RE: Gavan Kershaw on Lotus Emira | PH Meets

RE: Gavan Kershaw on Lotus Emira | PH Meets

Author
Discussion

Pistaaah

119 posts

173 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Ordered one!

Lotus checking times on card deposits to verify the waiting list positions - heady times indeed…

Caddyshack

11,053 posts

208 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Pistaaah said:
Ordered one!

Lotus checking times on card deposits to verify the waiting list positions - heady times indeed…
Good on ya…well done for taking the lead (or hopefully close to)

Shnozz

27,646 posts

273 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Pistaaah said:
Ordered one!

Lotus checking times on card deposits to verify the waiting list positions - heady times indeed…
Jesus.

I am a bit edgy as I put my deposit with JCT which they happily accepted and told me where I am on their list. However, I read on PH that other dealers (B&C notably) have been directing clients straight to Lotus to lay deposits. Not sure how this is all going to work out...

Pistaaah

119 posts

173 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Shnozz said:
Jesus.

I am a bit edgy as I put my deposit with JCT which they happily accepted and told me where I am on their list. However, I read on PH that other dealers (B&C notably) have been directing clients straight to Lotus to lay deposits. Not sure how this is all going to work out...
Apparently, all cars are sold by Lotus with commissions to dealers, to avoid discounting and queue jumping

Shnozz

27,646 posts

273 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Pistaaah said:
Shnozz said:
Jesus.

I am a bit edgy as I put my deposit with JCT which they happily accepted and told me where I am on their list. However, I read on PH that other dealers (B&C notably) have been directing clients straight to Lotus to lay deposits. Not sure how this is all going to work out...
Apparently, all cars are sold by Lotus with commissions to dealers, to avoid discounting and queue jumping
Fook knows then what that means as to where my order is in the scheme of things.

jl4069

195 posts

104 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Equus said:
xcentric said:
Does anyone have any insights into whether/when they may do a convertible version? I assume that with the bonded chassis that the roof is only marginally contributing to the structural stiffness, so from an engineering perspective it's easy.
Assuming the Emira isn't a million miles away from the Evora chassis in terms of basic structural concept...

With the Evora, the roof virtually doubled the stiffness.

Not that 14kNm/degree is to be sniffed at: it's stiffer than the Elise - circa 10kNm/degree - and over twice as stiff as a Mk.1 Mazda MX5, for example (though the latter probably isn't saying much, since the MX5 shudders like a stting spaniel at the slightest sniff of a bumpy road), but chopping the roof of has more than just a marginal effect, it seems.



Edited by Equus on Thursday 8th July 18:48
To be honest, while a 26,000 nm/def rigidity was decent for 2008- about the same as a Golf V of that time...13 years later its rather poor. And its not like Lotus are telling us they have made this more rigid. Even cheap cars like Honda Civics and Subaru Imprezas acheive rigidity numbers in the 40k range as of late. These higher numbers allow for much better crash protection, better handling and lighter overall weight. I note the Honda Civic r with a similar engine to this Emira is less than 1300 kilos, and that is with four doors. j

Gadzookoids

91 posts

134 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
jl4069 said:
To be honest, while a 26,000 nm/def rigidity was decent for 2008- about the same as a Golf V of that time...13 years later its rather poor. And its not like Lotus are telling us they have made this more rigid. Even cheap cars like Honda Civics and Subaru Imprezas acheive rigidity numbers in the 40k range as of late. These higher numbers allow for much better crash protection, better handling and lighter overall weight. I note the Honda Civic r with a similar engine to this Emira is less than 1300 kilos, and that is with four doors. j
I haven’t researched the figures but I can categorically say that an Evora 400 rides far better than any hot hatch. Not quite as good as a Macca with its carbon tub - but close.

Carl_Manchester

12,414 posts

264 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
the_hood said:
When I saw the main pic I thought it was a Ferrari.
It looks like an early Ferrari 458 design prototype that was drawn by the same team just after the Ferrari 360 was drawn.

No bad thing !

otolith

56,861 posts

206 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Very high degrees of torsional stiffness are more about NVH than handling.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

236 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
jl4069 said:
Equus said:
xcentric said:
Does anyone have any insights into whether/when they may do a convertible version? I assume that with the bonded chassis that the roof is only marginally contributing to the structural stiffness, so from an engineering perspective it's easy.
Assuming the Emira isn't a million miles away from the Evora chassis in terms of basic structural concept...

With the Evora, the roof virtually doubled the stiffness.

Not that 14kNm/degree is to be sniffed at: it's stiffer than the Elise - circa 10kNm/degree - and over twice as stiff as a Mk.1 Mazda MX5, for example (though the latter probably isn't saying much, since the MX5 shudders like a stting spaniel at the slightest sniff of a bumpy road), but chopping the roof of has more than just a marginal effect, it seems.



