RE: Drayson EV record car: Driven
RE: Drayson EV record car: Driven
Tuesday 29th October 2013

Drayson EV record car: Driven

Chris Harris scores a drive in Lord Drayson's electric powered record breaker



"And how much torque does it have?" This is the slightly glib foreplay that we go through before any shoot. I say glib because I'm often guilty of appearing uninterested during these exchanges - I've been told as much - when the truth is that I'm concentrating on the car and wondering how to keep Neil from imploding due to the perennial lack of shooting time.

Drayson is a Lola B10/60, up to the rear bulkhead
Drayson is a Lola B10/60, up to the rear bulkhead
And so I was walking around the stunning B12/69EV with Chief Engineer Graham Moore and asking the usual questions regarding basic specification that I could memorise for the in-car talking bit of the video. Removing the fuel tank and internal combustion engine and adding four electric motors with fuel cells rated at a potential 850hp has only added around 40kg. The power figure today is more like 800hp, which is enough to make me gawp slightly, especially given the calmness with which Moore delivers the message.

And then we come to the matter of torque. "Four thousand Newton metres", he replies with all the drama of a man asked the result of last week's Strictly. That's 2,950lb ft.

Drayson pulled apart a Lola to make it
Drayson pulled apart a Lola to make it
The wind is causing a right old kerfuffle around the awning, and I don't hear too well anyway. "Ha! I thought you said 4,000Nm for a minute."

"I did." says Moore, doing a reasonable impression of Ivan Drago from Rocky IV.

I become even more unimpressive than usual. What I want to do is ask how a conventional rear axle can handle such a twisting force but the words won't form correctly because my limited cerebral capacity is completely baffled by the information. So I just walk around the back of the car muttering stuff. "Just not possible; can't be possible; that can't be done."

Eventually something vaguely cogent forms. "Does it just shred the tyres?"

"On hot slicks it's pretty incredible," says Moore. I guess we'd better drive it and find out how incredible.

That's what 2,950lb ft will do!
That's what 2,950lb ft will do!
This car is one of the great automotive follies of the motoring era - and I mean that in the correct sense of the word. It's a non-commercial, scientific journey for a man who wanted to explore the unknown and was willing to underwrite the costs himself. That man is LordDrayson, or Paul Drayson when you shake his hand.

The car is based on a Lola B10/60. The carbon passenger cell is unmodified, but everything rear of the bulkhead has been redesigned to accommodate the battery cells. The four axial flux Oxford YASA motors sit roughly where the gearbox would have been and are British designed and built. According to both Moore and Drayson they're the best money can buy.

So why build an electric LMP1 car?

Drayson now has a new speed record of 205.1mph
Drayson now has a new speed record of 205.1mph
Drayson is clear on his reasons, and they slightly undermine my definition of his being non-commercial. He rightly speaks with an inevitability about the emergence of electric vehicles, and he is very much focused on next year's Formula E championship in which he will be running a car. But he reserves a special grin for the series in 2015. "Next year we all have to race the same car, the following year we can develop our own; this is a perfect way to develop the technology."

So in part this is motorsport going back its roots as a development exercise. Everything learnt here will somehow impact on the way we interact with electric cars in the future and with his business head in place, Drayson sees this being a natural continuation of UK dominance in motorsport. We have the skills to be the pre-eminent makers of electric racing cars in the future, just as we are the dominant force in petrol power at the moment.

And why an LMP1 car? "Well, we already had this one, so it seemed a good idea."

Faired-in rear wheels for speed record car
Faired-in rear wheels for speed record car
Pulling apart a beautiful Lola that you raced at Le Mans would have caused me some soul-searching but apparently not Paul. Does he miss driving the car with the petrol motor? "Not at all: once you've driven it, you'll see why", he smirks. Would he go back to Le Mans to race in a car with a 'normal' engine? "No."

My first contact with this new fusion of electricity and motor racing wasn't positive. I drove a Nissan Leaf thing at Goodwood: it was slow, dull-witted and utterly characterless. The first impression of the Drayson B12/69EV is one of rank contradiction. The car's visuals are absolutely immense: an LMP1 car is a vast thing, festooned with winglets and scoops, and for me the silent anger of the thing sitting at rest is a precursor for the moment it yelps into life.

But of course that never happens.

