Modifying to be illegal?

Modifying to be illegal?

Author
Discussion

Kawasicki

13,118 posts

236 months

Sunday 26th December 2021
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
Could.
A great word that. It 'could' have absolutely no affect whatsoever.
Likewise, a blob of mud could block it or break it.

Edited by Oilchange on Sunday 26th December 15:16
It could have no effect
It could be worse
It could be improved

Sounds a bit random/out of government control, that does.

If a driver assist system fails to function and then the system throws up a warning that the driver ignores…

DonkeyApple

55,843 posts

170 months

Sunday 26th December 2021
quotequote all
Surely the fundamental issue is that these systems are needed because the driver is not of sufficient ability to safely manage such a complex bit of kit and environments yet when the computer reaches the limits of its ability its solution is to hand over to the driver a situation which it categorically knows said driver can't handle because it's already decided the driver can't even cope with driving down the road. biggrin

Which is the idiot? The pilot or the computer that deems the pilot to be incompetent but then hands off to them at the worst possible time when apparently the computer has decided they're now Sterling Moss. wink

M4cruiser

3,720 posts

151 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
vaud said:
M4cruiser said:
... and it will never crash, just like an Airbus.
confused
No-one has said they won't crash but there is a good indications that there will be fewer incidents per 1m miles for fully autonomous, with the rate improving as the % of cars that are autonomous increases.

Car to car data, multiple cameras, ML, sensors, knowledge of speed limits etc.

It's not tomorrow but the direction is firmly set for incremental autonomy of the car.
I'm willing to believe the autonomous car may be safer than the average driver. But that's because the poor drivers are bringing down the average.
Advanced drivers are nine(*) times safer than the average driver.
(*) Ok, not sure of the current figure, but when the System was first implemented and monitored it reduced incidents by a factor of 9.


bigothunter

11,443 posts

61 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
M4cruiser said:
I'm willing to believe the autonomous car may be safer than the average driver. But that's because the poor drivers are bringing down the average.
Advanced drivers are nine(*) times safer than the average driver.
(*) Ok, not sure of the current figure, but when the System was first implemented and monitored it reduced incidents by a factor of 9.
So the less capable driver is less likely to die. Isn't Reverse Darwinism pivotal to a fair society? scratchchin

NMNeil

5,860 posts

51 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Excessive noise is already an offence isn’t it?

I’m sure context is everything but an obviously modified and too loud vehicle can be dealt with.

Half the issue here is enforcing existing laws/regs.

I recall my Dad’s generation cutting down springs, cutting up exhausts etc… all looked OE, but wasn’t.
In those days it was done to be cheap.

To enforce these new rules would be so costly, and on a used vehicle you’d argue it came like that.


The simple fix.

MOT check diesels exhaust better. Smoke density only was a joke.

Spot checks on exhausts to make sure they meet MOT. So many de-cat/mod exhausts swapped for MOT.

Those two alone would catch 90% of the people causing 90% of the issues with emissions or anti-social noise levels.
Already in the works.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8818895/C...
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/governmen...

NMNeil

5,860 posts

51 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
vaud said:
M4cruiser said:
... and it will never crash, just like an Airbus.
confused
No-one has said they won't crash but there is a good indications that there will be fewer incidents per 1m miles for fully autonomous, with the rate improving as the % of cars that are autonomous increases.

Car to car data, multiple cameras, ML, sensors, knowledge of speed limits etc.

It's not tomorrow but the direction is firmly set for incremental autonomy of the car.
The only way it will work will be total segregation of autonomous vs. non autonomous cars.


NMNeil

5,860 posts

51 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
Surely the fundamental issue is that these systems are needed because the driver is not of sufficient ability to safely manage such a complex bit of kit.
Many on PH openly admit that they just cannot grasp the concept that if the posted speed limit says 70mph then the big speedometer in front of them should not read anything above 70mph.
It's just way too complicated for them, so a machine will easily be able to do far better..

bigothunter

11,443 posts

61 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
Many on PH openly admit that they just cannot grasp the concept that if the posted speed limit says 70mph then the big speedometer in front of them should not read anything above 70mph.
This should fix the problem wink


DodgyGeezer

40,697 posts

191 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
bigothunter said:
NMNeil said:
Many on PH openly admit that they just cannot grasp the concept that if the posted speed limit says 70mph then the big speedometer in front of them should not read anything above 70mph.
This should fix the problem wink

Back to the 80's...




Oilchange

8,518 posts

261 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
Nice but I prefer this one


bigothunter

11,443 posts

61 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
Nice but I prefer this one

Why have a speedo where less than one-third of the scale can be used? Your needle should stop at 70 nono

Oilchange

8,518 posts

261 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
Absolute bks.
One always needs to know how fast one is going when in areas otherwise governed by the UK speed limit.
Some might say that's the Supermarket car park, not me. The Autobahn, race tracks, private roads etc. It's not all public highway you know.

And I bet yours doesn't!

Music101

8 posts

32 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
The Autobahn might be getting speed limits.

vaud

50,788 posts

156 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
The only way it will work will be total segregation of autonomous vs. non autonomous cars.
I suspect it will be "managed" through insurance premiums. Fewer autonomous features - higher premiums.

NMNeil

5,860 posts

51 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
vaud said:
NMNeil said:
The only way it will work will be total segregation of autonomous vs. non autonomous cars.
I suspect it will be "managed" through insurance premiums. Fewer autonomous features - higher premiums.
I was more thinking of the same logic as bicycle lanes.
Paint cycle lanes on a road and as far as many car drivers are concerned this translates to "You can park here, after all they're only cyclists"
Hence physical barriers to stop the cars.
Of course car drivers still ignore those because they seem to feel they are somehow special, and the roads were intended only for cars, nobody else.
https://road.cc/content/news/council-has-no-intent...

NMNeil

5,860 posts

51 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
bigothunter said:
Why have a speedo where less than one-third of the scale can be used? Your needle should stop at 70 nono
When they introduce the ISA speed limiter system, it probably will.

bigothunter

11,443 posts

61 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
Absolute bks.
One always needs to know how fast one is going when in areas otherwise governed by the UK speed limit.
Some might say that's the Supermarket car park, not me. The Autobahn, race tracks, private roads etc. It's not all public highway you know.

And I bet yours doesn't!
Just planning 2022 track day calendar which starts on March 15th at Oulton. Should run 11 events this year. We don't use a speedo on track cars, or it may not even be fitted at all. Fastest GPS speed recorded is 152mph at Snetterton, although 156 has been seen when racing at Thruxton.

But it's a strict 70mph maximum for me on the road, at least in the tow van which has a rigid 70 limiter. That's quite fast enough with the car trailer behind thanks thumbup





CarCrazyDad

4,280 posts

36 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
Isn't the limit of a big van or vehicle with a trailer 60mph on the motorway?

bigothunter

11,443 posts

61 months

Friday 31st December 2021
quotequote all
CarCrazyDad said:
Isn't the limit of a big van or vehicle with a trailer 60mph on the motorway?
whistle

Oilchange

8,518 posts

261 months

Saturday 1st January 2022
quotequote all
bigothunter said:
CarCrazyDad said:
Isn't the limit of a big van or vehicle with a trailer 60mph on the motorway?
whistle
Busted!