Edited by Equus on Thursday 8th July 18:48
To be honest, while a 26,000 nm/def rigidity was decent for 2008- about the same as a Golf V of that time...13 years later its rather poor. And its not like Lotus are telling us they have made this more rigid. Even cheap cars like Honda Civics and Subaru Imprezas acheive rigidity numbers in the 40k range as of late. These higher numbers allow for much better crash protection, better handling and lighter overall weight. I note the Honda Civic r with a similar engine to this Emira is less than 1300 kilos, and that is with four doors. j
The latest Honda Civic and last Impreza are truly stunning handling cars. I hope the boys at Lotus look hard and learn from them.

GTRene

16,965 posts

226 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Ursicles said:
Really has a small F430 vibe going about it

Im very tempted with this one.
yep,


otolith

56,861 posts

206 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
1300kg Civic Type-R my arse


GTRene

16,965 posts

226 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
thats a big difference.

Also my Z3 2.8 facelift roadster, weight was 1265kg on paper, did engine swap and many lighter parts in the car, would have saved 60-80kg
But forgot to weight the car before I brought it to the builder, so weighted it afterwards with the lower weight parts and what came out.

I thought, well under 1250kg surely... but with almost empty tank and some smal things out, weighted still 1285 kg
so original it was booked on paper at 1265kg but must have been a over 1300kg in the real world.

MDMetal

2,787 posts

150 months

Thursday 8th July 2021
quotequote all
Pistaaah said:
Ordered one!

Lotus checking times on card deposits to verify the waiting list positions - heady times indeed…
I'm tempted, never bought a new car before but this looks like the one. Wonder what the wait times are. Also never driven a lotus, either hmmmmm

as7920

732 posts

203 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
According to Autocar (most recently) and loads of other sources from 2018, Mercedes/AMG have a 2 seater Cayman rival in the works.

I suspect they could well be using the Emira for R&D.

Put my deposit down on launch night. AMG DCT for me. In the blue with yellow details or dark grey with red details.

Speed1283

1,172 posts

97 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
Saw one up close at Goodwood yesterday, it looked lovely, couldn't really see an angle that I didn't like to be honest.




kambites

67,746 posts

223 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
Equus said:
Not that 14kNm/degree is to be sniffed at: it's stiffer than the Elise - circa 10kNm/degree - and over twice as stiff as a Mk.1 Mazda MX5, for example (though the latter probably isn't saying much, since the MX5 shudders like a stting spaniel at the slightest sniff of a bumpy road), but chopping the roof of has more than just a marginal effect, it seems.
Well yes, but it's not absolute stiffness which matters because the torsional forces being applied to the chassis are, all other things being equal, proportional to the weight of the vehicle. Hence it's actually stiffness to weight ratio which matters, not absolute stiffness.

Thom

1,716 posts

249 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
This looks like a cheap version of the McLaren Arsetura. What's wrong with car designers these days?

Fulla

450 posts

217 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
Speed1283 said:
Saw one up close at Goodwood yesterday, it looked lovely, couldn't really see an angle that I didn't like to be honest.



Was also lucky enough to see it yesterday as well.
I liked the proportions of the car, interior looked unfussy, nice space behind seats for soft bags unless they where pulled all the way forward?
Had a look at the MC12 which looked good as well and would say the Lotus interior was a lot less fussy but the MC12 seemed to have more buttons which I prefer over screens.
Paint looked good as it had a nice metallic look to it. The yellow on the unobtainable EV also looked great, the £2m of that made the Emira seem a bargain, although I was thinking it will push close to £80k with options or more maybe.



Shnozz

27,646 posts

273 months

Friday 9th July 2021
quotequote all
Fulla said:
Was also lucky enough to see it yesterday as well.
I liked the proportions of the car, interior looked unfussy, nice space behind seats for soft bags unless they where pulled all the way forward?
Had a look at the MC12 which looked good as well and would say the Lotus interior was a lot less fussy but the MC12 seemed to have more buttons which I prefer over screens.
Paint looked good as it had a nice metallic look to it. The yellow on the unobtainable EV also looked great, the £2m of that made the Emira seem a bargain, although I was thinking it will push close to £80k with options or more maybe.
Interested to read what you say re space behind the seats as still yet to see a photo of this. When you say unless they were pulled all the way forward, do you mean if the seat was all the way back? I am 6'3" so need seat pretty much at the back in most cars (although didn't go to the end of the runners on my Evora interestingly). I'd like to be able to put a couple of cabin cases on the shelf behind the seats if I am going to be able to rag this around Europe.