Computers fine, brain needs re-wiring though
Computers fine, brain needs re-wiring though
You bolt yourself in and look around the cabin for controls. Very little is familiar on the main dash, the steering wheel has settings for the traction control and is reasonably conventional, but the start procedure is quite spooky. The main switch has two positions, the first allows the car's systems to start, the second allows the thing to prime itself and move. Graham talks me through the procedure calmly - in fact I don't appreciate the serenity of the moment because there's no chuntering motor and slapping dog-box behind me, but he then says "push the high-voltage button please" - a great big red number surrounded by a protective collar just like the fire extinguisher manual release.

I hit it and a bank of lights appear above it, Graham is silent as the lap-top brains monitor what's going on and I have to say, I'm sitting there not feeling entirely comfortable. Large voltages are lurking somewhere near my testicles and their silence is malevolent.

"Engage reverse please."

A reasonable push on the throttle pedal sends the car creeping backwards. Then it's out onto Elvington runway to experience 4,000Nm of torque. I'm a little apprehensive. "Leave the traction control in position six for now, you're on wet tyres but you'll be surprised how much grip there is."

Right you are.

LMP1 a development car for Formula E racer
LMP1 a development car for Formula E racer
The dash is set to the most simple piece of information: percentage of charge remaining. We have 100 showing, but the car will only run about five laps of this short one-and-a-bit-mile circuit before it needs recharging. The batteries cannot be allowed to discharge fully either, so at 10 per cent remaining you pit.

The thrust is hard to comprehend at first, - actually, scratch that, summoning the courage to push the long-travel throttle pedal to the floor is more difficult. For the first loop I don't manage it, and still the car seemingly is picked up and flung into the next corner. Next time around I try full throttle - or whatever the new phrase for maximum everything will be on electric racers - and the effect numbs the brain. Because it is so instant. It just happens.

We think we understand the phrase 'throttle response' when in fact we've been messing about on the fringes for a century. You push your right foot, you end up 200 yards away from where you were and your head says "How did that happen?" I'm guilty of over-using the word, but it's extraordinary. Does it feel like three times the thrust of a Veyron pushing half the kerbweight? No, it doesn't. Because that would feel like a fighter jet doing aerobatics.

And it's problematic. Firstly, my brain just isn't calibrated to either deal or enjoy the immediacy - to channel a slightly crude analogy: the gratification just doesn't last long enough. I actually had to prepare my brain in advance to be ready to think about what was going to happen. The initial thrust is so great, think Veyron-and-some-more, that when it subsides after a few seconds into something less physical your brain and body are less than impressed. In reality, you are still accruing speed at an indecent rate. In complete silence. But that initial surge is so violent that what follows is less thrilling - much as it is in a heavily turbocharged, low-compression combustion engine once the boost has subsided.

Small battery pack means a 10-minute range
Small battery pack means a 10-minute range
I don't know how I feel about the silence. It certainly cements a fascinating contradiction between the serenity of the powertrain and the violence of the acceleration but boy did I miss the conventional race car soundtrack - about as much as I missed having a gearbox to fiddle with. The steering is assisted and light, the chassis has far too much grip for me to explore on an airfield and, as is always the case with electric cars, the lack of mechanical noises from the engine bay just leaves you with a rather apologetic collection of graunches and squeaks from the chassis. At least wearing a helmet and radio set reduces their collective volume.

The brakes are insanely good. You can hit them as hard as you can push the pedal from 140mph and they won't lock. Even on cold wet-weather tyres, in the dry.

And then the charge ran out, so we headed back to base. Now I expected this first experimental machine to have reduced range, but being able to run at full for just 10 minutes is still a little disappointing: it slightly undermines the crazy straight line performance. Battery technology is improving and Paul reckons that we're five years away from a car with this level of electric performance being able to run a full stint at Le Mans. Sebastian Vettel won his first Grand Prix five years ago.

I've now had time to digest what I experienced at Elvington, and I have mostly positive thoughts. In fact everything about the quantity of the performance on offer, and the way Drayson and his team have already managed to keep the weight low (admittedly by not having enough battery cell to allow much running) is very impressive.

