RE: Chris Harris video: GT86 vs 370Z vs Cayman

RE: Chris Harris video: GT86 vs 370Z vs Cayman

Author
Discussion

PAULBECKHAM11

19 posts

180 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
any suggestions for getting my OH in one, i miss being able to borrow her MR2 Roadster

i thought about leaving some brochures lying about, but that's a bit obvious lol
Just get her to drive one, she will love it, its that simple - oh and tell her she can have it in orange lol

Dave Hedgehog

14,599 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
PAULBECKHAM11 said:
Dave Hedgehog said:
any suggestions for getting my OH in one, i miss being able to borrow her MR2 Roadster

i thought about leaving some brochures lying about, but that's a bit obvious lol
Just get her to drive one, she will love it, its that simple - oh and tell her she can have it in orange lol
yeah, i picked orange on the configurator, looks fantastic

the more i think about it the more the GT86 seams to be a perfect car for the OH

do the back seats have isofix points?

Dave Hedgehog

14,599 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
The Game said:
omfg WANT!

juansolo

3,012 posts

280 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
The Game said:
omfg WANT!
Indeed, that looks so right. GET IT RALLIED! That would be bloody awesome to get some proper RWD action back on the rally stages.

PAULBECKHAM11

19 posts

180 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
yeah, i picked orange on the configurator, looks fantastic

the more i think about it the more the GT86 seams to be a perfect car for the OH

do the back seats have isofix points?
Yes the 2 rear seats have ISOFIX, it has a very decent size boot too - tell her its a sensible choice!

Alex

9,975 posts

286 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
It's just the rear facing seats are a PITA to use on a 2/3 door car, especially when junior becomes heavy.

Good luck though!

smile
Have you seen the rear seats in a GT86? I doubt there's a child seat available that will fit. Also, with a normal sized adult in the front, there is zero legroom in the back (and I mean zero!).

PAULBECKHAM11

19 posts

180 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Alex said:
Have you seen the rear seats in a GT86? I doubt there's a child seat available that will fit. Also, with a normal sized adult in the front, there is zero legroom in the back (and I mean zero!).
You can fit an adult of 5`10 behind someone whos 5`8 or round the other way of course, trust me I did it last night!!!

fido

16,882 posts

257 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Chris71 said:
I love the 370Z premise, but I was a bit underwhelmed by the reality. It feels quite agricultural in many respects (particularly the gearbox which is a real bicep builder); the engine has a reasonable amount of grunt but isn't especially exciting and the handling is a bit ponderous.
Pretty much my experience of the 370Z. I was in the market for one over a year ago - something fun to drive without the [potential] Porsche bills. It's much better put together than the 350Z and a much nicer car to sit in. But agree with the review - for pure driving pleasure it's missing a tenth (or hundredth) here and there and it all adds up to the overall experience. I actually prefer driving the 968 even though the V6 in the 370Z is obviously years ahead and has serious grunt at low revs. It's not a bad car in any way - just not a great one - but i'd still be happy to drive one.

deltashad

6,731 posts

199 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
I've been avoiding this thread as the GT86 didn't appeal to me on paper.

After reading a few reviews and watching the video I'm really warming up to the hype. I can see this car being an excellent used buy in a few years time.

As usual a fine video Mr. Harris with some lovely driving.
Personally as a private buyer I'd veer towards the used Caymen, but then I'd think, I could have wind in the hair fun in virtually the same car in the form of a Boxster, then I'd think I could have missile performance for the same money and a little more exclusivity in the form of an SLK55.

So, that's where my money would be going. SLK55. Totally different car though.

DoubleSix

11,743 posts

178 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
deltashad said:
I've been avoiding this thread as the GT86 didn't appeal to me on paper.

After reading a few reviews and watching the video I'm really warming up to the hype. I can see this car being an excellent used buy in a few years time.

As usual a fine video Mr. Harris with some lovely driving.
Personally as a private buyer I'd veer towards the used Caymen, but then I'd think, I could have wind in the hair fun in virtually the same car in the form of a Boxster, then I'd think I could have missile performance for the same money and a little more exclusivity in the form of an SLK55.

