RE: The M440i GC is practical. Fact | PH Footnote
RE: The M440i GC is practical. Fact | PH Footnote
Tuesday 25th January 2022

The M440i GC is practical. Fact | PH Footnote

Think four-door coupes are easy on the eye, but no match for a fast wagon? Think again...



Manufacturers, especially those from Der Vaterland, have become very adept at creating new markets to spin more profit. This has led to a swathe of new variants that, the day before they were launched, we had no idea we needed. The problem, though, is we're often still scratching our heads trying to understand what the benefit is the day after, and the days after that. Coupé SUVs are the greatest example of this. For me, they are the most ridiculous machines.

We're in a world in which going green has become a pathological pursuit. Underpinning the obsessiveness is a legitimate need - to reduce our global CO2 output. Few would dispute this is a good thing. Yet at the same time, the great buying public has been convinced - by car marketeers mainly - that they should drive nothing but SUVs, which, funnily enough, just happen to provide higher profit margins.

As anyone who knows anything about anything will tell you, SUVs are bigger and heavier than the hatchbacks and estates we used to buy. And if you've also studied GCSE physics, you'll know this means expending more energy to move them. So in a world where the zeitgeist is to consume less, we're swapping to higher consumption, more polluting cars. Marvellous. And on top of that, they are taller and less stable through bends and, because of their added weight and typically bigger wheels, don't ride as well as the traditional stuff either.


PHers have been saying this stuff for years, of course. Yet there is an upside: better practicality. Generally speaking, an SUVs higher roofline adds a bit more headroom and a deeper boot. Which is fine. Until you make a coupé version, which has less rear headroom and a smaller boot, therefore negating the only tangible benefit of buying a SUV. And the intangible, too. Coupés are meant to be cooler and better-looking cars, but every time I see a BMW X6 on the road, I look at the person behind the wheel and wonder why they bought a preposterous car that looks like an oversized shoe.

Four-door coupés are another questionable genre. What's the point of buying a marginally more practical, four-door version of an impractical two-door car, which is itself a spin-off of a far more practical alternative? Still with me at the back? If not, then in short: why buy a BMW M440i Gran Coupé when, if you need the practicality to transport an armchair, you can buy an M340i Touring instead. There, simple.

Except it isn't. Granted, it's not often you pop round to see a friend for a cup of tea and leave with the armchair you were sat on, but it does happen. I know it does, because it happened to me just the other day. My mate was getting rid of an old armchair and asked whether I knew anyone who would like it. "Yes," I said, "me." But the caveat was he needed shot of it ASAP, and I was in a BMW M440i Gran Coupé. Obviously, it's not going to fit in that.


Still, for the sake of trying I got out the tape measure and took down the chair's vital statistics, then measured them against the M440i's internal dimensions with its seats down. To my surprise, this armchair-shaped square peg did, indeed, appear to fit in this BMW-coupé-shaped hole. Easily, as it turned out. I could've also relieved him of a dozen scatter cushions (and very nearly did) but, apparently they weren't part of the offer. Shame.

All of which got me thinking. The M440i does actually tick a lot of boxes and offers something more. I wouldn't have managed to get that armchair in a two-door M440i, and I sure as hell wouldn't have got it in an M340i saloon. It would've fitted in a Touring, true - yet while that's a handsome car, it's not as handsome as the Gran Coupé, is it? Not to my mind it isn't. We can argue about the Gran Coupé's design details (yes, its flary nostrils being the most obvious) but the overall shape is very lovely. I found myself admiring it a lot.

I also admire how it drives, which, as Matt Bird described in his recent review, is very well indeed. It's fast, agile and comfortable. And on top of that, it's beautifully made and comes with very easy access to the back seats. Plus, because it's a sleek coupé, it slips through the air like a needle, producing fewer CO2s than a bulky SUV. It's a win, win, win. So I am removing four-door coupés from the 'of questionable value' additions to the automotive world, but feel free to disagree in the comments. I have an inkling that one or two of you will.


Author
Discussion

Turbobanana

Original Poster:

8,586 posts

232 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Pah, lightweight! I once got an IKEA double futon, complete with mattress, in a 3 door Saab 900 turbo.

Mind you, I also failed to get a B&Q flat pack shed in a Mitsubishi L300, necessitating the circumcision of 2 inches off the side panels (of the shed, silly) in the car park using a hastily purchased saw.

Slowlygettingit

951 posts

72 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Very interesting car park you are in

MuscleSedan

1,614 posts

206 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Didn't realize hatchbacks are a new thing ?