How long until we see pure EVs at Le Mans?
How long until we see pure EVs at Le Mans?
What worries me is the silence - and here I disagree with Paul. We'll post a video in the coming weeks, in it Paul presents a passionate endorsement of this kind of silent, electric performance as the future for fast road cars. He is actively excited by the thought of owning a car that performs in this manner. I find the thought quite chilling. Being thwacked down the Queen's Highway at some ludicrous velocity, in near silence might appeal to me as a passenger in a limousine, but not as someone who loves driving. What Paul sees as a new technological dawn is, to me, potentially the end of emotional driving. I suppose I always knew that to be the case, it's just that this car presented me with a full realisation of the situation.

For the likes of us, the next 20 years are going to be about adding an emotional cloak to this electric revolution - of that I'm sure.

And I don't doubt that Paul Drayson will fulfil his dream and race an electric car at Le Mans.





   
   
Author
Discussion

exceed

Original Poster:

455 posts

207 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Good read, shame you're still not convinced. I think whilst this is the future, the battery capacity just isn't there to make it viable.

We need to get research done in making some kind of generator and battery combo but feel that we won't see anything revolutionary for at least 10 years.

That power sounds mad though, the problem being you have the power from nothing so it always feels flat after you reach the end of the gearing where in reality you're producing a shed load of power everywhere.

I think you got it right in saying you need to recalibrate what it is to drive a car like this, future of the supercar is the hybrid with an ICE providing the drama.

I look forward to the day where all passenger cars are electric and the only cars you can hear are the supercars charging down the streets.

Henry Fiddleton

1,597 posts

208 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
With out sounding "Top gear",

what has happened to Hydrogen cars?

Are electric cars still requiring a finite fossil fuel from the source?

I don't get it - I could be wrong, but I just don't get electric/green/renewable cars.

To me, they are missing the point and already out of date.

Kam

urquattro

755 posts

217 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
The area I find disconcerting is the need for "brain retrain" as an electric vehicle with this power is beyond my/our driving comprehension and experience. During many years of driving and at my age it is the combination of mechanical noises,smells, syncronisations of gear changes/box and braking that make it all worth the while of time and cost. That is the car package that is presently shrinking into a technological world of sensor and ecu controls.

It will be a sad day when the future generations miss all above fun and instead rely upon either artifical noises being introduced or are trained to ignore the distractions quoted above that we enjoy, having to turn the hi fi up in an old car to overcome the car's own soundtrack is a pleasant choice.
just my views of course.

kambites

71,741 posts

252 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Henry Fiddleton said:
what has happened to Hydrogen cars?
I think people realised they were a daft idea because we can't generate hydrogen efficiently enough.

hairykrishna

14,540 posts

234 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Henry Fiddleton said:
With out sounding "Top gear",

what has happened to Hydrogen cars?

Are electric cars still requiring a finite fossil fuel from the source?

I don't get it - I could be wrong, but I just don't get electric/green/renewable cars.

To me, they are missing the point and already out of date.

Kam
Commercial hydrogen supplies are produced by reforming fossil fuels. You use fossil fuels to make it, out of more fossil fuels. Fuel cells are also still enormously expensive and likely to remain so for the foreseeable future.

NorfolkSteve

101 posts

222 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Can't help thinking that comparing the performance of a 850hp LMP car with a Veyron, as an example of the relative performance of electric and IC engined cars is a bit flawed.

Why not compare with an 850hp IC engined LMP car? (without restricters this output would be easily achievable by current LMP1's)

I suspect that with appropriate launch control software the experience would be equally dramatic in terms of acceleration, so the only real difference would be in terms of sound.

Torque determines instantaneous acceleration, but power determines average acceleration over a finite speed range, and torque is simple power divided by speed, so with appropriate gearing the IC engined torque at the wheels will match that of the electic powertrain.

It is correctly argued that electric motors deliver maximum torque from zero rpm, whereas IC engines cannot, however, an IC engined compensates for a lack of low rpm torque by using the momentum of the rotating inertia at high rpm to provide the necessary torque from standstill, transfering to combustion force dominated torque as the vehicle speed is matched to engine speed - obivously a certain amount of clutch slip is required to allow this.

Fundamentally, both high power electric and high powered IC engined vehicles are traction limited, and this determines the available acceleration from rest, negating the high torque from zero rmp capability of the electric motor.

