamera, boxster and Macan in one go earlier in the year.

I, you and we are never going to get one at list. cry

Diesel Meister

2,044 posts

203 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Mr Noble said:
I suppose that if each dealer only gets 15 of them, then there's never going to be any chance for the likes of you and me to buy one.

I called up my local OPC again this morning to ask, and was again told to politely do one or order a GTS or Turbo. (And I've had 3 cars from them over the years.)

15 per dealer is nothing.

Obviously the principle's wife will get one, and his 4 best mates, and his rich uncle Arthur, and then there will be the 6 famous local celebs and footballers who are on the 'GT VIP Club' list cause they provide the DP and his wife with invites to lots of VIP gigs throuout the year. That leaves just 3 cars for people he really had to persuade to buy a panamera, boxster and Macan in one go earlier in the year.

I, you and we are never going to get one at list. cry
I have no illusions of being in any way able or eligible to buy this sort of car, ever, but this is just depressing on principle. DPs shouldn't be allowed to do this imo and those that do, however lucrative it may be, should be flogged with Bosch wiper arms (other brands available). I accept it's a business but it just seems wrong to hand more advantage to folks who will likely already have too much.

If they get 15 cars each, surely they should only be permitted to tie up 1-2 of them (demo plus personal car or whatever) and the rest should be allocated first come, first served or based on a blind lotto-type draw of the first X number of enquirers. Anything else is just "Pork for your mates" (those "mates" seemingly being those individuals willing and able to give said DP a tongued-up one-hander whilst said DP motorboat's their mother's assets during the purchase of numerous, heavily-optioned vehicles from said DP at list price. Or something.).

Spivs and speculators rule the world. I'd like to get off please (yes, that way too hehe ).


Edited by Diesel Meister on Tuesday 7th March 15:07

Digga

40,458 posts

285 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
It does sort of strike me as such a one-sided deal that the dealer will be trying to lift your leg at every opportunity; one can only imagine the creative extras that get wound into desperately keen buyers.

BRR

1,852 posts

174 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
If I could afford one and could convince a dealer to sell me one this would definitely be what I'd by at this price point, in fact I think i'd need to be up around £200k to find something I'd want more

Dave Hedgehog

14,587 posts

206 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Mr Noble said:
I suppose that if each dealer only gets 15 of them, then there's never going to be any chance for the likes of you and me to buy one.

I called up my local OPC again this morning to ask, and was again told to politely do one or order a GTS or Turbo. (And I've had 3 cars from them over the years.)

15 per dealer is nothing.

Obviously the principle's wife will get one, and his 4 best mates, and his rich uncle Arthur, and then there will be the 6 famous local celebs and footballers who are on the 'GT VIP Club' list cause they provide the DP and his wife with invites to lots of VIP gigs throuout the year. That leaves just 3 cars for people he really had to persuade to buy a panamera, boxster and Macan in one go earlier in the year.

I, you and we are never going to get one at list. cry
don't worry porsche are not a hedgefund rotate

http://www.pistonheads.com/news/ph-porsche/preunin...

lucky i am a pleb so couldn't afford one even if they did sell them to customers lol

Yipper

5,964 posts

92 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Looks exactly the same as the last model...

macky17

2,217 posts

191 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Yipper said:
Looks exactly the same as the last model...
Page 4! Is that a record?

And yes, it does.

ZX10R NIN

27,747 posts

127 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
The manual option would be the one I would go for.

sonnenschein3000

710 posts

92 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
PDK PDK PDK PDK PDK PDK........

PhantomPH

4,043 posts

227 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
I'd take a PDK...not the I will get the option, of course!

mattyc69

331 posts

154 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Don't see why any of the press should even bother reporting on it.

Know one will be able to buy one unless you are sucking off your OPC dealer principle.

Same saga all over again, hopefully one day this will bite Porsche.

Hedski

11 posts

184 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Porsche go and make every top model in limited numbers therefore each one will rise in price and they know it.
Same as other countries Porsche dealers in U.K. are charging more than RRP for even second hand cars profiteering where they can.
If Porsche wanted to stay true to driving enthusiasts then they need to build cars to satisfy demand, not restrict numbers on a model such as this new GT3.
If Porsche were serious about any of this then why can't I as a Porsche enthusiast order a GT3, GT4, RS or R model of anything?
Demand is just driven higher by profiteering types jumping in who are brown nosing the dealers and grabbing the cars before the real buyer can and then hiking the price. Pointless unscrupulous dodgy middle men and culpable Porsche dealer network exacerbating the problem. My only hope now is this new model will actually cause a levelling or even drop in 997.1 GT3 prices.

JJMatrixx

755 posts

161 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
Owned a 991 GT3 and 991 GT3RS. The GT3 was 90% of the car. Also just don't get why you would go for manual in this - the engine deserves a PDK to get the best of it. Being 'more involved' with a manual in this car is bs - banging through the PDK box to 9k is some thrill!

Diesel Meister

2,044 posts

203 months

Tuesday 7th March 2017
quotequote all
JJMatrixx said:
Owned a 991 GT3 and 991 GT3RS. The GT3 was 90% of the car. Also just don't get why you would go for manual in this - the engine deserves a PDK to get the best of it. Being 'more involved' with a manual in this car is bs - banging through the PDK box to 9k is some thrill!
I can't speak from experience of a 991 GT3 / RS but I'd say that the involvement part of the PDK / tri-pedal debate need not be treated as part of some competition to prove manhood / PH status / anything else. I mean objectively you could argue both are involving you in the process of changing gear, giving you a measure of control and tactile input. It's just that some enjoy and value the nature of that involvement differently.

Difference is not BS - to call it such borders on fascism in fact. I mean no offence, but I believe it to be true.

Let's not all fall victim to the cheap shots when PH does a fairly cheeky bit of click baiting hehe

The real story should be how limited supply in fact is, unless you're willing and able to whack a double digit premium on top of the RRP for so-called "overs" market (and only should you be lucky enough to be granted leave to spread your [-]cheeks/-] chequebook to enter that particular sado-masochistic party hehe ).

BlackPrince

1,271 posts

171 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
JJMatrixx said:
Owned a 991 GT3 and 991 GT3RS. The GT3 was 90% of the car. Also just don't get why you would go for manual in this - the engine deserves a PDK to get the best of it. Being 'more involved' with a manual in this car is bs - banging through the PDK box to 9k is some thrill!
The idea that one isn't more involved in a manual is just silly. The clutch pedal definitionally adds another level of involvement. That's not to say the PDK can't be fun in its own way, though Chris Harris said that most of the time he left the gen 1 GT3 gearbox in auto as it was better at choosing gears than him.

I haven't driven a GT3 or an RS, but I found the 991 Carrera 4S with PDK I drove to be a bit anodyne, whereas the 981 Boxster PDK to be sublime and perhaps the transmission of choice, though I didn't drive a manual Boxster for comparison.

epom

11,654 posts

163 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
Would GT3 RS be undriveable without that rear wing ?? Say on the road where speeds wouldn't be as high or the surface so smooth ?

STiG911

1,210 posts

169 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
Shazbat said:
Now watch the pdk gen 1 GT3's with the chocolate engines plummet like lead weights...
You mean all those ones with replacement engines still selling for strong money?
Cock.