So, that's where my money would be going. SLK55. Totally different car though.
Sod it, if your going down that path I'd get an SL350, under 15 grand for good example.

Edited by DoubleSix on Saturday 18th August 12:57

dirtbiker

1,206 posts

168 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
PAULBECKHAM11 said:
Alex said:
Have you seen the rear seats in a GT86? I doubt there's a child seat available that will fit. Also, with a normal sized adult in the front, there is zero legroom in the back (and I mean zero!).
You can fit an adult of 5`10 behind someone whos 5`8 or round the other way of course, trust me I did it last night!!!
Went to have a sit in one today (test drive booked next weekend) and I did think that! I'm only 5'9 and there was certainly no room behind me for anyone to travel in comfort. I hardly ever have more than two people in the car anyway so not a massive concern but it's certainly not going to be as useable as a 3 door hatchback in that respect!

daveyc86

49 posts

167 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
I don't understand why the Z4M coupe didn't feature in this? It wipes the floor with all 3 of those cars.

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

205 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
daveyc86 said:
I don't understand why the Z4M coupe didn't feature in this? It wipes the floor with all 3 of those cars.
I asked that ages ago and got no response!

deltashad

6,731 posts

199 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
DoubleSix said:
deltashad said:
I've been avoiding this thread as the GT86 didn't appeal to me on paper.

After reading a few reviews and watching the video I'm really warming up to the hype. I can see this car being an excellent used buy in a few years time.

As usual a fine video Mr. Harris with some lovely driving.
Personally as a private buyer I'd veer towards the used Caymen, but then I'd think, I could have wind in the hair fun in virtually the same car in the form of a Boxster, then I'd think I could have missile performance for the same money and a little more exclusivity in the form of an SLK55.

So, that's where my money would be going. SLK55. Totally different car though.
Sod it, if your going down that path I'd get and SL350, under 15 grand for good example.
MX5 mk1 laugh

CJP80

1,097 posts

150 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
daveyc86 said:
I don't understand why the Z4M coupe didn't feature in this? It wipes the floor with all 3 of those cars.
The Z4M is not a better car than a Cayman S. Not by a long margin.

Dave Hedgehog

14,599 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
CJP80 said:
daveyc86 said:
I don't understand why the Z4M coupe didn't feature in this? It wipes the floor with all 3 of those cars.
The Z4M is not a better car than a Cayman S. Not by a long margin.
it is if your a banker

Sods Law

3,280 posts

227 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Interesting read following a good video review for me.

I was interested as I am looking for a RWD coupe for fun use in the next 6months.

Where this has left me, is back in the German second hand corner,
M3
Z4M cab
Caymen
Boxster

I have considered TVR, Atoms, etc but want regular tour ability, though a Chim/Cerb still might make the cut. hehe

The warranty on the Toyota as some have said can be offset by smart purchasing, adding a aftermarket or AUC warranty.

And the 350z doesnt appeal any way.

Re the video format, I do think we should remember this is an enthusiasts forum, so a review based on enthusiastically drving is the correct form. It's not which or handbag.com


Thanks Chris, I found it helpful and was considering a used Caymen v's an new 86....


(Btw thanks for the drive in the Clio V6 when I was at alpine all those years ago.)





Urban Sports

11,321 posts

205 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
CJP80 said:
The Z4M is not a better car than a Cayman S. Not by a long margin.
Says who?

CJP80

1,097 posts

150 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Urban Sports said:
Says who?
Me for a start. I really wanted to buy a Z4M when I was looking to change out of my Boxster S. I found the clutch pedal ridiculous and the steering wheel's as thick as a whales dick. It's fast and the engine is great, but it doesn't have the balance or poise of a Cayman. It also feels quite a bit heavier.

DoubleSix

11,743 posts

178 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
CJP80 said:
Urban Sports said:
Says who?
Me for a start. I really wanted to buy a Z4M when I was looking to change out of my Boxster S. I found the clutch pedal ridiculous and the steering wheel's as thick as a whales dick. It's fast and the engine is great, but it doesn't have the balance or poise of a Cayman. It also feels quite a bit heavier.
Agreed. Z4M is great, but felt a bit crude next to the Cayman.