So we come back to the fact that both electric motors and IC engines can produce equally big amounts of power(850hp from an electric motor is nothing special, just as 850hp from a IC engine is nothing special either), but because petrol is a more weight efficient portable energy storage medium than batteries or fuel cells, the IC engined vehicle will be significantly lighter for a given range.

The electric car in this example lasted ~10 minutes, an average LMP1 stint is ~45 minutes. This and the lack of noise are the real differences in the driving experience.

Finally, we are no more likely to see 850hp, 900kg electric road cars than we are 850hp, 900kg IC engined road cars.



Edited by NorfolkSteve on Tuesday 29th October 11:47

Redgate

325 posts

178 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Is this really the future ?

Don't you think it is a bit paradoxical for manufacturers to shift their production to more electric cars when European countries (I don't know for the rest of the world) want to move away from nuclear-produced electricity? How then is the additional need for electricity going to be covered? Coal-burning plants? Wouldn't that be defeating the purpose of cleaner vehicles? Or are the manufacturers just sending the ball back in the government's court ?

Could someone please explain what the mid-term plan is if we're going to have more of these cars on the road?

Also, the efficiency of the cells is still disappointing today even if the progress made over the last two decades cannot be denied. But I am sure that if we give power-cell technology another century of development like we did for the combustion engine, they might be able to be levelled in terms of range and performance. Sadly, I will not be there to see it for myself.


Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Henry Fiddleton said:
what has happened to Hydrogen cars?

Are electric cars still requiring a finite fossil fuel from the source?
You might not have noticed that the UK is closing coal-fired power stations and starting to replace them with a new generation of nuclear. Plus there's a certain amount of hydro-electric, solar and wind generated electricity, but nuclear will be the base load in future, with gas for short-term peak loads.

kambites

71,741 posts

252 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
I think even much of the green lobby are tending towards fission for electricity generation now, at least until such a time as fusion becomes viable.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
I'll believe in commercial fusion generation when I see it. I might live long enough (maybe another 30 to 50 years max), but I have no great expectation.

sanctum

191 posts

206 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
I totally agree about the sound of the cars. The sound of rising and falling rpm is a very emotive experience, one used in the beats per minute of music to elicit an emotional response from the audience long before the internal combustion engine was around.

But is this just us old hands hankering for a time gone by? Much like the manual/auto debate? Will a future generation, raised on electric vehicles miss that old school sound track? I don't think they will. But I do believe they will love it when they experience it, just like we all love the lines of a Ferrari 250 GTO, gorgeous and emotional, but we won't see them in a modern car and most of us will never get our hands on one.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
It's much more like the replacement of big piston engines with jet engines in military and airline use. You just have to think of them as completely different things rather than substitutes.

I am very deeply wedded to the emotional appeal of internal combustion in many forms, but in the case of some modern mainstream commuting machinery, like a Merc C220D or BMW 320D running through an eight speed autobox at 50 mph up a busy dual carriageway, I really don't think I'd find electric power any less engaging. I would very much regret losing the right to operate internal combustion in classics and weekend cars.

Edited by Lowtimer on Tuesday 29th October 12:09

scubadude

2,619 posts

228 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Good read, can't wait for the video.


I do however get rather irritated by all the negatvity about "electric" vehicles and I think part of that is the coverall EV tag. We all now a "normal" car has fuel tank, engine and gearbox but EV's are so diverse.

Some are hybrids, some are 100% electric (battery & motor) others have electric propulsion but fuel cells or generators, there is a confusion of terminology.

As Harris says (and decades of trains prove) electric drive is great and efficent.

The problem is that batteries are really crap, chemistry says they will stay that way despite all the efforts being put in, Chemical fuel has massive advantages in terms of energy storage and replenishment.

When someone makes an electric car you can refuel in 5minutes with 500mile range then they will be on to something.


FWIW- I would gladly have an electric van and family car (even at todays range specs) if the price was right for the sake of saving the planet enough to justify a IC engined sportscar for the weekend :-)

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
NorfolkSteve said:
Can't help thinking that comparing the performance of a 850hp LMP car with a Veyron, as an example of the relative performance of electric and IC engined cars is a bit flawed.

Why not compare with an 850hp IC engined LMP car? (without restricters this output would be easily achievable by current LMP1's)
I think the reason Chris made the comparison that he did is that there are probably more people on here who've driven a Veyron than an 850hp LMP car, and his purpose was to convey how it feels. I know he's got hands-on Veyron experience: I don't know how much time he has in a current LMP car, if any. To talk with authenticity about how something like this feels it's only honest to compare the experience with things you've actually felt.