JAMSXR

1,854 posts

78 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Not sure it would have fitted without the missing legs wink

I now won’t be able to look at an X6 without seeing an ugly shoe - I’ve always found them odd.


Miserablegit

4,449 posts

140 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Slowlygettingit said:
Very interesting car park you are in
Gran Coupes are not good looking - please can you move the BMW out of the shot so we can see more of the Ferrari (400?) next to you, the evora in the corner and the other interesting stuff.

Baldchap

9,639 posts

123 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Slowlygettingit said:
Very interesting car park you are in
Louses, Jags, Ferraris... Shame the article is about putting something in the boot of a poxy 4 series! laugh

TdM-GTV

349 posts

248 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Was thinking the same thing. Can you do an article on the background please?

Miserablegit

4,449 posts

140 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Is this peak PH fail? I mean there’s a car park full of stuff and we’re reading an article about shoving a chair in a BMW.

I’m as bad as the rest of you for reading the article…

Macron

13,545 posts

197 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
It really does look like every designer was told "draw your bit, but absolutely definitely DO NOT talk to any of the other designers at all".

TypeRTim

725 posts

125 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I think the 4 door coupé is actually, probably the only sensible niche to come out of this whole nonsense...providing it's a liftback design.

The A5 & A7 Sportback, the 4 series GC and the Kia Stinger are the only ones that fit the bill there (iirc). The 6 series GC still has a saloon style boot, as does the Merc CLA & CLS (which, going by merc's change in naming conventions should be called the CLE now??)

I considered a 4GC as a replacement for my Mondeo hatch, but the boot was quite a chunk smaller and we've filled the Mondy's boot several times!

ghost83

5,665 posts

221 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I got a 2 seater settee into my golf gti!

Anyways wouldn’t have one, one of the neighbours had his 440 gc (previous model) taken at gunpoint just before Xmas!

Broke in his house at 3am all armed

ducnick

2,295 posts

274 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Next week can we have a feature on putting the missing chair legs in the Ferrari f40 and the cushions in the 400i please?

Bill

58,948 posts

286 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Miserablegit said:
Is this peak PH fail? I mean there’s a car park full of stuff and we’re reading an article about shoving a chair in a BMW.

I’m as bad as the rest of you for reading the article…
And it's not even a nice chair! hehe

FamousPheasant

771 posts

147 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Picked up a previous gen 435iGC in December and chose it primarily for the liftback. Far easier to load bigger items compared to a conventional saloon - though the sloping roofline does make putting a little one in the back a little more challenging without banging their head.

It's somewhat sad to say, but I'm finding the front end of these somewhat less challenging than I did originally, although I still much prefer the F series looks.

And as others have said, that's one interesting car park.

Turbobanana

Original Poster:

8,586 posts

232 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Macron said:
It really does look like every designer was told "draw your bit, but absolutely definitely DO NOT talk to any of the other designers at all".
Designed by a committee that never met?

jimmsy

1,055 posts

158 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Just a casual F40 in the background...

aarondbs

883 posts

177 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
MuscleSedan said:
Didn't realize hatchbacks are a new thing ?
Exactly what I was thinking. Its a hatchback not a new bloody niche!! No different to a other family car hatchbacks like the old Cavalier, Renault Laguna, Ford Sierra etc.

Why didn't Ford and Vauxhall call theirs a Gran Coupe I wonder.... because you'd have sounded like a right prat saying that down the pub.... then as now

2Btoo

3,838 posts

234 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Bill said:
Miserablegit said:
Is this peak PH fail? I mean there’s a car park full of stuff and we’re reading an article about shoving a chair in a BMW.

I’m as bad as the rest of you for reading the article…
And it's not even a nice chair! hehe
Miserablegit is on the money - there are PLENTY more interesting things in that car park than a chair and a hatchback.

(Although it looks like quite a nice chair to me!)

Groaver

85 posts

64 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
aarondbs said:
Exactly what I was thinking. Its a hatchback not a new bloody niche!! No different to a other family car hatchbacks like the old Cavalier, Renault Laguna, Ford Sierra etc.

Why didn't Ford and Vauxhall call theirs a Gran Coupe I wonder.... because you'd have sounded like a right prat saying that down the pub.... then as now
Indeed, hatchbacks for those who cannot bring themselves to admit that is what they drive.

FlukePlay

1,202 posts

176 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
JAMSXR said:
Not sure it would have fitted without the missing legs wink

I now won’t be able to look at an X6 without seeing an ugly shoe - I’ve always found them odd.
Absolutely...there's a bit of cheating going on here.

Secondly, this seems like yet another PH/BMW love-in...trying to get passed the looks and performance aspect we'll now try to pitch this one on practicality.