One could conduct an objective comparison by simply reporting the factual numbers, but what I want from reading Chris is his personal perspective, not just a regurgitation from a spreadsheet.

Craiglamuffin

360 posts

211 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Why do so many electric cars have covers over the rear wheels? If it's just good aero sense, surely we'd see it done on every supercar.

RTH

1,059 posts

243 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
The range, the weight and the enormous cost of the batteries at present means this is not the foreseeable future in anything other than fixed distance daily delivery vehicles - much the same conclusion reached 100 years ago.

Time would be better spent on developing ultralight 100mpg combustion cars and as Audi are currently doing developing commercially viable synthetic road fuels made from GM modified Algae ,seawater, pure CO2 and extreme heat and sun in their test plant in New Mexico.
This is capable of making a liguid fuel for transport in a virtuous circle at the same time capturing and using all the CO2 currently emitted by all the power stations cement works and steelworks on the planet

There was a big 6 page article & photos of the plant which has the look of an oil refinery in "Racecar Engineering" magazine a couple of months ago

This tells you about what is currently going on - It shows a great deal more hope than just recharging batteries from the mains

http://www.autofocus.ca/how-to/green-guide/audis-g...



Edited by RTH on Tuesday 29th October 12:32

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Craiglamuffin said:
Why do so many electric cars have covers over the rear wheels? If it's just good aero sense, surely we'd see it done on every supercar.
It _is_ good aero sense but it's not currently regarded as good fashion sense, in which the display of oversized wheels and brake bling are de rigeur. As the massive rimz tendency shows us, engineering considerations take a firm second place to marketing.

Smitters

4,419 posts

188 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
I have to be honest, and I feel I might be in a very small minority here, but I see the "silent" soundtrack as an opportunity really.

I love the sound of cars and so, in a real world situation, I am immensely frustrated that my bog standard 350Z sounds good from the outside, but Nissan have somehow made a car that lets in an abundance of road noise, tyre slap, dirt and water hitting the arch liners, but very little exhaust. And it's there too. Car-friends have commented positively.

So, what of simulated engine noises? I don't mean some tin-can poor representation either. I mean a proper, genuine, well thought through, matched soundtrack, so as you speed up, revs rise precisely in synch? And so on any given day you could waft to work in silence listening to R4, then pop out for a lunchtime blast with an Audi 5 cylinder accompaniment, and drive home into the sunset with a sublime Italian V12. Anything done poorly is poor, but done well, I personally think I'd quite like it.

Mark Wibble

211 posts

255 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
^ what sanctum and Lowtimer say- driving will become what it's going to become, we at the point of change will compare pre- and post- but once that change has been made on a day-to-day basis we'll all just get used to it.

The one thing that mankind will ALWAYS need is electricity, so it's safe to say electric cars are the future in one way or another... the question is when. Technology for turning electricty into motion is there, but as also said above, it's the energy storage medium that's the unkown right now.

Cars like this, and the other demonstrator and niche production ones about, are essential to move industry onwards- developing either new battery or energy cell technology will only happen if there's a market and cars like this help create that. Don't get absorbed in the bottom line of these specific cars, right now they're just the tip of the EV technology iceberg!

There are other pionering companies out there too- I worked for a while at Protean Electric http://www.proteanelectric.com/en/ - at heart a British engineering company (not quite that simple any more though!), hopefully they'll be ramping up for production soon with their 1000Nm, in-wheel electric motor, as well as pauper-spec motors for family hatches...

RenesisEvo

3,828 posts

250 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
Craiglamuffin said:
Why do so many electric cars have covers over the rear wheels? If it's just good aero sense, surely we'd see it done on every supercar.
It _is_ good aero sense but it's not currently regarded as good fashion sense, in which the display of oversized wheels and brake bling are de rigeur. As the massive rimz tendency shows us, engineering considerations take a firm second place to marketing.
Don't forget that covers over the wheels have to be removed to get the wheel off - a pain for pit-stops, less so for road cars. Also, those covers will make braking cooling a little more difficult, as you generally pass air out through the spokes of the wheel. With a cover there may not be enough extraction to maintain a good rate of flow across the rear brakes.